Introduction
Method
Results
Search Results
Characteristics of Current EMA Applications in Studying Youth Psychopathology
Authors | Patient group | Comparison group(s) | EMA details | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N | Age range | DSM diagnosis | N | Description | Format | Contingency | Completed by | Observations/day | Days | Observations | Compliance1 | Outcome variable(s) | |
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder | |||||||||||||
Babinski and Welkie [27] | 13 | 12–16 | ADHD-only, ADHD-comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder | – | – | Mobile phone app | Signal | Parent and child | 2–4 | 7 | 18 | 91% (parent) and 84% (child) | Negative emotion |
Factor et al. [33] | 42 | 8–12 | ADHD-only, ADHD-comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder | 22 | Healthy controls | PDA | Time | Parent and child | 3 | 28 | 84 | 76% (parent) | Affect |
Fogleman et al. [42] | 59 | 8–12 | ADHD | 45 | Community sample | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 28 | 84 | 83% | Affect |
Leaberry et al. [34] | 58 | 8–12 | ADHD-only, ADHD-comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder | – | – | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 28 | 84 | 81% | Affect |
Rosen and Factor [25] | 27 | 8–11 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | – | – | PDA | Time | Parent and child | 3 | 28 | 84 | 85% (parent) and 77% (child) | Affect |
Rosen et al. [26] | 11 | 8–11 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | – | – | PDA | Time | Parent and child | 3 | 28 | 84 | 87% (parent) and 77% (child) | Affect |
Rosen et al. [35] | 56 | 8–12 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | 46 | Community sample | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 28 | 84 | 82% | Affect |
Slaughter et al. [36] | 53 | 8–13 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | 43 | Community sample | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 28 | 84 | Unclear | Affect |
Walerius et al. [37] | 47 | 8–12 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | 37 | Community sample | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 4–10 | 12–31 | 85% | Affect |
Walerius et al. [38] | 42 | 8–12 | ADHD (incl. comorbid behavioral, mood or ANX disorder) | 32 | Com–munity sample | PDA | Time | Parent | 3 | 28 | 84 | 89% | Affect, functional impairment |
Whalen et al. [63] | 51 | 8–12 | ADHD | 58 | Healthy controls | PDA | Time | Mother | 2 | 7 | 14 | 99% | Mood, behavior |
Whalen et al. [40] | 51 | 8–12 | ADHD | 58 | Healthy controls | PDA | Signal | Mother and Child | Every 30 min in monitoring intervals | 7 | Unclear | 93–94% (mother) and 91–94% (child) | Anger, stress, good mood |
Whalen et al. [39] | 27 | 7–12 | ADHD | 25 | Healthy controls | PDA | Signal | Mother and Child | Every 30 min in monitoring intervals | 7 | Unclear | 91–92% (mother) and 89–90% (child) | Behaviors, context, mood, interaction quality |
Whalen et al. [32] | 27 | 7–12 | ADHD | 25 | Healthy controls | PDA | Signal + time | Mother and Child | Every 30 min in monitoring intervals + mothers 2/day | 7 | Unclear | 91–92% (mother) and 89–90% (child) | Behaviors, context, mood, interaction quality, parenting |
Whalen et al. [41] | 51 | 8–12 | ADHD | 58 | Healthy controls | PDA | Signal | Mother and Child | Every 30 min in monitoring intervals | 7 | Unclear | 93–94% (mother) and 91–94% (child) | Behaviors, mood, context |
Autism spectrum disorders | |||||||||||||
Chen et al. [23] | 6 | 8–12 | HFASD | – | – | iPod Touch app | Signal | Child | 7 | 7 | 49 | 57% | Affect, social context, quality of experiences |
Cordier et al. [44] | 6 | 8–12 | HFASD | – | – | iPod Touch app | Signal | Child | 7 | 7 | 49 | 57% | Affect, social context, quality of experiences |
Khor et al. [22] | 31 | 12–18 | HFASD | – | – | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | 4 (1 on the final day) | 14 | 53 | 62% | Stress |
Khor et al. [43] | 31 | 12–18 | HFASD | – | – | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | 4 | 14 | 53 | 62% | Stress |
Kovac et al. [24] | 19 | 9–19 | HFASD | 20 | Healthy controls | Smartphone or computer web survey | Signal | Child | 1–2 | 4 | 6 | 85–93% | Affect, behavioral and social context |
Mood disorders and anxiety disorders | |||||||||||||
Allen et al. [29] | 96 | 4–15 | Separation anxiety (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 92 | Healthy controls and other ANX | Diary | Event | Mother | 1 or more | 8 | 8 or more | 90% (overview) and 68% (situation sheets) | Separations, anxiety, thoughts, behaviors, parental reactions |
Allen et al. [30] | 58 | 7–14 | Separation anxiety (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 67 | Healthy controls and other ANX | Diary | Event | Child | 1 or more | 8 | 8 or more | 89% (overview) and 71% (situation sheets) | Separations, anxiety, thoughts, behaviors, parental reactions |
Allen et al. [52] | 106 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, externalizing disorder) | – | – | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | 51% of calls included | Perceived control, emotional reactivity, emotion regulation |
Axelson et al. [28] | 16 | 10–17 | MDD, BD, lifetime GAD/MDD | 5 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 20 | 60 | 90% | Affect, behavior, motivation, social context |
Beidel et al. [50] | 50 | 7–13 | Social anxiety (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 22 | Healthy controls | Diary | Event | Child | 1 or more | 14 | 14 or more | 86% | Socially distressing events, coping behavior |
Butterfield et al. [57] | 87 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 33 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | Unclear | Distressing events, coping behavior |
Cousins et al. [19] | 65 | 8–16 | MDD, ANX, comorbid MDD and ANX | 29 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 8 | 24 | 92% | Affect, sleep |
Doane et al. [21] | 114 | 16–18 | Past or recent MDD or ANX, comorbid MDD and ANX | 186 | Healthy controls | Digital watch + diary, vial | Signal + time | Child | 6 | 3 | 18 | Unclear | Affect, cortisol (saliva sample into vial) |
Forbes et al. [49] | 15 | 8–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX) | 28 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 4 | 12 | 95% | Affect |
Forbes et al. [20] | 66 | 8–16 | MDD, ANX, comorbid MDD and ANX | – | – | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 20 | 60 | 89% | Affect, social context |
Mor et al. [18] | 47 | 16.9 (M) | MDD, ANX, comorbid MDD and ANX | 231 | Healthy and other DSM controls | Digital watch and diary | Signal + time | Child | 6 | 3 | 18 | 91% | Affect, stress, self–focus |
Morgan et al. [54] | 130 | 9–14 | Social anxiety, ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 46 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 25 | 70 | 82% (social anxiety) and 77% (ANX) –78% | Affect, social context |
Price et al. [56] | 78 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 20 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | 56% of calls included | Affect, emotion regulation |
Primack et al. [45] | 46 | 7–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX) | 60 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 20 | 60 | 89% | Media exposure |
Silk et al. [48] | 20 | 8–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX) | 22 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 4 | 12 | Unclear | Affect |
Silk et al. [64] | 47 | 7–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX) | 32 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 20 | 60 | 92% | Affect, behavior, social context |
Silk et al. [66] | 133 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | – | – | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 25 | 70 | 89% | Affect |
Smith et al. [55] | 37 | 8–18 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | 20 | Healthy controls | Mobile phone app | Time | Child | 3 | 7 | 21 | 76% | Affect, interactions with peers |
Stone et al. [53] | 117 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, externalizing disorder) | – | – | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | 29% of calls included | Affect, social context, emotion regulation |
Tan et al. [51] | 65 | 9–13 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, externalizing disorder) | 65 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | 93%–91% | Affect, emotion regulation |
Teixeira and Freire [65] | 1 | 14 | MDD | – | – | Electronic device + diary | Signal | Child | 8 | 21 | 168 | 65% | Mood, self–satisfaction, context |
Wallace et al. [67] | 114 | 9–14 | ANX (incl. comorbid ANX, MDD, externalizing disorder) | – | – | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 5 | 14 | 92% | Affect, social context, events, sleep |
Waller et al. [46] | 29 | 11–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX, externalizing disorder) | 31 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 3 | 15 | 42 | 83% | Social context, problem talk |
Whalen et al. [47] | 30 | 7–17 | MDD (incl. comorbid ANX, externalizing disorder) | 23 | Healthy controls | Phone call | Signal | Child | 2–4 | 20 | 60 | Unclear | Affect, caffeine consumption, sleep |
Eating disorders | |||||||||||||
Fürtjes et al. [62] | 33 | 12–19 | Anorexia nervosa (incl. comorbid MDD, ANX) | – | – | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | 6 | 28 | 168 | 82% | Rumination, affect |
Kolar et al. [58] | 20 | 12–19 | Anorexia nervosa (incl. comorbid MDD, ANX, BD) | 20 | Healthy controls | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | Every full hour | 2 | 25–26 (mean) | 79%–82% | Aversive tension |
Kolar et al. [59] | 20 | 12–19 | Anorexia nervosa (incl. comorbid MDD, ANX, BD) | 20 | Healthy controls | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | Every full hour | 2 | 25–26 (mean) | 79%–82% | Emotion identification, aversive tension |
Seidel et al. [60] | 37 | 12–28 | Anorexia nervosa (incl. comorbid MDD, ANX) | 33 | Healthy controls | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | 6 | 14 | 84 | 84%–76% | Rumination, affect |
Seidel et al. [61] | 35 | 12–29 | Anorexia nervosa (incl. comorbid MDD, ANX) | 35 | Healthy controls | Mobile phone app | Signal | Child | 6 | 14 | 84 | 84%–76% | Rumination, affect |
Psychosis | |||||||||||||
Smelror et al. [31] | 3 | 17.7 (M) | Early onset psychosis | – | – | iPod touch app | Signal + event | Child | 5 | 7 | 35 | 74% | Auditory verbal hallucinations |