Abstract

Project GRAD (Graduate Ready for Activity Daily) was a randomized controlled study to teach university seniors behavioral skills necessary for increasing and/or maintaining physical activity habits in preparation for the transition to working adult roles after graduation. This study examines the secondary effects of this intervention on body image concerns among college-aged men and women. Three hundred thirty-eight undergraduates (54% female, M age = 24 years, SD = 1.95; M Body Mass Index = 24.26, SD = 4.0) were studied. The sample was 61% Anglo, 16% Latino, 16% Asian/Pacific Islander, 4% African American, and 3% Native American/Other. Body image concerns were assessed at pre- and posttreatment using 2 subscales of the Eating Disorder Inventory: Drive for Thinness and Body Dissatisfaction. Because the latter concentrates on body parts typically associated with female concerns (e.g., thighs, hips, buttocks), a parallel scale was developed to target body parts that may be of more concern to men (e.g., legs, shoulders, arms, stomach). Results indicated that compared to the control group, women in the intervention showed a significant increase in drive for thinness without any changes in body dissatisfaction. For men, there were no significant changes in drive for thinness or body dissatisfaction. These results suggest that physical activity interventions may have some negative consequences of increasing concerns about thinness in women. This negative effect occurred despite intervention content designed to prevent concern over eating, dieting, and the importance of weight. Health promotion studies should include assessments of potential negative side effects.

References

(1)

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
:
Physical Activity and Health: A Report of the Surgeon General.
1996
;
Atlanta, GA
:
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion
.

(2)

Thompson
JK
,
Heinberg
LJ
,
Altabe
M
,
Tantleff-Dunn
S
:
Exacting Beauty: Theory, Assessment, and Treatment of Body Image Disturbance.
1999
;
Washington, DC
:
American Psychological Association
.

(3)

Mintz
LB
,
Betz
NE
:
Prevalence and correlates of eating disordered behaviors among undergraduate women
.
Journal of Counseling Psychology.
1988
,
35
:
463
471
.

(4)

Streigel-Moore
RH
,
Steiner-Adair
C
:
Primary prevention of eating disorders: Further considerations from a feminist perspective
. In
Vandereyecken
W
,
Noordenbos
G
(eds),
The Prevention of Eating Disorders.
1998
;
New York
:
New York University Press
,
1
22
.

(5)

Drewnowski
A
,
Yee
DK
:
Men and body image: Are males satisfied with their body weight?
.
Psychosomatic Medicine.
1987
,
49
:
626
634
.

(6)

Davis
C
:
Body image and weight preoccupation: A comparison between exercising and non-exercising women
.
Appetite.
1990
,
15
:
13
21
.

(7)

Calfas
KJ
,
Sallis
JF
,
Lovato
CY
,
Campbell
J
:
Physical activity and its determinants before and after college graduation
.
Medicine, Exercise, Nutrition, & Health.
1994
,
3
:
323
334
.

(8)

Fisher
E
,
Thompson
JK
:
A comparative evaluation of cognitive-behavioral therapy vs. exercise therapy for the treatment of body image disturbance: Preliminary findings
.
Behavior Modification.
1994
,
18
:
171
185
.

(9)

Tucker
LA
,
Maxwell
K
:
Effects of weight training on the emotional well-being and body image of females: Predictors of greatest benefit
.
American Journal of Health Promotion.
1992
,
6
:
338
344
.

(10)

Tucker
LA
,
Mortell
R
:
Comparison of the effects of walking and weight training programs on body image in middle-aged women: An experimental study
.
American Journal of Health Promotion.
1993
,
8
:
34
42
.

(11)

Matheson
H
,
Crawford-Wright
A
:
An examination of eating disorder profiles in student obligatory and non-obligatory exercisers
.
Journal of Sport Behavior.
2000
,
23
:
42
50
.

(12)

Sarkin
JA
,
Marshall
SJ
,
Larson
KA
,
Sallis
JF
,
Calfas
KJ
:
A comparison of recruitment methods to a health promotion program for university seniors
.
Preventive Medicine.
1998
,
27
:
562
571
.

(13)

Sallis
JF
,
Hovell
MF
:
Determinants of exercise behavior
.
Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews.
1990
,
18
:
307
330
.

(14)

Bandura
A
:
Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory.
1986
;
Englewood Cliffs, NJ
:
Prentice Hall, Inc.
.

(15)

Prochaska
JO
,
Marcus
BH
:
The Transtheoretical Model: Application to exercise
. In
Dishman
R
(ed),
Advances in Exercise Adherence.
1994
;
Champaign, IL
:
Human Kinetics
,
161
180
.

(16)

Sallis
JF
,
Calfas
KJ
,
Nichols
JF
, et al. :
Evaluation of a university course to promote physical activity: Project GRAD
.
Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport.
1999
,
70
:
1
10
.

(17)

Garner
DM
,
Olmstead
MP
:
Eating Disorder Inventory Manual.
1984
;
New York
:
Psychological Assessment Resources
.

(18)

Blair
SN
:
How to assess exercise habits and physical fitness
. In
Matarazzo
JD
,
Herd
JA
,
Miller
NE
,
Weiss
SM
(eds),
Behavioral Health: A Handbook of Health Enhancement and Disease Prevention.
1984
;
New York
:
Wiley
,
424
447
.

(19)

Gross
LD
,
Sallis
JF
,
Buono
MJ
,
Roby
JA
,
Nelson
JA
:
Reliability of interviewers using the seven-day physical activity recall
.
Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport.
1990
,
61
:
321
325
.

(20)

Sarkin
J
,
Campbell
J
,
Gross
L
, et al. :
Project GRAD Seven-Day Physical Activity Recall Interviewer's Manual
.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise.
1997
,
29
:
S91
S102
.

(21)

Montoye
HJ
,
Kemper
HCG
,
Saris
WHM
,
Washburn
RA
:
Measuring Physical Activity and Energy Expenditure.
1996
;
Champaign, IL
:
Human Kinetics
.

(22)

Marcus
BH
,
Rakowski
W
,
Rossi
JS
:
Assessing motivational readiness and decision making regarding exercise
.
Health Psychology.
1992
,
11
:
257
261
.

(23)

Killen
JD
,
Taylor
CB
,
Hayward
C
, et al. :
Pursuit of thinness and onset of eating disorder symptoms in a community sample of adolescent girls: A three-year prospective analysis
.
International Journal of Eating Disorders.
1994
,
16
:
227
238
.

(24)

Woodside
DB
,
Garfinkel
PE
:
Age of onset in eating disorders
.
International Journal of Eating Disorders.
1992
,
12
:
31
36
.

This content is only available as a PDF.