Introspection and the Würzburg School
Implications for Experimental Psychology Today
Abstract
Abstract. In the early 20th century, scholars of the so-called Würzburg School departed from the conventional approach of psychological enquiry and developed a unique type of introspection that uncovered promising findings and paved the road for important developments in experimental psychology. Despite their early success, introspection was subsequently criticized and the Würzburg School disappeared soon after its protagonists had died or separated. The classical explanation for this development is that introspection has ultimately been a subjective and flawed endeavor. In the current paper we argue, by contrast, that the way the Würzburgers conducted introspection was in fact more of an extended type of third-person observation, not a genuine form of first-person research. Hence, their approach did not constitute a strong counterweight to the emerging third-person doctrine of the time and there was thus little need to maintain introspection as an independent paradigm. Such methodological aspects, as well as, biographical and historical factors contributed to the decline of introspection more so than the claim that introspection is a flawed approach per se. We suggest that a more direct form of introspection is needed to explore important phenomena within psychology which so far have been often approached one-sidedly.
References
(1905). Über die Willenstätigkeit und das Denken
[On the activity of volition and thinking] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/berdiewillenstt01achgoog. (2017) In M. A. WirtzEd., Dorsch – Lexikon der Psychologie. Retrieved from https://portal.hogrefe.com/dorsch/aktpsychologie/. Göttingen, Germany: Hogrefe
(1985).
Die experimentelle Psychologie an den deutschsprachigen Universitäten von der Wilhelminischen Zeit bis zum Nationalsozialismus [Experimental psychology at German universities from the Wilhelminian era to National Socialism] . In M. G. AshU. GeuterEds., Geschichte der deutschen Psychologie im 20. Jahrhundert (pp. 45–82). Opladen, Germany: Westdeutscher Verlag.(1999).
Die Würzburger Schule – Kontext, Praxis, Rezeption [The Würzburg School – context, practice, impact] . In W. JankeW. SchneiderEds., Hundert Jahre Institut für Psychologie und Würzburger Schule der Denkpsychologie (pp. 57–74). Göttingen, Germany: Hogrefe.(1989). Brentano und Mills Methode der beschreibenden Analyse
[Brentano and Mills’ method of descriptive analysis] . Brentano Studien, 2, 63–78.(1997). Von Brentano zu Külpe. Die Deskriptive Psychologie Brentanos und die „Würzburger Schule“ der Denkpsychologie
[From Brentano to Külpe. Brentano’s descriptive psychology and the “Würzburg School” of thought-psychology] . Brentano Studien, 7, 31–52.(2011).
Cognitive Phenomenology: An Introduction . In T. BayneM. MontagueEds., Cognitive Phenomenology (pp. 1–34). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.(2015).
Karl Bühler . In W. WolfradtE. Billmann-MahechaA. StockEds., Deutschsprachige Psychologinnen und Psychologen 1933–1945 (pp. 58–60). Wiesbaden, Germany: Springer.(2012). Neurophenomenology, an ongoing practice of/in consciousness. Constructivist Foundations, 7, 165–171.
(2011). Oswald Külpe (1862–1915) und die Dorpater religionspsychologische Schule
[Oswald Külpe (1862–1915) and the Dorpat School of psychology of religion] . In N. AngermannW. LenzK. MaierEds., Geisteswissenschaften und Publizistik im Baltikum des 19. und frühen 20. Jahrhunderts (pp. 483–511). Retrieved from http://stephanbitter.fjjt.de/veroeffentlichungen/(1950). A history of experimental psychology (2nd ed.). New Jersey, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
(1953). A history of introspection. Psychological Bulletin, 3, 169–189. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0090793
(1874). Psychologie vom empirischen Standpunkte
[Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/psychologievome01brengoog, Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint (
A. C. Rancurello, D. D. Terrell & L. L. McAllister , Trans.).(2013).
The history of introspection revisited . In J. W. CleggEd., Self-observation in the social sciences (pp. 25–43). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.(1968). On the origin of behaviorism. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 4, 143–151. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6696(196804)4:2<::AID-JHBS2300040201>3.0.CO;2-F
(1907). Tatsachen und Probleme zu einer Psychologie der Denkvorgänge. Über Gedanken
[Facts and problems of a psychology of thinking processes. About thoughts] . Archiv für die Gesamte Psychologie, 9, 297–365.(1908). Antwort auf die von W. Wundt erhobenen Einwände gegen die Methode der Selbstbeobachtung an experimentell erzeugten Erlebnissen
[Answer to W. Wundt and his objections against the method of self-observation of experimentally induced experiences] . Archiv für die Gesamte Psychologie, 12, 93–122. Retrieved from http://www.mpi.nl/publications/escidoc-2304835(1980). The history of introspection reconsidered. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 16, 241–262. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6696(198007)16:3<241::AIDJHBS2300160306>3.0.CO;2-O
(1980). Verbal reports as data. Psychological Review, 87, 215–251. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.87.3.215
(1993). Protocol analysis. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
(2012). Husserl’s Crisis as a crisis of psychology. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 43, 493–503. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.shpsc.2011.11.008
(2011). From second‐order cybernetics to enactive cognitive science: Varela’s turn from epistemology to phenomenology. Systems Research and Behavioral Science, 28, 631–645. https://doi.org/10.1002/sres.1116
(2008). The phenomenological mind. An introduction to philosophy of mind and cognitive science. London, UK: Routledge.
(1911).
Über das Wesen und die Bedeutung der Einfühlung [About the essence and meaning of empathy] . In F. SchumannEd., Bericht über den IV. Kongreß für experimentelle Psychologie (pp. 29–73). Leipzig, Germany: Barth.(1974). Beiträge zur Phänomenologie des ästhetischen Genusses
[Contributions to the phenomenology of aesthetic pleasure] (2nd ed.). Tübingen, Germany: Max Niemayer.(2010). Phenomenological psychology: A brief history and its challenges. Journal of Phenomenological Psychology, 41, 145–179.
(1996). Faktor Mensch im Krieg. Der Eintritt der Psychologie und Psychotechnik in den Krieg
[The human factor and war. Psychology and psychotechnic entering war] . Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte, 19, 131–143. https://doi.org/10.1002/bewi.19960190211(2004). Die Gesellschaft für experimentelle Psychologie, später Deutsche Gesellschaft für Psychologie und ihre Kongresse 1904 bis 1932
[Society for Experimental Psychology, later German Society for Psychology, and its congresses 1904 to 1932] . Psychologische Rundschau, 55, 12–20.(1994). Denkpsychologie – Kritischer Realismus. Eine wissenschaftshistorische Studie zum Werk Oswald Külpes
[Thought psychology – critical realism. A historical study about the work of Oswald Külpe] . Frankfurt am Main, Germany: Peter Lang.(2005).
Oswald Külpe . In H. E. LückR. MillerEds., Illustrierte Geschichte der Psychologie (pp. 54–55). Weinheim, Germany: Beltz.(2013). An introduction to the history of psychology (7th ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
(1993). Phänomenologie und Experiment in der Psychologie
[Phenomenology and experiment in psychology] . Journal für Psychologie, 1, 44–54. http://nbnresolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-21472(1997). William James und die Würzburger. Aspekte eines merkwürdigen Stücks psychologischer Rezeptionsgeschichte
[William James and the Würzburgers. Aspects of an odd part of history of psychology] . Brentano Studien, 7, 183–195.(1996). The Würzburg School. Retrieved from http://www.psychologie.uni-wuerzburg.de/w_schule/
(1951). Thinking: an introduction to its experimental psychology. Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/thinkinganintrod031641mbp
(2006). The descriptive experience sampling method. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 5, 271–301. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11097-006-9024-0
(1900). Logische Untersuchungen (Vol. 1,
[Logical Investigation] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/logischeuntersuc01hussuoft(1901). Logische Untersuchungen (Vol. 2,
[Logical Investigation] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/logischeuntersuc00hussuoft(1996). Carl Stumpfs Wirken für die descriptive Psychologie
[Carl Stumpf bearing on descriptive psychology] . Brentano Studien, 6, 67–102.(2001). Carl Stumpfs Analysen des Hörempfindens und die Implikation der “Würzburger” für die Evolutionäre Erkenntnistheorie
[Carl Stumps analysis of listening and implications for the “Würzburgers” for evolutionary epistemology] . Brentano Studien, 9, 167–198.(1999). Psychological knowledge. A social history and philosophy. London, UK: Routledge.
(1893a). Anfänge und Aussichten der experimentellen Psychologie
[Beginnings and perspectives of experimental psychlogy] . Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie, 6, 170–189. https://doi.org/10.1515/agph.1893.6.2.170(1893b). Psychologie. Auf experimenteller Grundlage dargestellt
[Psychology. Based on experimental grounds] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/grundrissderpsyc00kl(1904). Versuche über Abstraktion
[Experiments about abstraction] . In F. Schumann (Ed.), Bericht über den 1. Kongress für experimentelle Psychologie in Giessen vom 18. bis 21. April 1904 (pp. 56–71). Leipzig, Germany: Barth.(1912a). Über die moderne Psychologie des Denkens
[On modern psychology of thinking] . Internationale Monatsschrift für Wissenschaft, Kultur und Technik, 6, 1069–1110.(1912b). Psychologie und Medizin
[Psychology and medicine] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/b28118911(1914). Über die Methoden der psychologischen Forschung
[About the methods of psychological research] . Internationale Monatsschrift für Wissenschaft, Kultur und Technik, 8, 1053–1070.(1910). Einleitung in die Philosophie
[Introduction to philosophy] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/einleitungindiep00kluoft(1919). Einleitung in die Philosophie
[Introduction to philosophy] . A. Messer (Ed.) (9th ed.). Leipzig, Germany: Hirzel.(1920). Vorlesungen über Psychologie
[Lectures on psychology] . K. Bühler (Ed.). Leipzig, Germany: Hirzel.(1978). Oswald Külpe and the Würzburg School. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 14, 132–141. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6696(197804)14:2<132::AID-JHBS2300140206>3.0.CO;2-4
(2003). Neurophenomenology integrating subjective experience and brain dynamics in the neuroscience of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 10, 31–52.
(2002). Geschichte der Psychologie. Strömungen, Schulen, Entwicklungen
[History of psychology. Schools and developments] (3rd ed.). Stuttgart, Germany: Kohlhammer.(1986). The disappearance of introspection. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
(1994).
Die Würzburger Schule und ihre Bedeutung für die Kognitionswissenschaft [The Würzburg School and its relevance for cognitive science] . In H. GundlachEd., Arbeiten zur Psychologiegeschichte (pp. 141–158). Göttingen, Germany: Hogrefe.(2005).
Die Würzburger Schule [The Würzburg School] . In H. E. LückR. MillerEds., Illustrierte Geschichte der Psychologie (pp. 50–53). Weinheim, Germany: Beltz.(2007). A history of modern experimental psychology: From James and Wundt to cognitive science. Cambridge, MA: MIT.
(1901). Experimentell-psychologische Untersuchungen über das Urteil. Eine Einleitung in die Logik
[Experimental psychological investigation of judgment. An introduction to logic] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/experimentellpsy00marb(1930).
Autobiography of Karl Marbe . In C. MurchisonEd., History of psychology in autobiography (Vol. 1, pp. 181–213). Retrieved from http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Marbe/murchison.htm(1945).
Selbstbiographie des Psychologen Geheimrat Prof. Dr. Karl Marbe in Würzburg [Autobiography of the psychologist Prof. Dr. Karl Marbe in Würzburg] . In E. Abderhalden. Haller, Germany: Akademie der Naturforscher.(2016).
Assoziationismus [Associationism] . In M. A. WirtzEd., Dorsch – Lexikon der Psychologie. Göttingen, Germany. Retrieved from https://portal.hogrefe.com/dorsch/assoziationismus/(1901). Zur qualitativen Untersuchung der Assoziation
[On the qualitative investigation of association] . Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane, 26, 1–3. Retrieved from http://echo.mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de/ECHOdocuView?url=/permanent/vlp/lit25188/index.meta(1908). Empfindung und Denken
[Feeling and thinking] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/empfindungundde00messgoog(1912). Husserls Phänomenologie in ihrem Verhältnis zur Psychologie
[The relation of Husserl’s phenomenology to psychology] . Retrieved from http://www.ophen.org/pub-137154(1922). Psychologie
[Psychology] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/psychologie00mess(2005).
Otto Selz . In H. E. LückR. MillerEds., Illustrierte Geschichte der Psychologie (pp. 56–57). Weinheim, Germany: Beltz.(2016). Franz Brentano and the beginning of experimental psychology: Implications for the study of psychological phenomena today. Psychological Research, 82, 245–254.
(2000). Introduction to phenomenology. London, UK: Routledge.
(2014).
Das Selbst [The Self] . In K. JonasW. StroebeM. HewstoneEds., Sozialpsychologie (6th ed., pp. 141–196). Berlin, Germany: Springer.(2010).
Einleitung [Introduction] . In G. MeyK. MruckEds., Handbuch Qualitative Forschung in der Psychologie (pp. 11–32). Wiesbaden, Germany: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.(1900). Experimentelle Beiträge zur Lehre vom Gedächtnis
[Experimental works about the lessons on memory] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/b28111916(1998).
Die mannigfachen Beziehungen zwischen Philosophie und Psychologie. Das Verhältnis Edmund Husserls zur Würzburger Schule in philosophie-, psychologie- und institutionengeschichtlicher Perspektive [The manifold relations between philosophy and psychology. The relation between Edmund Husserl and the Würzburg School in philosophical, psychological, and institutional history] . In J. JahnkeJ. FahrenbergR. StegieE. BauerEds., Psychologiegeschichte – Beziehungen zu Philosophie und Grenzgebiete (pp. 318–345). München, Germany: Profil.(1951).
Oswald Külpe and the Würzburg School . The American Journal of Psychology, 64, 4–19. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/1418592(1903). Gefühl und Bewusstseinslage. Eine kritisch-experimentelle Studie
[Feeling and situation of consciousness. A critical experimental study] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/gefhlundbewusst00orthgoog(2006). Describing one’s subjective experience in the second person: An interview method for the science of consciousness. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 5, 229–269. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11097-006-9022-2
(2009). The validity of first-person descriptions as authenticity and coherence. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 16, 252–284.
(2009). Listening from within. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 16, 363–404.
(2013). A gap in Nisbett and Wilson’s findings? A first-person access to our cognitive processes. Consciousness and Cognition, 22, 654–669. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.concog.2013.02.004
(1963). Phänomenologie des Wollens. Eine psychologische Analyse
[Phenomenology of willing. A psychological analysis] (3rd ed.). München, Germany: Barth.(1996). Positivismus und Phänomenologie
[Positivism and phenomenology] . Brentano Studien, 6, 297–312.(1982).
Bewusstseinsforschung und Bewusstsein in Pfänders Phänomenologie des Wollens [Research on consciousness and mind in Pfänder’s phenomenology of willing] . In H. SpiegelberE. Avé-LallemantEds., Pfänder-Studien (pp. 155–180). The Hague, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff.(1988). Brentano und die Münchener Phänomenologie
[Brentano and the Munich phenomenology] . Brentano Studien, 1, 97–107.(2014).
Introspection . In E. N. ZaltaEd., The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (summer 2014 ed.). Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/introspection/(1971). The phenomenological movement. A historical introduction (2nd ed., Vol. 1), The Hague, The Netherlands: Nartinus Mijhoff.
(2016). Denkpsychologie
[Psychology of thinking] . In W. StanglEd., Lexikon für Psychologie und Pädagogik. Retrieved from http://lexikon.stangl.eu/17403/denkpsychologie/(1894/1968). Die Philosophie der Freiheit
[The philosophy of freedom] . Dornach, Switzerland: Verlag am Goetheanum.(2010). The psychology of thinking before the cognitive revolution: Otto Selz on problems, schemas, and creativity. History of Psychology, 13, 2–24. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0017442
(1985). Geschichte für die Gegenwart: Vorträge und Aufsätze zur Psychologiegeschichte
[History for present: Lectures and articles about the history of psychology] (Vol. 3). Passau, Germany: Passavia.(1996). Neurophenomenology: A methodological remedy for the hard problem. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 3, 330–349.
(1999). First-person methodologies: What, why, how. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 6, 1–14.
(1904). Experimentelle Beiträge zu einer Theorie des Denkens
[Experimental contributions to a theory of thinking] . Leipzig, Germany: Engelmann.(2013). Psychologie. Wissenschaftstheorie, philosophische Grundlagen und Geschichte
[Psychology. Theory of science, philosophical foundations and history] (3rd ed.). Stuttgart, Germany: Kolhammer.(2016). Exploring the behavioral, experiential, and conceptual dimensions of the self. Introducing a new phenomenological approach. European Psychologist, 21, 180–194. https://doi.org/10.1027/1016-9040/a000263
(2018). Introspection in Psychology: Its contribution to theory and method in memory research. European Psychologist, 23, 206–216. https://doi.org/10.1027/1016-9040/a000296
(in press). Researching mind wandering from a first‐person perspective. Applied Cognitive Psychology, https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.3406
(2015a). The challenges and opportunities of first-person inquiry in experimental psychology. New Ideas in Psychology, 36, 38–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.newideapsych.2014.09.001
(2015b). The behavioral, experiential and conceptual dimensions of psychological phenomena. New Ideas in Psychology, 39, 23–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.newideapsych.2015.07.002
(1994). The proper protocol: Validity and completeness of verbal reports. Psychological Science, 5, 249–252. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.1994.tb00621.x
(2010).
Introspektion [Introspection] . In G. MeyK. MruckEds., Handbuch Qualitative Forschung in der Psychologie (pp. 491–505). Wiesbaden, Germany: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.(1983). Strukturphänomenologie
[Structural phenomenology] . Dornach, Switzerland: Gideon Spicker.(1874). Grundzüge der physiologischen Psychologie
[Principles of physiological psychology] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/b21905393(1888). Selbstbeobachtung und innere Wahrnehmung
[Self-observation and inner perception] . PhilosophischeStudien, 4, 292–309. Retrieved from http://echo.mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de/MPIWG:Y8YNX56Y(1904). Völkerpsychologie: Eine Untersuchung der Entwicklungsgesetze von Sprache, Mythus und Sitte
[Ethnopsychology: an investigation of developmental laws of language, myth and morals] (2nd ed., Vol. 1). Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/vlkerpsychologi00unkngoog(1907). Über Ausfrageexperimente und über die Methoden zur Psychologie des Denkens
[On interrogation experiments and the methods of a psychology of thinking] . Retrieved from http://psychologie.biphaps.uni-leipzig.de/wundt/opera/wundt/Ausfrexp/Inhalt.htm(1908). Grundzüge der physiologischen Psychologie
[Outlines of physiological psychology] . Retrieved from https://archive.org/details/grundzgederphys23wundgoog(1913). Die Psychologie im Kampf ums Dasein
[Psychology struggling for existence] . Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/10111/UIUCBB:wundwi0001psykam(1998).
Reine Psychologie und Philosophie als strenge Wissenschaft – Die Rezeption der Husserlschen Phänomenologie durch die Würzburger Schule [Pure psychology and philosophy as rigorous science – The Würzburg School and Husserl’s phenomenology] . In J. JahnkeJ. FahrenbergR. StegieE. BauerEds., Psychologiegeschichte – Beziehungen zu Philosophie und Grenzgebiete (pp. 347–366). München, Germany: Profil.(2018). First-person experiments in thinking. European Psychologist, 23, 189–205. https://doi.org/10.1027/1016-9040/a000301
