Cost-benefit analysis of influenza vaccination in a public healthcare unit

Giorgio L Colombo¹, Antonio Ferro², Marta Vinci¹, Maria Zordan², Giulio Serra¹

¹S.A.V.E. Studi Analisi Valutazioni Economiche, Milano, Italia; ²Unità Locale Socio Sanitaria ULSS n°17, Regione Veneto, Italia

Objective: Estimate the costs and benefits of influenza vaccination in a group of employees of an Italian District Health Authority, Unità Locale Socio Sanitaria (ULSS), to define a scheme of an economic evaluation to be used for other vaccination strategies.

Design: In an observational study conducted from December 2002 to April 2003, 107 ULSS employees, voluntarily vaccinated, were compared with 107 nonvaccinated ULSS employees matched for age, sex, and job category. The outcome of cost-benefit analysis was evaluated by checking personnel department records about absences from work and their causes, including influenza. Costs and benefits of the influenza vaccination from the ULSS point of view were calculated.

Results: The influenza vaccination strategy reduced absences from work by 23% and decreased the loss of working days by 30% and related cost. This difference is not significative. The ratio vaccination benefits/cost was €4.2. The advantage of vaccination is confirmed by sensitivity analysis performed on the mean cost of a working day, which showed that the benefit-cost ratio ranged from €4.5 to €11.7.

Conclusions: The results suggest that the influenza vaccination strategy in our sample of people was cost-saving. The economic evaluation used in this study could also be used for other vaccination strategies and in other settings.

Keywords: economic evaluation, influenza vaccination strategy, observational study