Abstract
We explore the features of a corpus of naturally occurring word substitution speech errors. Words are replaced by more imageable competitors in semantic substitution errors but not in phonological substitution errors. Frequency effects in these errors are complex and the details prove difficult for any model of speech production. We argue that word frequency mainly affects phonological errors. Both semantic and phonological substitutions are constrained by phonological and syntactic similarity between the target and intrusion. We distinguish between associative and shared-feature semantic substitutions. Associative errors originate from outside the lexicon, while shared-feature errors arise within the lexicon and occur when particular properties of the targets make them less accessible than the intrusion. Semantic errors arise early while accessing lemmas from a semantic-conceptual input, while phonological errors arise late when accessing phonological forms from lemmas. Semantic errors are primarily sensitive to the properties of the semantic field involved, whereas phonological errors are sensitive to phonological properties of the targets and intrusions.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Astell, A. J., & Harley, T. A. (1996). Tip-of-the-tongue states and lexical access in dementia. Brain and Language, 54, 196-215.
Baars, B. J., Motley, M. T., & McKay, D. G. (1975). Output editing for lexical status from artificially elicited slips of the tongue. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 14, 382-291.
Barry, C. (1984). Consistency and types of semantic errors in a deep dyslexic patient. In R. N. Malatesha & H. A. Whitaker (Eds.), Dyslexia: A global issue (pp. 311-337). The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
Beattie, G. W., & Butterworth, B. L. (1979). Contextual probability and word frequency as determinants of pauses and errors in spontaneous speech. Language and Speech, 22, 201-211.
Bock, J. K. (1982). Toward a cognitive psychology of syntax: Information processing contributions to sentence formulation. Psychological Review, 89, 1-47.
Bock, J. K. (1987). Co-ordinating words and syntax in speech plans. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Progress in the psychology of language, Vol. 3 (pp. 337-390). London: Erlbaum.
Burke, D. M., MacKay, D. G., Worthley, J. S., & Wade, E. (1991). On the tip of the tongue: What causes word finding failures in young and older adults? Journal of Memory and Language, 30, 542-579.
Butterworth, B. (1979). Hesitation and the production of verbal paraphasias and neologisms in jargon aphasia. Brain and Language, 8, 133-161.
Butterworth, B. (1982). Speech errors: Old data in search of new theories. In A. Cutler (Ed.), Slips of the tongue and language production (pp. 73-108). Amsterdam: Mouton.
Butterworth, B. (1989). Lexical access in speech production. In W. Marslen-Wilson (Ed.), Lexical representation and process (pp. 108-135). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Caramazza, A. (1997). How many levels of processing are there in lexical access? Cognitive Neuropsychology, 14, 177-208.
Caramazza, A., & Miozzo, M. (1997). The relation between syntactic and phonological knowledge in lexical access: Evidence from the 'tip-of-the-tongue' phenomenon. Cognition, 64, 309-343.
Coltheart, M. (1980). The semantic error: Types and theories. In M. Coltheart, K. Patterson, & J. C. Marshall (Eds.), Deep dyslexia (pp. 146-160). London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Cutler, A. (1981). Making up materials is a confounded nuisance, or: Will we be able to run any psycholinguistic experiments at all in 1990? Cognition, 10, 65-70.
Cutler, A. (1982). The reliability of speech error data. In A. Cutler (Ed.), Slips of the tongue and language production (pp. 7-28). Berlin: Mouton.
Dell, G. S. (1986). A spreading-activation theory of retrieval in sentence production. Psychological Review, 93, 283-321.
Dell, G. S. (1990). Effects of frequency and vocabulary type on phonological speech errors. Language and Cognitive Processes, 5, 313-349.
Dell, G. S., & Reich, P. A. (1981). Stages in sentence production: An analysis of speech error data. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 20, 611-629.
Dell, G. S., & O'Seaghdha, P. G. (1991). Mediated and convergent lexical priming in language production: A comment on Levelt et al. (1991). Psychological Review, 98, 604-614.
Dell, G. S., & O'Seaghdha, P. G. (1992). Stages of lexical access in language production. Cognition, 42, 287-314.
del Viso, S., Igoa, J. M., & Garcia-Albea, J. E. (1991). On the autonomy of phonological encoding: Evidence from slips of the tongue in Spanish. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 20, 161-185.
Ellis, A. W. (1985). The production of spoken words: A cognitive neuropsychological perspective. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Progress in the psychology of language, Vol. 2 (pp. 107-147). London: Erlbaum.
Ellis, A. W., Miller, D., & Sin, G. (1983). Wernicke's aphasia and normal language processing: A case study in cognitive neuropsychology. Cognition, 15, 111-144.
Fay, D., & Cutler, A. (1977). Malapropisms and the structure of the mental lexicon. Linguistic Inquiry, 8, 505-520.
Ferber, R. (1991). Slips of the tongue or slips of the ear? On the perception and transcription of naturalistic slips of the tongue. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 20, 105-121.
Francis, W. N., & Kuçera, H. (1982). Frequency analysis of English usage: Lexicon and grammar. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin company.
Fromkin, V., & Rodman, R. (1998). An introduction to language, 6th ed. Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace.
Freud, S. (1975). The psychopathology of everyday life. (Trans. A. Tyson.) Harmondsworth: Penguin. (Originally published 1901.)
Fromkin, V. A. (1971). The non-anomalous nature of anomalous utterances. Language, 47, 27-52.
Garrett, M. F. (1976). Syntactic processes in sentence production. In R. J. Wales & E. Walker (Eds.), New approaches to language mechanisms (pp. 231-255). Amsterdam: North Holland.
Garrett, M. F. (1980). Levels of processing in sentence production. In B. L. Butterworth (Ed.), Language production, Vol. 1, Speech and talk, (pp. 177-220). London: Academic Press.
Garrett, M. F. (1982). Production of speech: Observations from normal and pathological language use. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Normality and pathology in cognitive functions (pp. 19-76). London: Academic Press.
Garrett, M. F. (1992). Disorders of lexical selection. Cognition, 42, 143-180.
Garrett, M. F. (1993). Errors and their relevance for models of language production. In Blanken, G., Dittman, J., Grimm, H., Marshall, J. C., & Wallesch, C.-W. (Eds.), Linguisitic disorders and pathologies: An international handbook. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Garrett, M. F. (1975). The analysis of sentence production. In G. H. Bower (Ed.), The Psychology of learning and motivation (Vol. 9, pp. 133-177). New York: Academic Press.
Harley, T. A. (1984). A critique of top-down independent levels models of speech production: Evidence from non-plan-internal speech errors. Cognitive Science, 8, 191-219.
Harley, T. A. (1988). Automatic and executive processing in semantic and syntactic planning: A dual process model of speech production. In M. Zock & G. Sabah (Eds.), Advances in natural language generation: An interdisciplinary perspective, Vol. 1 (pp. 160-172). London: Pinter.
Harley, T. A. (1990a). Paragrammatisms: Syntactic disturbance or failure of control? Cognition, 34, 85-91.
Harley, T. A. (1990b). Environmental contamination of normal speech. Applied Psycholinguistics, 11, 45-72.
Harley, T. A. (1993). Phonological activation of semantic competitors during lexical access in speech production. Language and Cognitive Processes, 8, 291-309.
Harley, T. A. (1995). Connectionist models of anomia: A comment on Nickels. Language and Cognitive Processes, 10, 47-58.
Harley, T. A. (1999). Will one stage and no feedback suffice in lexicalization? Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 1-75.
Harley, T. A., & Bown, H. (1998). What causes tip-of-the-tongue states? British Journal of Psychology, 89, 151-174.
Harley, T. A., & MacAndrew, S. B. G. (1992). Modelling paraphasias in normal and aphasic speech. Proceedings of the 14th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society (pp. 378-383). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Harley, T. A., & MacAndrew, S. B. G. (1995). Interactive models of lexicalisation: Some constraints from speech error, picture naming, and neuropsychological data. In J. Levy, D. Bairaktaris, J. Bullinaria, & D. Cairns (Eds.), Connectionist models of memory and language (pp. 311-331). London: UCL Press.
Hinton, G. E., & Shallice, T. (1991). Lesioning an attractor network: Investigations of acquired dyslexia. Psychological Review, 98, 74-95.
Holland, A. L., McBurney, D. H., Moossy, J., & Reinmuth, O. M. (1985). The dissolution of language in Pick's disease with neurofibrillary tangles: A case study. Brain and Language, 24, 36-58.
Hotopf, W. H. N. (1980). Semantic similarity as a factor in whole-word slips of the tongue. In V. Fromkin (Ed.), Errors in linguistic performance (pp. 97-109). New York: Academic Press.
Howard, D., & Orchard-Lisle, V. (1984). On the origin of semantic errors in naming: Evidence from the case of a global aphasic. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 1, 163-190.
Humphreys, G. W., Riddoch, M. J., & Quinlan, P. T. (1988). Cascade processes in picture identification. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 5, 67-103.
Jescheniak, J. D., & Levelt, W. J. M. (1994). Word frequency effects in speech production: Retrieval of syntactic information and of phonological form. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 20, 824-843.
Jones, G. V., & Langford, S. (1987). Phonological blocking in the tip of the tongue state. Cognition, 26, 115-122.
Jones, G. V. (1989). Back to Woodworth: Role of interlopers in the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon. Memory & Cognition, 17, 69-76.
Kay, J., & Ellis, A. W. (1987). A cognitive neuropsychological case study of anomia: Implications for psychological models of word retrieval. Brain, 110, 613-629.
Kempen, G., & Huijbers, P. (1983). The lexicalisation process in sentence production and naming: Indirect election of words. Cognition, 14, 185-209.
La Heij, W. (1988). Components of Stroop-like interference in picture naming. Memory & Cognition, 16, 400-410.
La Heij, W., Starreveld, P. A., & Steehouwer, L. C. (1993). Semantic interference and orthographic facilitation in definition naming. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 19, 352-368.
Levelt, W. J. M. (1983). Monitoring and self-repair in speech. Cognition, 14, 41-104.
Levelt, W. J. M. (1989). Speaking: From intention to articulation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press/Bradford Books.
Levelt, W. J. M. (1992). Accessing words in speech production: Stages, processes and representations. Cognition, 42, 1-22.
Levelt, W. J. M., Roelofs, A., & Meyer, A. S. (1999). A theory of lexical access in speech production. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 1-75.
Levelt, W. J. M., Schriefers, H., Vorberg, D., Meyer, A. S., Pechmann, T., & Havinga, J. (1991a). The time course of lexical access in speech production: A study of picture naming. Psychological Review, 98, 122-142.
Levelt, W. J. M., Schriefers, H., Vorberg, D., Meyer, A. S., Pechmann, T., & Havinga, J. (1991b). Normal and deviant lexical processing: Reply to Dell and O'Seaghdha (1991). Psychological Review, 98, 615-618.
Martin, N., Dell, G. S., Saffran, E. M., & Schwartz, M. F. (1994). Origins of paraphasias in deep dysphasia: Testing the consequences of a decay impairment to an interactive spreading activation model of lexical retrieval. Brain and Language, 47, 609-660.
Meyer, A. S., & Bock, K. (1992). The tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon: Blocking or partial activation? Memory & Cognition, 20, 715-726.
Morton, J. (1970). A functional model for human memory. In D. A. Norman (Ed.), Models of human memory (pp. 203-260). New York: Academic Press.
Nickels, L. (1995). Getting it right? Using aphasic naming errors to evaluate theoretical models of spoken word recognition. Language and Cognitive Processes, 10, 13-45.
Plaut, D. C., & Shallice, T. (1991). Effects of word abstractness in a connectionist model of deep dyslexia. Proceedings of the 13th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society (pp. 73-78). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Plaut, D. C., & Shallice, T. (1993). Deep dyslexia: A case study of connectionist neuropsychology, Cognitive Neuropsychology, 10, 377-500.
Quinlan, P. T. (1992). Oxford psycholinguistic database. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Roelofs, A. (1992). A spreading-activation theory of lemma retrieval in speaking. Cognition, 42, 107-142.
Roelofs, A. (1993). Testing a non-decompositional theory of lemma retrieval in speaking: Retrieval of verbs. Cognition, 47, 59-87.
Schriefers, H. (1990). Lexical and conceptual factors in the naming of relations. Cognitive Psychology, 22, 111-142.
Schriefers, H., Meyer, A. S., & Levelt, W. J. M. (1990). Exploring the time course of lexical access in language production: Picture-word interference studies. Journal of Memory and Language, 29, 86-102.
Seymour, P. H. K. (1973). A model for reading, naming, and comprehension. British Journal of Psychology, 64, 35-49.
Shallice, T., & McGill, J. (1978). The origin of mixed errors. In J. Requin (Ed.), Attention and performance VII (pp. 193-208). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Snodgrass, J. G. (1984). Concepts and their surface representations. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behaviour, 23, 3-22.
Starreveld, P. A., & La Heij, W. (1995). Semantic interference, orthographic facilitation, and their interaction in naming tasks. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 21, 686-698.
Stemberger, J. P. (1984). Structural errors in normal and agrammatic speech. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 1, 281-313.
Stemberger, J. P. (1985). An interactive activation model of language production. In A. W. Ellis (Ed.), Progress in the psychology of language, Vol. 1 (pp. 143-186). London: Erlbaum.
Tent, J., & Clark, J. E. (1980). An experimental investigation into the perception of slips of the tongue. Journal of Phonetics, 8, 317-325.
Theios, J., & Amrhein, P. C. (1989). Theoretical analysis of the cognitive processing of lexical and pictorial stimuli: Reading, naming, and visual and conceptual comparisons. Psychological Review, 96, 5-24.
Vanderwart, M. (1984). Priming by pictures in lexical decision. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 23, 67-83.
Vitevitch, M. S. (1997). The neighborhood characteristics of malapropisms. Language and Speech, 40, 211-228.
Warren, C., & Morton, J. (1982). The effects of priming on picture recognition. British Journal of Psychology, 73, 117-130.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Harley, T.A., MacAndrew, S.B.G. Constraints Upon Word Substitution Speech Errors. J Psycholinguist Res 30, 395–418 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1010421724343
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1010421724343