Modelling the contribution of changes in family life to time trends in adolescent conduct problems
Introduction
Recent decades have seen substantial changes in family life—including rising divorce rates, changes in socio-economic well being, and reductions in family size. The same period has also been marked by substantial increases in psychosocial disorders of youth, with increases in rates of crime, depression, suicide, and drug use in most Western societies since the second world war (Fombonne, 1998; Maughan, Iervolino, & Collishaw, 2005; Rutter & Smith, 1995). A key question with obvious policy and theoretical implications is whether changes in the family are responsible for the rise in young people's mental health problems.
To address this it is necessary to consider a number of related issues and questions. First, there is a wealth of evidence on risk factors that contribute to individual differences in mental health. Do changes in these same factors also account for overall level differences in mental health? Second, has the correlation among family risk factors changed? Third, does the association of family risk factors with child outcomes change as the prevalence of these factors in the population varies? Fourth, to what extent have reductions in prevalence or risk of some family factors offset any deleterious impact on child outcomes of increases in other risk domains? This study explores these issues by focusing on three well-established family risk indicators: family type, family income, and family size (Hill, 2002). The study examines the extent to which changes in their prevalence, patterning or association with conduct problems account for the documented increase in the prevalence of adolescent conduct problems (Collishaw, Maughan, Goodman, & Pickles, 2004).
The study will consider these issues in the context of trends in the UK over the last quarter of the twentieth century. The scope for generalising from findings about UK trends in adolescent experiences to other countries is an important issue. Many of the social trends discussed here (e.g. increasing rates of parental divorce, decreasing family size) affect not just families in the UK, but families in many countries and societies. Similarly, evidence for a deterioration in adolescent mental health comes from a number of different countries (Maughan et al., 2005; Rutter & Smith, 1995). Nevertheless, most explanations of secular change implicate society-level phenomena, and these may of course be relatively culture specific. There are significant cross-cultural differences in the rates of child and adolescent mental health problems (Crijnen, Achenbach, & Verhulst, 1997), and it would be no surprise if specific cohort differences also varied from country to country (e.g. in terms of timing, duration and extent of historical change). The current study examined the links between changes in family structure and income and trends in adolescent conduct problems in the UK. In doing so we hoped to highlight a number of important conceptual and methodological complexities that are of international relevance to research on trends in mental health.
In the UK, the annual divorce rate increased around seven-fold between 1958 and 2003 (Office for National Statistics, 2006). In the short term, almost all children of divorced and separated families experience a period of living in a single-parent family, while in the longer term many children of divorced parents live in stepfamilies. Population statistics show that rates of single parenthood in the UK increased sharply throughout the 1970s and 1980s – 7% of children lived in single-parent families in 1971, compared with 24% in 2005. In addition, a further 10% of children in 2005 lived in stepfamilies, primarily with their mother and stepfather (Office for National Statistics, 2006). One aim of the present study was to assess the extent to which changes in family type have contributed to trends in adolescent adjustment.
The socio-economic conditions in which teenagers have grown up have also changed. In particular, there has been a substantial increase in UK household disposable income with average income twice as high in 1999, compared with, and adjusted to, 1970 levels (Office for National Statistics, 2004). At the same time, however, there has been an increase in the number of families with children living in relative poverty, with the proportion with incomes below 60% of the median increasing from around 15% in the 1960s and 1970s to around 25% in the early 1990s, and since reducing to around 20% (Office for National Statistics, 2006). It has been suggested that population income inequalities are a more pertinent predictor of mental health problems and criminality than absolute disposable income (Kawachi, Kennedy, & Wilkinson, 1999).
Finally, the second-half of the 20th Century saw a considerable reduction in family size (Office for National Statistics, 2006). The proportion of families in the UK with three or more children declined from 43% in 1972 to 29% in 2005. Large family size has been highlighted as a risk factor for conduct problems both in historical and contemporary studies (Loeber & Farrington, 1998; Rutter, Tizard, & Whitmore, 1970), so it is plausible that there have been benefits for children's adjustment as a result of these reductions in family size.
Alongside a general consensus on the existence of adolescent mental health trends, reviews have also highlighted major methodological complexities in the field (Rutter & Smith, 1995). Changes in the official recording of crime and in the diagnosis and recognition of psychiatric disorders (e.g. ADHD and autism) have made it difficult to provide a clear picture of trends in youth mental disorder and criminality. Only a few studies have examined trends in adolescent emotional and behavioural outcomes using the same instruments at each time point (e.g. Achenbach, Dumenci, & Rescorla, 2003; Collishaw et al., 2004; Verhulst, van der Ende, & Rietbergen, 1997). Collishaw et al. (2004) assessed the extent to which conduct, hyperactive and emotional problems became more common over a 25-year period in three general population samples of UK adolescents. Results showed a substantial increase in adolescent conduct problems that affected males and females, all social classes and all family types. Further analyses using longitudinal data from the first two cohorts showed that long-term psychosocial outcomes for adolescents with conduct problems were equally poor, suggesting that observed trends in conduct problems were not simply the result of changes in reporting thresholds.
Establishing trends in adolescent mental health is complicated by a number of methodological difficulties—most obviously the need to use comparable measures at each time point. Testing explanations for such trends is even more difficult. To date, most people have looked at aggregate trends in disorder and hypothesised explanatory factors. Such comparisons may be helpful, but they are not conclusive. As described above, some family-level risk factors for conduct problems have become more prevalent. In particular, much attention has been paid to the increasing prevalence of parental divorce. Given that there is an association between parental divorce and adolescent adjustment (e.g. Fergusson, Horwood, & Lynskey, 1994; Hill & Maughan, 2001), it is plausible that trends in divorce have contributed to trends in adolescent outcomes. Taken alone, however, the coincidence of changes in adolescent adjustment and in family structure cannot prove a causal connection. In particular, it is important to consider the possibility that as risk factors change in their prevalence, so their associations with child adjustment may also vary. Evidence on parental divorce provides some interesting pointers.
Parental divorce is likely to be stressful and difficult for most parents and children. Nonetheless, commentators have argued that the dramatic increases in the divorce rate in recent decades is likely to mean that the conditions surrounding divorce will have changed and, as a result, that its negative impact on child outcomes may have diminished (Amato & Keith, 1991). As divorce becomes more common, these arguments suggest, associated stigma may be reduced; couples may separate at lower thresholds of marital discord than in the past; and families and society as a whole may be better prepared for managing the negative consequences of divorce.
To date, evidence on changes in associations between divorce and child outcomes is mixed. The limited UK evidence suggests little if any diminution of effects on educational (Ely, Richards, Wadsworth, & Elliott, 1999) or later mental health outcomes (Sigle-Rushton, Hobcraft, & Kiernan, 2005). A meta-analysis of the international literature about effects on children's academic, social and emotional outcomes published in the early 1990s initially supported the view that divorce had become less ‘toxic’ as it became more common, with lower effect sizes reported in studies published in the 1980s than in those conducted in the 1960s and 1970s (Amato & Keith, 1991). However, a recent update to this meta-analysis (Amato, 2001) has shown that effect sizes for studies published in the 1990s were significantly higher than those conducted in the 1980s, though not quite as high as those reported in the earliest studies. The issue is clearly a complex one, but current evidence lends some support to the view that as the prevalence of divorce has changed, its effects may also have moderated.
While a dilution of risk may be associated with some aspects of recent demographic change, other trends may be associated with increasing associations with child psychopathology. In relation to socio-economic disadvantage, for example, an increasing emphasis on individualist and materialist values in recent decades (Eckersley, 2006) may have resulted in the increased impact of socio-economic disadvantage on individuals’ mental well being. Again there is only scant empirical evidence with which to test this hypothesis. However, comparisons of self-reported depression and anxiety among adults in their thirties in the three British birth cohorts indicate the existence of social gradients in affective problems that have become more prominent over time (Ferri, Bynner, & Wadsworth, 2003).
There have been many social changes affecting children's families over recent decades. It is unclear whether and to what extent these changes are associated with trends in child well being. Our study addresses how far trends in three family demographic indicators can account for trends in adolescent conduct problems. Specifically, the study focuses on family type, family income and family size, and parent-rated conduct problems, assessed in comparable ways in nationally representative UK studies conducted in 1974, 1986 and 1999. First, changes in the prevalence and inter-correlation of the family indicators are summarised. Second, analyses test for changes in levels of association between these family indicators and adolescent conduct problems. Third, the study tests the extent to which trends in family life have contributed to trends in conduct problems.
Section snippets
Samples and design
The study used data collected as part of three general population surveys of children living in the UK-the National Child Development Study (NCDS), the 1970 British Cohort study (BCS70), and the 1999 British Child and Adolescent Mental Health Survey (B-CAMHS99). NCDS and BCS70 are prospective longitudinal studies of all children born in the UK in one week in 1958 (3–9 March) and 1970 (5–11 April), respectively. Ratings of conduct problems and information about family type, family income and
Response and attrition
The longitudinal nature of NCDS and BCS70 allowed an assessment of patterns of non-response at age 16. About 10,348 (61% of those with data at birth) in NCDS and 7234 (45%) in BCS70 had complete data in adolescence. Response rates were lower in adolescence for BCS70 than for NCDS because the tracing of study members through schools was affected by teachers’ industrial action. In addition, as is usual for large-scale longitudinal studies of this kind, there were also some systematic differences
Prevalence of non-intact family type, low family income and large family size
As shown in Table 1, the family structures of the three cohorts of adolescents differed in important ways. First, the numbers of adolescents living in intact families decreased from 85% to 65% over the 25-year period of the study. More than twice as many adolescents lived in single parent or stepfamilies in 1999 compared with 1974. Second, a marked reduction in family size meant that only 11% of adolescents lived with three or more siblings in 1986 or 1999, compared with 24% in 1974. Finally,
Summary of the main findings
The aim of the study was to test whether changes in UK family life can account for an increase in adolescent conduct problems. The findings support four main conclusions. First, in keeping with national statistics, the prevalence of some well-established family risk factors for conduct problems differed considerably between cohorts. There were more single and stepparent families in the more recent cohorts, but fewer adolescents lived in large families in 1986 and 1999 than in 1974. Second, the
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the Nuffield Foundation for grants 00.27 and NCF/00281/G and to the Economic & Social Research Council for grant H333 25 0013, which have helped support this work. Barbara Maughan is supported by the Medical Research Council. We are also grateful to the UK Data Archive for providing access to data from the National Child Development Study and the 1970 British Cohort Study, and to Howard Meltzer at the Office of National Statistics for providing access to data from the 1999
References (35)
- et al.
Comparison of problems reported by parents of children in 12 cultures: Total problems, externalizing, and internalizing
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1997) - et al.
Crime: Social disorganization and relative deprivation
Social Science & Medicine
(1999) - et al.
The life course prospective design: An example of benefits and problems associated with study longevity
Social Science and Medicine
(2003) - et al.
Are American children's problems still getting worse? A 23-year comparison
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
(2003) The consequences of divorce for adults and children
Journal of Marriage and the Family
(2000)Children of divorce in the 1990s: An update of the Amato and Keith (1991) meta-analysis
Journal of Family Psychology
(2001)- et al.
Parental divorce and the well-being of children—A meta-analysis
Psychological Bulletin
(1991) A review of adjusted estimators of attributable risk
Statistical Methods in Medical Research
(2001)Secular trends in growth
Proceedings of the Nutrition Society
(2000)- et al.
Time trends in adolescent mental health
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
(2004)
Is modern culture a health hazard?
International Journal of Epidemiology
Secular changes in the association of parental divorce and children's educational attainment—evidence from three British birth cohorts
Journal of Social Policy
Parental separation, adolescent psychopathology, and problem behaviors
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
Changing Britain. Changing lives. Three generations at the turn of the century
Increased rates of psychosocial disorders in youth
European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience
The strengths and difficulties questionnaire: A research note
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Cited by (42)
Explaining long-term trends in adolescent emotional problems: what we know from population-based studies
2024, Discover Social Science and HealthLifetime prevalence and treatment of mental disorders in Saudi youth and adolescents
2023, Scientific ReportsRussian adolescent mental health in 2002, 2015 and during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2021
2023, Child and Adolescent Mental HealthCross-Cohort Changes in Parent-Rated Child Mental Health over Two Decades
2023, Psychiatry (Moscow)Trends in adolescent emotional problems in Wales between 2013 and 2019: the contribution of peer relationships
2023, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines