Introduction
Methods
Search Strategy
Databases | Search strategy 16-11-2020 |
---|---|
PUBMED | |
#1 | (ASD OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR Rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative) |
#2 | "occupational therapy" |
#3 | (app OR apps OR application) OR (tablet OR ipad) OR mobile OR “virtual reality” OR (computer OR laptop) OR technology OR device OR internet OR ("video game" OR software) |
#1 AND #2 AND #3 | |
SCOPUS | |
ALL ( ( asd OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative)) | |
ALL ( "occupational therapy") | |
ALL ( ( app OR apps OR application) OR ( tablet OR ipad) OR mobile OR "virtual reality" OR ( computer OR laptop) OR technology OR device OR internet OR ( "video game" OR software)) | |
( TITLE-ABS-KEY ( asd OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative) AND ALL ( "occupational therapy") AND ALL ( app OR apps OR application OR tablet OR ipad OR mobile OR "virtual reality" OR computer OR laptop OR technology OR device OR internet OR "video game" OR software)) | |
Web of science | |
((ASD OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative)) | |
("occupational therapy") | |
((app OR apps OR application) OR (tablet OR ipad) OR mobile OR “virtual reality” OR (computer OR laptop) OR technology OR device OR internet OR ("video game" OR software)) | |
((ASD OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative)) AND #2 ("occupational therapy") AND #3 ((app OR apps OR application) OR (tablet OR ipad) OR mobile OR “virtual reality” OR (computer OR laptop) OR technology OR device OR internet OR ("video game" OR software)) | |
EMBASE | |
#1 | 'asd'/exp OR asd OR 'autism'/exp OR autism OR autistic OR asperger OR rett OR pervasive OR disintegrative |
#2 | 'occupational therapy' |
#3 | app OR apps OR application OR tablet OR ipad OR mobile OR 'virtual reality' OR computer OR laptop OR technology OR device OR internet OR 'video game' OR software |
#1 AND #2 AND #3 |
Review Criteria
Study Selection
Data Extraction and Synthesis
Author, year | Study design | Sample, country | Participants | Intervention/comparator | Evaluation | Study outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Josman et al. (2008) | Pilot | 12, Israel Loss of follow-up n = 0 | IG: 3 boys and 1 girl with ASD CG: 5 boys and 1 girl with TD Age: 8–16 years | Street-crossing desktop virtual environment/ Street-crossing desktop virtual environment | Pre- and post- evaluation | Pedestrian behavior and safety when crossing the street assessed with the PSS |
Cosper et al. (2009) | Quasi | 12, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 10 boys and 2 girls with ASD and ADHD or CDD Age: 6–13 years | Computer-based noninvasive technology (Interactive Metronome)/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation | Motor control and coordination assessed with the BOT-2 Brief Sustained attention assessed with the GDS |
Lo et al. (2009) | Pilot | 3, Taiwan Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 3 boys with ASD and 1 UND Age: 4–7 years | Interactive game: Racing Game Playful Tray and Interactive game: Playful Toothbrush/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation | Duration of meals and mealtime behavior assessed with video recordings Efficiency and number of brushings assessed with a plaque-revealing dye and video recordings |
Gentry et al. (2010) | Quasi | 22, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 18 boys and 4 girls with ASD Age: 14–18 years | Training intervention in the use of a PDA as a task management tool/NA | Pre- and post-evaluation | Occupational performance assessed with the COPM PDA use assessed with the FATCAT |
Wuang et al. (2010) | Quasi | 60, Taiwan Loss of follow-up n = 11 | 47 boys and 13 girls with ASD Age: 6–10 years | Simulated Developmental Horse-Riding Program + OT/OT | Pre-, 22-week and post- evaluation | Motor function assessed with the BOT-2 Sensory integration assessed with the TSIF |
Palsbo and Hood-Szivek (2012) | Pilot | 18, United States Loss of follow-up n = 2 | 14 boys and 4 girls with ASD, ADHD, PDD, ID, APD or UN Age: 5–11 years | Robotic-guided three-dimensional repetitive fine motion training/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation | Motor control assessed with the VMI Handwriting skills assessed with the THS–R, the Print Tool and the ETCH |
Lee et al. (2013) | nRCT | 2, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 2 boys with ASD Age: 4–5 years | Computer-based intervention program for enhancing visual perceptual skills/NA | Pre- and post-evaluation | Visual perception assessed with the DTVP-2 |
Janeslätt et al. (2014) | RCT | 47, Sweden Loss of follow-up n = 10 | 25 boys and 12 girls with ADHD, ASD, CP, ID or SB Age: 6–11 years | Compensatory intervention based on the use of time management aids/ Usual therapy + Compensatory intervention based on the use of time management aids | Pre- and post-evaluation | Time management skills assessed with the KaTid-Child and the Time-Parent scale |
Lorah et al. (2014) | Case | 3, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 2 boys and 1 girl with ASD and CH Age: 4–6 years | Use of the iPad™ and application Proloqu2Go as a speech generating device/NA | Pre- and post-evaluation | Speech generation and sentence discrimination assessed with the Proloquo2Go trial scores |
Campbell et al. (2015) | nRCT | 3, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 2 boys and 1 girl with ASD Age: 17–19 years | Video modeling on a handheld device to teach hand washing (Sylvania HD Video Mp4 Player)/NA | Pre- and post-evaluation | Occupational performance assessed with a video task analysis |
Chen et al. (2015) | Case | 3, Taiwan Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 3 adolescents with ASD (sex NS) Age:10–13 years | Augmented reality technology/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation | Emotion recognition assessed with video stories questions |
Meister and Salls (2015) | Pilot | 9, United States Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 8 boys y 1 girl with ASD Age: 7.5–13.5 years | Point-of-view video modeling as an intervention strategy to improve self-help skills using iPad/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation | ADLs assessed with the COSA |
Gal et al. (2016) | Quasi | 14, Israel Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 14 boys with ASD Age: 8–12 years | StoryTable application implemented through the Diamond Touch multitouch tabletop/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation and 3-week follow up | Social interaction assessed with the FOS |
Henning et al. (2016) | Pilot | 10, Australia Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 5 boys with ASD and 3 boys and 2 girls with TD Age: 4–11 years | Play-based intervention, including therapists, peers, parents and video modeling/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation and 2-month follow-up | Play skills assessed with the ToP Social and behavioral problems assessed with the CCBRS-P |
Ikuta et al. (2016) | Pilot | 21, Japan Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 16 boys and 5 girls with ASD Age: 4–16 years | Control period followed by Earmuffs and finally Headphones/Control period followed by Headphones and finally Earmuffs | Pre- and post- evaluation | Effectiveness of the intervention assessed with the GAS |
Lee et al. (2016) | Quasi | 6, Taiwan Loss of follow-up n = 0 | 4 boys and 2 girls with ASD Age: 12–15 years | Applied Cliplets‑based half‑dynamic videos as intervention/NA | Pre- and post- evaluation and 1-month follow-up | Emotion recognition assessed with the analysis of facial expressions on video |
Hatfield et al. (2017) | nRCT | 94, Australia Loss of follow-up n = 6 | IG: 39 boys and 10 girls with ASD CG: 33 boys and 12 girls with ASD Age: 12–18 years | Better Outcomes & Successful Transitions for Autism (BOOST-A™): online/NA transition planning program/Regular transition planning practice | Pre- and post- evaluation | Self-Determination assesses with the AIR |
Hochhauser et al. (2018) | RCT | 61, Israel Loss of follow-up n = 10 | IG: 32 boys and 4 girls with ASD CG: 2 girls and 23 boys with ASD Age: 12–18 years | Computer application that uses video modeling and video self-modeling: CONTACT/No intervention | Pre- and post- evaluation and 1-month follow-up | Negotiation attitudes and behaviors assessed with the FFNS Conflict management assessed with The ConflicTalk questionnaire |
Lamash and Josman (2021) | nRCT | 56, Israel Loss of follow-up n = 0 | IG: 29 boys and 4 girls with ASD CG: 17 boys and 6 girls with ASD Age: 11–19 years | Virtual supermarket (VAPs) + metacognitive intervention/Standard intervention to promote shopping | Pre- and post- evaluation | Cognitive functions assessed with the WebNeuro® software Shopping in the community assessed with the TOGSS |
Parsons et al. (2019) | RCT | 59, Australia Loss of follow-up n = 12 | IG: 25 boys and 5 girls with ASD CG: 23 boys and 6 girls with ASD Age: 2–6 years | iPad application: The Therapeutic Outcomes by You application (TOBY app)/Usual therapy and iPad without the TOBY app installed | Pre- and post- evaluation and 6-month follow-up | Cognitive function assessed with the MSEL Social imitation assessed with the CSBS |
Author, year | Participants and diagnosis | NT | Interventions | Duration (w) | Sessions | Intervention managers | Main results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Josman et al. (2008) | 12, ASD and TD | Computer | IG: Street-crossing desktop virtual environment (VE). 9 stages. The VE was designed as a typical four-lane divided street, had two types of cross walks, one with a pedestrian island and one with a traffic light CG: Same as IG | NS | IG: One- to two-weekly 10-to 30-min sessions CG: one 45-min session | OTs | Low number of sessions to successfully complete the 9 stages needed in IG vs CG (p < 0.01) Higher task performance in post- vs pre- IG scores (p < 0.01) |
Cosper et al. (2009) | 12, ADHD, CDD and ASD | Computer | Interactive Metronome. Non-invasive PC-based technique to practice the timing and rhythmicity of various movement combinations of the hands and feet in response to auditory cues | 15 | One-weekly 1-h sessions | OTs | Increase in complex visual choice reaction time (p < 0.05), in visuomotor control (p = 0.02), in UL balance and coordination (p = 0.06) and in UL speed (p = 0.07), in post-vs pre- intervention |
Lo et al. (2009) | 4, ASD and UN | Computer | Racing Game tray. Interactive game over a weight-sensitive tray surface. The tray surface recognizes and follows the child's natural eating actions in real time. When the child completes the meal, the game ends. Playful Toothbrush. Interactive game into a brushing activity. The game starts with a virtual image of uncleaned teeth, when the child finishes cleaning all his or her teeth, the virtual teeth become completely white and an applause sound plays | 4 | One-daily session. Duration NS | OTs | 33% reduction in meal duration and 20% reduction in non-food related behaviors in post-vs pre- intervention Increase in cleaning effect (from 32 to 67%.) and in the average number of brushing strokes (from 190 to 248) in post-vs pre- intervention |
Gentry et al. (2010) | 22, ASD | Another NT (PDA) | Software Palm® Desktop was used onto the computer where calendar entries and alarms are entered and transferred to the PDA via USB. They added medication schedules, homework, household chores and other calendar items to the PDA, adding a reminder alarm to each | 6 | One-weekly 60- to 90- min sessions | OTs | Increase in performance and satisfaction with performance of everyday life tasks (p < 0.001) in post-vs pre- intervention |
Wuang et al. (2010) | 60, ASD | Another NT (Simulated program) | Simulated Developmental Horse-Riding Program. Joba® is an exercise equipment that simulates the movements during real horseback riding, for the improvement of motor and sensory integration functions. A intervention plan was especially designed for each child that incorporated activities compatible with the child’s interest and current motor function | 40 | Two-weekly 1-h sessions | OTs | Increase in motor function (p < 0.0001) and sensory integration (p < 0.0001) in post- vs pre- intervention |
Palsbo and Hood-Szivek (2012) | 18, ASD, ADHD, PDD, ID, APD, CP and UN | Another NT (Robot) | Robotic-guided three-dimensional repetitive fine motion training to improve handwriting. My Scrivener haptic interface device. During sessions 10-min review of the letters and numbers, 10 min with robot-assisted glyph formation and 10 min on the workbook lesson were offered | 4–6 | Three- to five-weekly 30-min sessions | OTs and research professor | Improvement in motor control percentiles (from 29 to 42, p < 0.10) in post- vs pre- intervention Improvement in consistency of glyph formation in 10 children (p < 0.10) in post- vs pre- intervention |
Lee et al. (2013) | 2, ASD | Computer | Concepts on the Move-Basic and Concepts on the Move 2-Advanced software. to improve visual-perceptual skills. The participants chose three of the nine items for each of the five categories, such as colors, sizes or shapes, yielding 15 permutations per session | 6 | Two-weekly 30-min sessions | OTs | Improvement in motor-reduced visual-perceptual skills in post- vs pre- intervention. (p value NS) |
Janeslätt et al. (2014) | 47, ADDH, ASD, CP, ID and SB | Another NT (PDA) | IG: Received at least one-time aids for daily time management, based on devices that make the time passing visible CG: Received intervention as usual during their waiting-list time. During intervention they received the same intervention as IG | NS | Two- to five weekly 1- to 2-h sessions | OTs and special educator | Increase in time processing ability (p < 0.05).in IG vs CG |
Lorah et al. (2014) | 3, ASD | iPad™ | Proloqu2Go app as a speech generating device for the acquisition of a tact (labeling) repertoire. A small plastic toy dog, a small ball, a standard size crayon and a children's book were used as stimuli during training | NS | One-daily sessions. Duration NS | OTs | Improvement in the acquisition of a tact repertoire and in the discrimination between the acquired sentence frames (p value NS) |
Campbell et al. (2015) | 3, ASD and PDD | Computer | Video modeling intervention using a handheld device (Sylvania HD Video Mp4 Player) to teach hand washing. The video was elaborated by 13-step task analysis | 4 | NS | OTs | Increased levels of handwashing skill and independence in post- vs pre- intervention (p value NS) |
Chen et al. (2015) | 3, ASD | Computer | Training emotional judgments and social skills through 3D Augmented Reality Self-Facial Modeling system. Participants read the scenario script and looked at the corresponding illustrations on the monitor screen to select one of the six basic emotional masks to wear | 6 | One-weekly 1-h sessions | OTs | Improvement in emotional and expression recognition in post- vs pre- intervention (p < 0.05) |
Meister and Salls (2015) | 8, ASD | iPad™ | Video intervention to improve self-help skills. A video was created demonstrating each step of the target activity, and included simple step-by-step verbal directions. The iMovie and VideoTote applications were used | 6 | Two-weekly 10-to 25- min sessions | OTs | Improvement of 50.5% in post- vs pre- intervention (p value NS) |
Gal et al. (2016) | 14, ASD | Computer | StoryTable (ST) application. Intervention based on a collaborative narrative tabletop interface to improve social skills. Children were teaching in different aspect of social interaction, such as sharing, negotiating and receiving and providing help. Then, children were asked to narrate a joint story using the ST functions | 3 | Three- to four- 45-min sessions | OTs | Increase in positive social interactions (p = 0.004) and collaborative play (p = 0.007) in post- vs pre- intervention Decrease in negative social interaction (p = 0.05) in post- vs pre- intervention |
Henning et al. (2016) | 10 ASD and TD | Computer | Play-based intervention to improve social play interactions. Video feedback and play in the clinic which consisted of watching an episode of the DVD, discussing what they had seen and arranging a weekly play date with the playmate | 7 | 9-weekly sessions. Duration NS | OTs | Improvements in the mean ToP score from 39.8 to 54.1 in post- vs pre- intervention |
Ikuta et al. (2016) | 21, ASD | Another NT (Earmuffs and Noise-cancelled headphones) | Intervention through standard earmuffs and noise-cancelled headphones in controlling behavioral problems related to hyper-reactivity to auditory stimuli | 6 | NS | OTs | Higher effectiveness of intervention score for the earmuff period than that for the control period (p = 0.006) There were no significant differences between the noise-cancelled headphone period and the control period (p = 0.91), and between the earmuff period and noise-cancelled headphone period (p = 0.67) |
Lee et al. (2016) | 6, ASD | Computer | Intervention using Applied Cliplets‑based half‑dynamic videos. Children had to selected the basic facial expression that they thought best reflected the feelings of the character in the video and one of six adjectives to answer each question, and received corrective feedback from the therapist | 6 | One-weekly 1-h sessions | OTs | High correct assessment rates of all the participants in post- vs pre- intervention (p < 0.05) |
Hatfield et al. (2017) | 94, ASD | Computer | IG: Autism specific online program The Better OutcOmes & Successful Transitions for Autism. This program consisted of four modules delivered via a website that is accessed by an individual login CG: Regular practice at their respective schools. This may have included any generic transition planning processes utilized at the school | 48 | NS | OTs | There were no significant differences between IG and CG, in self-determination according to AIR comparing pre- and post-intervention for adolescents (p = 0.19) Improvement in career exploration (p = 0.01) in IG vs CG |
Hochhauser et al. (2018) | 61, ASD | Computer | IG: CONTACT, computer application that uses video modeling and video self-modeling to address conflict resolution skills CG: no intervention | 6 | One-weekly 60-min sessions | OTs and researchers | Improvements in self-confidence (p = 0.02), communication (p = 0.003) and negotiation skills (p ≤ 0.001) in IG vs CG |
Lamash and Josman (2021) | 56, ASD | Computer | IG: Metacognitive intervention combined with practice in a virtual supermarket. Virtual Action Planning-Supermarket (VAP-S) software was used. VAP-S simulates a regular supermarket, including selecting products according to a list that appears on the computer monitor, paying and exiting the supermarket CG: Standard OT intervention to promote a shopping task | 8 | 8-weekly 45-min sessions | OTs | Improvements in the duration of the shopping task performance (p < 0.05), redundant entrances (p < 0.05), accuracy (p < 0.001) and total strategy use (p < 0.05) in IG vs CG |
Parsons et al. (2019) | 59, ASD | iPad™ | IG: Therapy Outcomes by You (TOBY) iPad app, with four major skills areas: (1) visual motor; (2) imitation; (3) language; and (4) social CG: Usual therapy and iPad without the TOBY app installed | 12 | One-daily 20-min sessions | OTs and pshycologists | Increase in the sub-scale of receptive language (p = 0.039) in the MSEL, social (p < 0.001) and symbolic subdomains (p = 0.001) of the CSBS, in post- vs pre- intervention |
Author, year | Main limitations | Funding sources | Declarations of interest |
---|---|---|---|
Josman et al. (2008) | NS | NS | NS |
Cosper et al. (2009) | Lack of control group, small sample size, patients with comorbidity diagnosis, very little research to support Interactive Metronome training | NS | NS |
Lo et al. (2009) | NS | NS | NS |
Gentry et al. (2010) | Non-random, non-representative sample, small sample size, lack of control group, evaluation and training administered by the same people | Program development grant from the Commonwealth Neurotrauma Initiative Fund | NS |
Wuang et al. (2010) | Restricted age range, lack of control group | NS | NS |
Palsbo and Hood-Szivek (2012) | Absence of a valid instrument for functional measurement of fine motor control, small sample size, unable to assess the representativeness of all children with dysgraphia, improvements in self-esteem or social and family inclusion were not assessed | National Institutes for Disability Rehabilitation and Research Grant No. H133S070082 and by Obslap Research, LLC | NS |
Lee et al. (2013) | Minimum number of participants (n = 2), results difficult to generalize, short intervention duration, high initial scores in the recognition subsection, which limited the monitoring of participants' progress | NS | NS |
Janeslätt et al. (2014) | High dropout rate (21%), small sample size, high participants variability, measurement instruments have not been used previously to assess change over time | Clas Groschinskys Minnesfond and Centre for Clinical Research in Dalarna and Stiftelsen Sunnerdahls Handikappfond | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Lorah et al. (2014) | Highly structured and systematic nature of intervention procedures, generalization outside the training environment was not assessed, use of the same stimuli in all training sessions | NS | NS |
Campbell et al. (2015) | Short study duration, small sample size | Did not receive funding support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Chen et al. (2015) | NS | NS | NS |
Meister and Salls (2015) | Short study duration, consistency of performance over time not assessed, generalization in other contexts and at other times not assessed, lack of control group | NS | NS |
Gal et al. (2016) | Small sample size, lack of control group | Autism speaks and the FBK-Haifa agreement | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Henning et al. (2016) | Small sample size, lack of randomization, methodological problems during home visits | NS | NS |
Ikuta et al. (2016) | Small sample size, lack of control group, 4 participants refused to wear earmuffs or NC headphones, and 5 others refused to wear NC headphones (limited NC headphone period behavioral data), adverse and long-term effects were not examined, age, gender, general intelligence, functional level of participants, frequency of intervention, and duration of device use were not controlled | Grant-in-aid for Scientific Research (C) no. 21500473 from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Lee et al. (2016) | Small sample size, limited time for testing | Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan (MOST 104-2420-H-006-020-MY3) | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Hatfield et al. (2017) | The diagnosis of ASD was based on parental report and confirmed by SRS-2, high dropout rate for adolescents (10% control; 31% intervention), Quasi-random, non-blinded intervention assignment, no follow-up or information on work performance was collected | Australian Postgraduate Award scholarship from the Australian Federal Government and Curtin University. Financial support of the Cooperative Research Centre for Living with Autism (Autism CRC) under the Australian Government’s Cooperative Research Centers Program | The authors declare that they have read Biomed Central’s guidance on competing interests and wish to declare the following interests: MH developed the BOOST-A and was also the first author of the manuscript which describes the effectiveness of the BOOST-A |
Hochhauser et al. (2018) | Measurement instrument with a low internal consistency, the transference of acquired behaviors to daily life was not assessed | The Erasmus Mundus Action 2 program of the European Union | NS |
Lamash and Josman (2021) | Small sample size, ASD symptomatology was not directly measured, no follow-up, not designed as a randomized controlled trial, did not follow all CONSORT guidelines | NS | The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest |
Parsons et al. (2019) | Dosage and fidelity of intervention were lower than prescribed, high dropout rate (n = 12) | Lishman Health Foundation and support of South West Autism Group (SWAN) and Telethon Kids Institute | The authors (and funders) have no affiliation with the application or its developers and will not receive, or have previously received, any royalties from sales |