Abstract
The octave illusion is elicited by a sequence of tones presented to each ear that continuously alternate in frequency by one octave, but with high and low frequencies always in different ears. The percept for most listeners is a high pitch in one ear, alternating with a low pitch in the other ear. The influentialsuppression model of the illusion proposed by Deutsch and Roll (1976) carries three postulates: first, that listeners perceive only the pitch of the tones presented to their dominant ear; second, that this pitch is heard in whichever ear received the higher frequency tone; and third, that this apparent dissociation betweenwhat andwhere mechanisms arises from sequential interactions between the tones. In the present article, we reappraise evidence for the suppression model and demonstrate (1) the incompatibility of the theory with the existing literature on pitch perception, sound localization, and ear dominance and (2) methodological limitations in studies that have claimed to provide support for the suppression model. We conclude by proposing an alternative theory of the octave illusion that is based on established principles of fusion, rather than suppression, between ears.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Akerboom, S., ten Hoopen, G., &van der Knoop, A. (1985). Does the octave illusion evoke the interaural tempo illusion?Perception & Psychophysics,38, 281–285.
Arehart, K. H., &Burns, E. M. (1999). A comparison of monotic and dichotic complex-tone pitch perception in listeners with hearing loss.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,106, 993–997.
Bernstein, L. R., &Trahiotis, C. (1996). The normalized correlation as an index of interaural envelope correlation.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,100, 3774–3784.
Bernstein, L. R., &Trahiotis, C. (2001). Using transposed stimuli to reveal similar underlying sensitivity to interaural timing information at high and low frequencies: Support for the Colburn-Esquissand hypothesis. In D. J. Brebaart, A. J. M. Houstma, A. Kohlrausch, V. F. Prijs, & R. Schoonhoven (Eds.),Proceedings of the 12th International Symposium on Hearing: Physiological and psychophysical bases of auditory function (pp. 137–144). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Bernstein, L. R., &Trahiotis, C. (2002). Enhancing sensitivity to interaural delays at high frequencies by using “transposed stimuli [Abstract].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,112, 1026–1036.
Blauert, J. (1997). Spatial hearing: The psychophysics of human sound localization (Rev. ed.). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Blauert, J., &Divenyi, P. L. (1988). Spectral selectivity in binaural contralateral inhibition.Acustica,66, 267–274.
Chambers, C. D., Mattingley, J. B., &Moss, S. A. (2002). The octave illusion revisited: Suppression or fusion between ears?Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,28, 1288–1302.
Cohen, Y. E., &Knudsen, E. I. (1999). Maps versus clusters: Different representations of auditory space in the midbrain and forebrain.Trends in Neuroscience,22, 128–135.
Colburn, H. S., &Esquissand, P. (1976). An auditory-nerve model for interaural time discrimination of high-frequency complex stimuli [Abstract].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,59(Suppl. 1), S23.
Demany, L., &Semal, C. (1988). Dichotic fusion of two tones one octave apart: Evidence for internal octave templates.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,83, 687–695.
Deutsch, D. (1974). An auditory illusion.Nature,251, 307–309.
Deutsch, D. (1975). Musical illusions.Scientific American,233, 92–104.
Deutsch, D. (1978). Lateralization by frequency for repeating sequences of dichotic 400- and 800-Hz tones.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,63, 184–186.
Deutsch, D. (1980a). Ear dominance and sequential interactions.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,67, 220–228.
Deutsch, D. (1980b). The octave illusion and the what-where connection. In R. S. Nickerson (Ed.),Attention and performance VIII (pp. 575–592). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Deutsch, D. (1981). The octave illusion and auditory perceptual integration. In J. V. Tobias & E. D. Schubert (Eds.),Hearing research and theory (Vol. 1, pp. 99–142). New York: Academic Press
Deutsch, D. (1988). Lateralization and sequential relationships in the octave illusion.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,83, 365–369.
Deutsch, D., &Roll, P. L. (1976). Separate “what” and “where” decision mechanisms in processing a dichotic tonal sequence.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance,2, 23–29.
Divenyi, P. L. (1990a).Coincidence models of auditory localization, localization of dichotic tone pairs, and the Deutsch octave illusion. Unpublished manuscript.
Divenyi, P. L. (1990a). Lateralization mechanisms and Deutsch’s octave illusion [Abstract].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,88, S97.
Divenyi, P. L. (1992). Binaural suppression of nonechoes.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,91, 1078–1084.
Dye, R. H. (1990). The combination of interaural information across frequencies: Lateralization on the basis of interaural delay.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,88, 2159–2170.
Efron, R., Koss, B., &Yund, E. W. (1983). Central auditory processing: IV. Ear dominance: Spatial and temporal complexity.Brain & Language,19, 264–282.
Efron, R., &Yund, E. W. (1974). Dichotic competition of simultaneous tone bursts of different frequency: I. Dissociation of pitch from lateralization and loudness.Neuropsychologia,12, 249–256.
Efron, R., &Yund, E. W. (1975). Dichotic competition of simultaneous tone bursts of different frequency: III. The effects of stimulus parameters on suppression and ear dominance functions.Neuropsychologia,13, 151–161.
Efron, R., &Yund, E. W. (1976). Ear dominance and intensity independence in the perception of dichotic chords.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,59, 889–898.
Fechner, G. (1966).Elements of psychophysics (H. E. Adler, Trans.). New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. (Original work published 1860)
Franssen, N. V. (1962).Stereophony. Eindhoven: Philips Technical Library.
Gregory, A. H., Efron, R., Divenyi, P. L., &Yund, E. W. (1983). Central auditory processing: I. Ear dominance: A perceptual or attentional asymmetry?Brain & Language,19, 225–236.
Haas, H. (1951). On the influence of a single echo on the intelligibility of speech.Acustica,1, 48–58.
Hafter, E. R., &DeMaio, J. (1975). Difference thresholds for interaural delay.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,57, 181–187.
Hafter, E. R., &Ricard, G. L. (1973). Binaural interaction with stimuli that produce periodicity pitch.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,53, 334.
Hari, R. (1990). The neuromagnetic method in the study of the human auditory cortex. In F. Grandori, M. Hoke, & G. L. Romani (Eds.),Auditory evoked magnetic fields and electric potentials: Advances in audiology (pp. 222–282). Basel: Karger.
Harris, G. G. (1960). Binaural interactions of impulsive stimuli and pure tones.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,32, 685–692.
Hartmann, W. M., &Rakerd, B. (1989). Localization of sound in rooms: IV. The Franssen effect.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,86, 1366–1373.
Heller, L. M., &Trahiotis, C. (1995). Interference in detection of interaural delay in a sinusoidally amplitude-modulated tone produced by a second, spectrally remote sinsusoidally amplitude-modulated tone.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,97, 1808–1816.
Henning, G. B. (1974a). Detectability of interaural delay in highfrequency complex waveforms.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,55, 84–90.
Henning, G. B. (1974b). Lateralization and the binaural masking level difference.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,55, 1259–1262.
Henning, G. B. (1980). Some observations on the lateralization of complex waveforms.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,68, 446–454.
Hermann, L. (1890). Phonophotagraphische Untersuchungen III.Pflügers Archiv für die gesamte Physiologie,47, 347–391.
Houstma, A. J. M. (1979). Musical pitch of two-tone complexes and predictions by modern pitch theories.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,66, 87–99.
Houstma, A. J. M., &Fleuren, J. F. M. (1991). Analytic and synthetic pitch of two-tone complexes.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,90, 1674–1677.
Houstma, A. J. M., &Goldstein, J. M. (1972). The central origin of the pitch of complex tones: Evidence from musical interval recognition.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,51, 520–529.
Irvine, D. R. F. (Ed.) (1986).The auditory brainstem: Progress in sensory physiology (Vol. 7). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Kuhn, G. F. (1987). Physical acoustics and measurements pertaining to directional hearing. In W. A. Yost & G. Gourevitch (Eds.),Directional hearing (pp. 3–25). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Lamminmäki, S., &Hari, R. (2000). Auditory cortex activation associated with octave illusion.NeuroReport,11, 1469–1472.
Licklider, J. C. R. (1954). “Periodicity” pitch and “place” pitch.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,26, 945.
Lindemann, W. (1986). Extension of a binaural cross-correlation model by contralateral inhibition: II. The law of the first wave front.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,80, 1623–1630.
Litovsky, R. Y., Colburn, H. S., Yost, W. A., &Guzman, S. J. (1999). The precedence effect.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,106, 1633–1654.
Macmillan, N. A., &Creelman, C. D. (1991).Detection theory: A user’s guide. New York: Cambridge University Press.
McClurkin, R. H., &Hall, J. W. (1981). Pitch and timbre in a two-tone dichotic auditory illusion.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,69, 592–594.
McFadden, D., &Pasanen, E. G. (1976). Lateralization at high frequencies based on interaural time differences.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,59, 634–639.
Mills, A. W. (1972). Auditory localization. In J. Tobias (Ed.),Foundations of modern auditory theory (Vol. 2, pp. 301–345). New York: Academic Press.
Mills, J. H., Dubno, J. R., &He, N. (1996). Masking by ipsilateral and contralateral maskers.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,100, 3336–3344.
Nuetzel, J. M., &Hafter, E. R. (1976). Lateralization of complex waveforms: Effects of fine structure, amplitude, and duration.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,60, 1339–1346.
Odenthal, D. W. (1963). Perception and neural representation of simultaneous pure tone stimuli.Acta Physiologica et Pharmacologica Neerlandica,12, 453–496.
Patterson, R. D. (1969). Noise masking of a change in residue pitch.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,45, 1520–1524.
Rayleigh, [L.] (1876). On our perception of the direction of a source of sound.Proceedings of the Musical Association,2, 75–84.
Rayleigh, [L.] (1907). On our perception of sound direction.Philosophical Magazine,13, 214–232.
Ross, J., Tervaniemi, M., &Näätänen, R. (1996). Neural mechanisms of the octave illusion: Electrophysiological evidence for central origin.NeuroReport,8, 303–306.
Schouten, J. F. (1938). The perception of subjective tones.Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen,41, 1086–1093.
Schouten, J. F. (1940a). The perception of pitch.Philips Technical Review,5, 286–294.
Schouten, J. F. (1940a). The residue and the mechanism of hearing.Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen,43, 991–999.
Schouten, J. F. (1940c). The residue, a new component in subjective sound analysis.Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen,43, 356–365.
Schröger, E. (1996). A neural mechanism for involuntary attention shifts to changes in auditory stimulation.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,8, 527–539.
Seebeck, A. (1841). Beobachtungen über einige Bedingungen der Entstehung von Tönen.Annalen der Physik und Chemie,53, 417–436.
Shin-Cunningham, B. G., Zurek, P. M., Durlach, N. I., &Clifton, R. K. (1995). Cross-frequency interactions in the precedence effect.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,98, 164–171.
Small, A. M. (1955). Some parameters influencing the pitch of amplitude modulated signals.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,27, 751–760.
Small, A. M., &Campbell, R. A. (1961). Masking of pulsed tones by bands of noise.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,33, 1570–1576.
Sonnadara, R. R., &Trainor, L. J. (2002). The octave illusion: How is information combined across the ears? In C. Stevens, D. Burnham, G. McPherson, E. Schubert, & J. Renwick (Eds.),Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Music Perception and Cognition (pp. 530–533). Adelaide, Australia: Causal Productions.
Stellmack, M. A., &Dye, R. H. (1993). The combination of interaural information across frequencies: The effects of number and spacing of components, onset asynchrony, and harmonicity.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,93, 2933–2947.
Stevens, S. S., &Egan, J. P. (1941). Diplacusis in normal ears.Psychological Bulletin,38, 548.
Terhardt, E. (1974). Pitch, consonance and harmony.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,55, 1061–1069.
Terhardt, E. (1979). Calculating virtual pitch.Hearing Research,1, 155–182.
Terhardt, E., Stoll, G., &Seewann, M. (1982a). Algorithm for the extraction of pitch and pitch salience from complex tonal signals.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,71, 679–688.
Terhardt, E., Stoll, G., &Seewann, M. (1982b). Pitch of complex signals according to virtual-pitch theory: Tests, examples and predictions.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,71, 671–678.
Thurlow, W. R., &Small, A. M. (1955). Pitch perception for certain periodic auditory stimuli.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,27, 132–137.
van den Brink, G. (1965). Pitch shift of the residue by masking.International Audiology,4, 183–186.
van den Brink, G. (1970a). Experiments on binaural diplacusis and tone perception. In R. Plomp & G. F. Smoorenburg (Eds.),Frequency analysis and periodicity detection in hearing (pp. 362–372). Leiden: Sijthoff.
van den Brink, G. (1970b). Two experiments on pitch perception: Diplacusis of harmonic AM signals and pitch of inharmonic AM signals.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,48, 1355–1365.
van den Brink, G. (1975a). Monaural frequency-pitch relations as the origin of binaural diplacusis for pure tones and residue sounds.Acustica,32, 166–174.
van den Brink, G. (1975b). The relation between binaural diplacusis for pure tones and for complex sounds under normal conditions and with induced monaural pitch shift.Acustica,32, 159–165.
van den Brink, G. (1979). Intensity and pitch.Acustica,41, 271–273.
Wallach, H., Newman, E. B., &Rosenzweig, M. R. (1949). The precedence effect in sound localization.American Journal of Psychology,62, 315–336.
Ward, W. D. (1963). Diplacusis and auditory theory.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,35, 1746–1747.
Wightman, F. L., &Kistler, D. J. (1993). Sound localization. In W. A. Yost, A. Popper, & R. Fays (Eds.),Springer handbook of auditory research: Human psychophysics (pp. 155–192). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Yang, X., &Grantham, D. W. (1997). Cross-spectral and temporal factors in the precedence effect: Discrimination suppression of the lag sound in free-field.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,102, 2973–2983.
Yost, W. A., Mapes-Riordan, D., &Guzman, S. J. (1997). The relationship between localization and the Franssen effect.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,101, 2994–2997.
Yost, W. A., Wightman, F. L., &Green, D. M. (1971). Lateralization of filtered clicks.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,50, 1526–1531.
Young, L. L., &Carhart, R. (1974). Time-intensity trading functions for pure tones and a high-frequency AM signal.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,56, 605–609.
Yund, E. W. (1982). Comments on “Ear dominance and sequential interactions.”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,71, 1287–1290.
Yund, E. W., &Efron, R. (1975). Dichotic competition of simultaneous tone bursts of different frequency: II. Suppression and ear dominance functions.Neuropsychologia,13, 137–150.
Zurek, P. M. (1985). Spectral dominance in sensitivity to interaural delay for broadband stimuli [Abstract].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,78, S18.
Zurek, P. M. (1987). The precedence effect. In W. A. Yost & G. Gourevitch (Eds.),Directional hearing (pp. 85–105). New York: Springer-Verlag.
Zwislocki, J. (1972). A theory of central auditory masking and its partial validation.Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,52, 644–659.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chambers, C.D., Mattingley, J.B. & Moss, S.A. Reconsidering evidence for the suppression model of the octave illusion. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 11, 642–666 (2004). https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03196617
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03196617