Skip to main content


Swipe om te navigeren naar een ander artikel

01-10-2018 | Original Article | Uitgave 11/2018 Open Access

Netherlands Heart Journal 11/2018

Longitudinal echocardiographic and clinical follow-up of patients undergoing mitral valve surgery without concomitant tricuspid valve repair

Netherlands Heart Journal > Uitgave 11/2018
R. Jansen, B. R. van Klarenbosch, M. J. Cramer, R. C. A. Meijer, P. H. M. Westendorp, H. W. J. Meijburg, J. J. J. Bucx, S. A. J. Chamuleau, J. Kluin
Belangrijke opmerkingen

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s12471-018-1159-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
The Authors R. Jansen and B.R. van Klarenbosch contributed equally to the manuscript.

What’s new

  • Guidelines recommend concomitant tricuspid valve (TV) repair for severe tricuspid regurgitation (TR); however, less is known regarding the management of mild to moderate TR.
  • Our study showed that in patients with moderate TR or less, undergoing mitral valve (MV) surgery without concomitant TV repair, significant late functional TR was seldom seen, and change in TR severity was not influenced by the MV aetiology.
  • Clinical decision-making regarding concomitant TV repair during MV surgery can be safely based on the preoperative evaluation of TR grade: it is safe to waive concomitant TV repair in our specific patient cohort.


Mitral valve (MV) disease represents an increasing health burden, due to ageing and population growth [1]. Approximately 30–50% of patients with severe mitral regurgitation (MR) have significant tricuspid regurgitation (TR) [2]. Functional TR carries an adverse prognosis which is related to its severity [3]. It was historically believed that TR may improve after correction of the MV pathology [4]. However, recent data have shown an increase in TR in a still unclassified subgroup, irrespective of residual or recurrence of MV disease or preoperative TR [58]. Reoperation may be associated with high mortality [9]. Therefore, guidelines recommend concomitant tricuspid valve (TV) repair for severe TR (class I), as it improves mortality and morbidity in these patients [1012]. However, less is known regarding the management of mild to moderate TR. Recent guidelines recommend concomitant tricuspid annuloplasty for a tricuspid annulus (TA) diameter of ≥40 mm or >21 mm/m2 (class IIa) regardless of the TR severity, solely based on expert opinion [10, 11, 1315]. While concomitant TV repair has proven to be a safe procedure [14, 1618], it seems severely underutilised in daily practice [12, 1820]. Insight into the longitudinal echocardiographic and clinical follow-up, including identification of risk factors for TR progression, is of importance to evaluate and complement current guidelines.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the echocardiographic and clinical results in patients with moderate TR or less, undergoing MV surgery without concomitant TV repair, in order to: (1) analyse postoperative TR progression and clinical outcome, and (2) evaluate the role of MV aetiology as potential risk factor for postoperative TR progression.


Study population

Between 2006 and 2014 a total of 1,226 patients underwent MV surgery in the University Medical Center Utrecht (UMCU), the Netherlands (Fig. 1). We analysed the two-dimensional (2D) transthoracic echocardiograms (TTE) and clinical data of 204 patients meeting the inclusion criteria: (1) age ≥18 years; (2) preoperative TR grade <3; (3) referred for elective MV surgery with or without coronary artery bypass grafting and no concomitant TV repair or other concomitant procedures (e. g. MAZE or aortic valve surgery); and (4) follow-up in a participating centre. Our study was approved by the institutional review board of the UMCU, which waived patient consent.

Data collection

Preoperative and perioperative information was retrieved from the surgical database of the UMCU. Postoperative follow-up data and echocardiographic images and/or reports were obtained from the treating physician. Re-evaluation of the images was performed off-line using Xcelera software (Philips Healthcare, the Netherlands). The routine evaluation of echocardiograms was performed by experienced sonographers. Echocardiographic measurements were obtained in accordance with the guidelines [21, 22]. Left ventricular (LV) and right ventricular (RV) function, and atrial and ventricular dimensions were qualified and, if possible, quantified. The severity of valvular disease was graded 0–4 (including grade 0.5 for trace severity) by a cardiologist of the participating centre with a special interest in cardiac imaging, using an integrative approach based on the echocardiographic criteria as recommended by the European guidelines [10, 21]. For data analysis TR grade was divided into four groups: none, trace or mild, moderate, and more than moderate TR. Additionally the change in TR grade between the preoperative and most recent TTE was determined. In case of insufficient data regarding TR grade and TA dimensions, the images were re-evaluated in the apical 4‑chamber view. TA was considered dilated when ≥40 mm [21]. Each patient was allocated to either the organic or functional MV subgroup: organic when a specific component of the MV apparatus was diseased, or functional when caused by secondary changes induced by abnormal ventricular size and leaflet retraction.

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was done using SPSS (version 21.0, IBM Corporation, New York). Continuous variables were expressed as mean (±SD) and compared using Student’s t‑test in case of normally distributed data, or expressed as median (interquartile range) and compared using Wilcoxon signed-rank test or Mann-Whitney U test for non-normal distribution. One-way ANOVA or Kruskal-Wallis was used to compare >2 unpaired groups. Categorical data were described using frequencies and percentages. We performed comparative evaluations via the χ2 or McNemar’s test for binary results, and χ2 or Wilcoxon signed-rank test in case of ordinal data. The Kaplan-Meier method was used to calculate long-term survival for the different grades of 1‑year postoperative TR. Statistical significances between the survival curves was determined by a log-rank test; the p-value <0.05 was considered statistically significant. Ordinal regression analysis for change in TR grade (between preoperative and most recent TTE) was performed based on complete case analysis, including univariable and multivariable ordinal regression on pre-determined variables of interest at baseline (MR grade, MV aetiology, MV aetiology subcategories, TR grade, TA diameter, RV function, RA dilatation, LV function, LA dilatation and gender) and potential confounders (age, NYHA class, pacemaker implantation and atrial fibrillation).


Patient characteristics

Baseline characteristics are shown in Table 1. In Online Resource 1 (Supplementary material) the subcategories per MV aetiology are depicted. Patients with functional MV disease (30.4%) were significantly older compared with the organic subgroup (69.6%). Also NYHA class, EuroSCORE and rates of the comorbidities hypertension, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, known coronary artery disease, diabetes, and renal failure were significantly higher in the functional aetiology subgroup, particularly for ischaemic MR. Preoperative MV annulus dilation was present in 58.5% of patients with organic and >90% of patients with functional valve disease. Clinically important mitral stenosis (MS) was only seen in the organic subgroup (9.9%). MV repair was more often performed in patients with functional disease (96.8%), compared with 18.3% MV replacement in the organic aetiology subgroup (mainly for rheumatic disease or severe calcifications). Patients with more preoperative TR showed a higher NYHA class (p = 0.011). Regarding the surgical characteristics, more MV replacements were performed in patients with moderate TR at baseline compared with lower grades (p = 0.017). Standard median sternotomy was performed in 98.5%. Three patients underwent a right anterior thoracotomy. Access to the MV was achieved through a left atriotomy.
Table 1
Baseline characteristics and procedure details (n = 204)
Patient Characteristics
Age (years)
 61.1 ± 13.1
Male gender
125 (61.3)
BSA (m2)
  2.2 ± 0.2
NYHA class ≥III
 92 (45.1)
  1.4 [0.8–3.5]
 63 (30.9)
Known coronary artery disease (n = 203)
 84 (40.9)
 23 (11.3)
 18 (8.8)
Renal failure
 38 (18.6)
Atrial fibrillation
 38 (18.6)
Pacemaker or ICD
  8 (3.9)
Surgical Characteristics
Organic MV disease
142 (69.6)
– Myxomatous degeneration
 79 (38.7)
– Fibroelastic degeneration
 47 (23.0)
– Rheumatic disease
 13 (6.4)
– Other
  3 (1.5)
Functional MV disease
 62 (30.4)
– Ischaemic cardiomyopathy
 46 (22.5)
– Other
 16 (7.8)
Preoperative MR (n = 203)
164 (80.2)
Preoperative TR
– No
 29 (14.2)
– Trace or mild
126 (61.8)
– Moderate
 49 (24.0)
  0 (0.0)
Preoperative TA ≥ 40 mm (n = 165)
 14 (8.5)
Preoperative TA diameter (mm) (n = 165)
 33 ± 4
MV replacement
 28 (13.7)
– Mechanical
 17 (8.3)
– Bioprosthesis
 11 (5.4)
MV repair
176 (86.3)
– Physio ring
137 (67.2)
– Cosgrove band
 38 (18.6)
Elevated RVSP (n = 118)
 51 (43.2)
Concomitant CABG
 75 (36.8)
Cross-clamp time (minutes)
118 [92–149]
Data are depicted as n (%), mean ± SD or median [interquartile range]
BSA body surface area, NYHA New York Heart Association, COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, ICD implantable cardioverter-defibrillator, MV mitral valve, MR mitral regurgitation, TR tricuspid regurgitation, TA tricuspid annulus, RVSP right ventricular systolic pressure, CABG coronary artery bypass crafting

Clinical results

Clinical outcomes are depicted in Table 2. Of the 204 patients, 5 (2.5%) died within 30 days (shock n = 3, respiratory failure n = 1, acute neoplastic disease n = 1). All had ischaemic MR. Reoperation <30 days after surgery occurred in 9.3%, mainly for bleeding complications (7.8%). Of the patients with postoperative AF, this rhythm was already present at baseline in 29.8%. The prevalence of AF at follow-up was similar to baseline, whereas the NYHA class ≥III significantly decreased. The overall survival after a median follow-up of 5.5 [3.7–8.1] years was 87.3%, and significantly better for the organic compared with functional MV aetiology (92.3% versus 75.8%). The highest mortality rate was seen for ischaemic MR (28.3%). There was no significant difference in survival according to TR grade at 1 year (Fig. 2, p = 0.972). In 50% of the deceased patients TR was never severe and therefore not a cause of mortality; the TR grade was unknown in the remaining subjects.
Table 2
Clinical results at follow-up and echocardiographic characteristic at most recent follow-up
Clinical Characteristics
Early outcome
Operative mortality
  0 (0.0)
30 days mortality
  5 (2.5)
New permanent pacemaker or ICD
  5 (2.5)
Atrial fibrillation
104 (51)
 19 (9.3)
– due to bleeding
 16 (7.8)
– other
  3 (1.5)
Late outcome
Postoperative (for most recent FU analysis) (years)
  3.4 [1.8–5.2]
Postoperative (for survival analysis) (years)
  5.5 [3.7–8.1]
 26 (12.7)
– Cardiovascular
 20 (9.8)
– Other
  6 (2.9)
NYHA class ≥III (n = 184)
 12 (6.5)
New reoperation (n = 184)
  7 (3.8)
– Due to mitral stenosis post MV surgery
  1 (0.5)
– Due to endocarditis
  2 (1.0)
– Due to bleeding
  1 (0.5)
Rehospitalisation (n = 187)
 66 (35.3)
– Cardiovascular
 46 (22.5)
Congestive heart failure (n = 183)
 19 (10.4)
New permanent pacemaker or ICD (n = 185)
 14 (7.6)
Atrial fibrillation (n = 183)
 38 (20.8)
OAC (n = 180)
 78 (43.3)
Stroke (n = 191)
  2 (1.0)
Echocardiographic Characteristics
Time after surgery, years (n = 164)
  3.1 [1.6–4.6]
LV function, n (%) (n = 160)
– Poor (EF < 30%) or moderate (EF 30–44%)
 33 (20.6)
LV EF, % ± SD (n = 103)
 55 ± 15
LA dilatation, n (%) (n = 135)
– Moderate or severe
 34 (25.2)
RA dilatation, n (%) (n = 155)
– Moderate or severe
 11 (7.1)
RV function, n (%) (n = 147)
– Poor or moderate
 11 (7.5)
TAPSE, cm ± SD (n = 129)
  1.8 ± 0.5
MR grade, n (%) (n = 159)
  3 (1.9)
TR grade, n (%) (n = 161)
– No
 24 (14.9)
– Trace or mild
107 (66.5)
– Moderate
 28 (17.4)
  2 (1.2)
TA ≥ 40 mm, n (%) (n = 154)
 23 (14.9)
– Of whom had pre-operative TA ≥ 40 mm
  3 (13.0)
Elevated RVSP, n (%) (n = 97)
 14 (14.4)
Data are depicted as n (%), mean ± SD or median [interquartile range]
ICD implantable cardioverter-defibrillator, NYHA New York Heart Association, MR mitral regurgitation, OAC oral anticoagulation, LV left ventricular, EF ejection fraction, LA left atrial, RA right atrial, TAPSE tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion, TR tricuspid regurgitation, TA tricuspid annulus, RVSP right ventricular systolic pressure.

Echocardiographic results

Overall echocardiographic results at follow-up are shown in Table 2. In 204 patients echocardiographic data were available at baseline. Postoperatively, the TTE was available in 202 patients (2 subjects passed away), while TR grade could be determined in 161 patients using the echocardiographic data or images (78.9%). Fig. 3 shows the overall change, including median changes per baseline TR grade subgroups. In general, almost all patients with no TR at baseline developed some TR at late follow-up, whereas in subjects with preoperatively moderate TR an increase was never seen. Overall change in TR severity was limited and not significant: in only 3 out of 161 patients (1.9%) was a change in TR severity of >1 grade seen, whereas TR severity did not change in 86 patients (53.4%). RV systolic function as measured by tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion (TAPSE) decreased from 2.4 ± 0.5 cm preoperatively to 1.8 ± 0.5 cm (p < 0.001) at late follow-up. Medians of TR grade were similar amongst the MV aetiology groups (Table 3). Long-term follow-up showed 2 patients with TR grade ≥3 (Fig. 4); one in each of the MV aetiology subgroups. Median changes in TR grade were never significant over time in either the MV aetiology subgroup or the MV aetiology subcategories (Fig. 4). Baseline MR severity was significantly lower in the functional compared with the organic group (median 3.0 versus 4.0 respectively). Both preoperative and postoperative LV and RV function were poorer in functional MV disease.
Table 3
Echocardiographic results in patients with organic and functional mitral valve disease
Organic (n = 142)
Functional (n = 62)
LV function (n = 141/61)
– Poor (EF < 30%) or moderate (EF 30–44%)
  4 (2.8)
25 (41.0)
LA dilatation (n = 131/55)
– Moderate or severe
 75 (57.3)
27 (49.1)
RA dilatation (n = 132/54)
– Moderate or severe
 14 (10.6)
 6 (11.1)
RV function (n = 127/55)
– Poor or moderate
  1 (0.8)
 3 (5.5)
TAPSE (cm) (n = 87/43)
  2.3 [2.1–2.8]
 2.0 [1.8–2.5]
MR grade (n = 141/62)
122 (86.5)
42 (67.7)
TR grade (n = 142/62)
– No
 21 (14.8)
 8 (12.9)
– Trace or mild
 88 (62.0)
38 (61.3)
– Moderate
 33 (23.2)
16 (25.8)
  0 (0.0)
 0 (0.0)
TA ≥ 40 mm (n = 115/50)
  8 (7.0)
 6 (12.0)
TA diameter (mm) (n = 115/50)
 33 ± 4
33 ± 5
LV function (n = 114/46)
– Poor (EF < 30%) or moderate (EF 30–44%)
 10 (8.3)
23 (50.0)
LA dilatation (n = 94/41)
– Moderate or severe
 23 (24.5)
11 (26.8)
RA dilatation (n = 109/46)
– moderate or severe
  7 (6.4)
 4 (8.7)
RV function (n = 105/42)
– Poor or moderate
  3 (2.9)
 8 (19.0)
TAPSE (cm) (n = 90/39)
  1.9 [1.6–2.1]
 1.6 [1.4–2.1]
MR grade (n = 114/45)
  2 (1.8)
 1 (2.2)
TR grade (n = 115/46)
– No
 16 (13.9)
 8 (17.4)
– Trace or mild
 79 (68. 8)
28 (60.9)
– Moderate
 19 (16.5)
 9 (19.6)
  1 (0.9)
 1 (2.2)
TA ≥ 40 mm (n = 111/43)
 18 (16.2)
 5 (11.6)
TA diameter (mm) (n = 110/43)
 34 ± 5
34 ± 5
Change in TR grade (n = 115/46)
  4 (3.5)
 2 (4.3)
 23 (20.0)
14 (30.4)
 66 (57.4)
20 (43.5)
 20 (17.4)
 9 (19.6)
  2 (1.7)
 1 (2.2)
Data are depicted as n (%), mean ± SD or median [interquartile range]
EF ejection fraction, LV left ventricular, LA left atrial, RA right atrial, RV right ventricular, TAPSE tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion, MR mitral regurgitation, TR tricuspid regurgitation, TA tricuspid annulus, RVSP right ventricular systolic pressure.

Regression analysis

Univariable regression analysis (Online Resource 2, supplementary material) showed a significant, negative correlation between change in TR grade and TR severity, TA diameter at baseline, and LA dilatation (regression coefficient (r) = −2.774, p < 0.0001, r = −0.839, p = 0.021, and r = −0.276, p = 0.024 respectively). In a multivariable regression model correcting for other parameters and confounders, only baseline TR grade and male gender remained independently correlated (r = −2.908, p < 0.0001 and r = −0.710, p = 0.027 respectively), suggesting more improvement of TR in patients with higher TR grade preoperatively, and more improvement in males compared with females.


Our study of patients with moderate TR or less, undergoing MV surgery without concomitant TV repair, revealed three important findings. First, more than moderate late functional TR was seldom seen in this cohort at a median follow-up of 3.1 years. Secondly, overall change in TR severity was not significant when comparing the preoperative and late postoperative TR grade. Lastly, change in TR severity was not influenced by MV aetiology. Therefore our data suggest that clinical decision-making regarding concomitant TV repair during MV surgery in patients with moderate TR or less, can be safely based on the preoperative evaluation of TR grade.

Prevalence and change of TR

Several factors contribute to TR in MV disease. First, an increase in LA pressure may result in pulmonary hypertension and subsequent RV enlargement, remodelling and dysfunction. Consequently, the TA diameter increases, leading to leaflet tethering and/or papillary muscle displacement [23]. Second, MV disease may induce AF resulting in TR. Lastly, the TV may be affected by the same disease process as the MV aetiology leading to MR. In our study, only 2 (1.2%) patients developed more than moderate TR, in contrast with previous data showing a late significant TR prevalence ranging from 8–74% [6, 8, 14, 2426]. A possible explanation for the non-significant change and therefore low prevalence of TR grade ≥3 in our cohort is the frequent performance of concomitant TV repair in patients with a TA annulus ≥40 mm. A proactive acquittal of the guidelines may have led to a selection bias, including less subjects with a larger TA diameter. Indeed, a brief evaluation of the TA diameter in patients: (1) without concomitant TV repair and TR grade <3 (current study cohort), (2) with concomitant TV repair and TR grade <3, and (3) with concomitant TV repair and TR grade ≥3, revealed a mean of 33 ± 4 mm, 42 ± 4 mm and 46 ± 6 mm respectively. Still, in 14 of the 165 patients with an available TA diameter (8.5%), the annulus at baseline was dilated, of whom 3 also showed a dilated TA at follow-up. Additionally, differences may depend on heterogeneity in study populations and outcome definitions. Also the follow-up period to determine significant TR remains controversial. Goldstone et al. showed that late postoperative TR is a slow progressive disease, with a marked increase (grade ≥3) after 9 years [8]. Our shorter follow-up period may therefore have led to a premature non-significant change in TR, possibly reflected by the decrease in RV systolic function (based on TAPSE) in our study population. However, other studies revealed a prevalence of significant TR (grade >2) in 48.6% and 18.2% after just 2 years [27, 28]. Lastly, our data do confirm guideline recommendations to defer concomitant TV repair in patients with non-severe TR: moderate TR at baseline decreased (69%) or remained unchanged (31%) in all subjects, and therefore TR never worsened. Although previous studies confirm these results [29], others have revealed TR grade >2 as being a risk factor for TR progression [7], possibly resulting from structural remodelling of, for example, RV and TA in patients with cardiomyopathy-related MV disease [30]. However, we expect less influence of structural remodelling on TR progression in our patient cohort, while 69.6% suffered from organic MV disease. In line with the idea of TR grade >2 being a risk factor, Chikwe et al. showed a higher 7‑year freedom from moderate or worse TR after concomitant TV repair compared with solely MV surgery in patients with moderate severity at baseline. On the contrary, the risk of developing moderate TR in subjects with no or mild regurgitation at baseline was low (17% versus 15%), matching our data. Nevertheless, their follow-up period was long (7 versus 3.1 years) [26]. Remarkably, our data more frequently showed a progression of TR in patients with lower baseline TR grade (probably explained by the regression toward the mean phenomenon), and female subjects [24, 29], although this was seldom significant TR and did not lead to excess mortality.

MV aetiology as a potential risk factor

Several studies have reported a high prevalence of postoperative TR in rheumatic MV [20, 24] and functional MR, with rheumatic MR being reported as an independent risk factor for late significant TR [20, 24, 25, 27, 31]. Our study showed TR progression towards more than moderate in only 2 patients (1.2%). There was no significant correlation between increased TR grade and MV aetiology, but this subanalysis was not very powerful. Differences at baseline and follow-up between the MV aetiology subgroups (e. g. lower survival and worse LV and RV function) can be explained by the poorer outcome in patients with ischaemic cardiac disease.

Study limitations

This study was retrospective with its inherent limitations. Only 17% of the 1,226 patients undergoing MV surgery in the UMC Utrecht were included. Main reasons are the exclusion of patients with follow-up in non-participating centres (682), and exclusion of patients with concomitant surgery (284). In addition, evaluation of 2D TTE in daily practice is limited by a poor imaging window, and especially TR-related measurements could not always be adequately obtained, further reducing the number of patients for clinical and echocardiographic data analysis towards 204, and for paired echocardiographic evaluation towards 161 subjects. Also standardised TR grading could not be carried out. Moreover, the surgical procedures performed in a single academic centre may not be applicable to other centres. Due to a low prevalence of late TR grade ≥3 postoperatively, no analyses for this endpoint could be performed, and no risk factors for significant postoperative TR were defined. A prospective study with longer follow-up is recommended to confirm our results.


In patients with mild to moderate TR who underwent elective MV surgery without concomitant TV repair, our study showed that significant late functional TR was seldom seen. Change in TR severity in the late postoperative period was not influenced by the MV aetiology, and mortality was not correlated to 1‑year postoperative TR severity. According to our study, it is safe to waive concomitant TV repair in this specific patient cohort, which is relevant for clinical decision-making in the heart team.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​4.​0/​), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

Onze productaanbevelingen

Netherlands Heart Journal

Het Netherlands Heart Journal wordt uitgegeven in samenwerking met de Nederlandse Vereniging voor Cardiologie en de Nederlandse Hartstichting. Het tijdschrift is Engelstalig en wordt gratis beschikbaa ...

Extra materiaal
Online Resource 1: Subcategories for the types of mitral valve etiology (figure). Online Resource 2 reflects the univariable and multivariable analysis in change in tricuspid regurgitation grade (n = 161) between baseline and most recent echocardiographic follow-up, and pre-determined variables of interest at baseline (table)
Over dit artikel

Andere artikelen Uitgave 11/2018

Netherlands Heart Journal 11/2018 Naar de uitgave