Modified Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy combined with Bimanual Training (mCIMT–BiT) in children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: How are improvements in arm-hand use established?
Research highlights
▶ mCIMT–BiT improved upper limb capacity significantly more compared to usual care ▶ mCIMT–BiT improved upper limb performance significantly more compared to usual care ▶ Developmental disregard did not show differential effects ▶ Passive and active range of motion did not show differential effects ▶ mCIMT–BiT results in a better utilization of existing motor functions in CP children.
Introduction
In children with unilateral spastic CP, an increasing number of studies has indicated positive effects of (modified) Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy ((m)CIMT) on the potential of the affected arm to assist the unaffected arm during bimanual activities (Eliasson et al., 2005, Wallen et al., 2008) as well as on the quality, speed, and dexterity of upper limb function (Bonnier et al., 2006, Charles et al., 2006, Crocker et al., 1997, Deluca et al., 2006, Naylor and Bower, 2005, Sung et al., 2005, Taub et al., 2004, Wallen et al., 2008, Willis et al., 2002), the spontaneous use of the affected arm (Charles et al., 2006, Crocker et al., 1997, Taub et al., 2004), and the level of independence in self care (Brandao et al., 2010, Charles et al., 2006, Deluca et al., 2006, Sung et al., 2005, Taub et al., 2004, Wallen et al., 2008, Willis et al., 2002). Nonetheless, a recent Cochrane review (Hoare, Imms, Carey, & Wasiak, 2007a) concluded that, although these results are encouraging, they are still inconclusive due to methodological limitations related to small sample sizes, group allocation bias, and the influence of non specific (mainly intensity) effects. It was recommended that the effectiveness of (m)CIMT should be revealed in future, sufficiently powered trials using uniform, objective and valid outcome measures.
Recently, we conducted a randomized controlled trial (RCT) (Aarts, Jongerius, Geerdink, van Limbeek, & Geurts, 2010) in 52 children with unilateral spastic CP showing that 6 weeks mCIMT followed by 2 weeks of task-specific bimanual training (mCIMT–BiT) improves the spontaneous use of the affected limb during play and self-care activities as assessed with the Assisting Hand Assessment (AHA) (Krumlinde-sundholm, Holmefur, & Eliasson, 2007) and the ABILHAND-Kids (Arnould, Penta, Renders, & Thonnard, 2004), respectively. In addition, significant improvements were obtained in terms of experienced daily life problems and individually tailored functional goals as assessed with the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (Law et al., 2005) and Goal Attainment Scaling (Steenbeek, Ketelaar, Galama, & Gorter, 2007). Apparently, children receiving 8 weeks mCIMT–BiT improved the spontaneous use of their affected hand in most areas of daily functioning. From a neurophysiological perspective, this result imposes the question how these improvements were established? For instance, did these children improve the underlying active range of motion (aROM) or passive range of motion (pROM) at critical joints as measures at the ‘bodily functions’ level of the International Classification of Functioning Disability and Health (ICF) (World Health Organisation, 2010)? Or did they improve their upper limb capacity leading to better spontaneous use at the ‘activity level’ of the ICF, without true restoration of underlying motor functions? There is also the possibility that the children's upper limb capacity essentially remained the same, but that those receiving mCIMT–BiT improved the amount of use of the upper limb due to a reduction of so-called ‘learned non-use’ or ‘developmental disregard’.
The notion of a reduction of learned non-use has probably received the greatest attention in the literature on mCIMT in children with CP, but it has never been established with good empirical evidence (Brady and Garcia, 2009, Hoare et al., 2007a, Hoare et al., 2007b, Huang et al., 2009). Children with unilateral spastic CP often display a form of learned non-use, as in daily life they experience too little incentive to use their affected upper limb during functional tasks, which often becomes apparent during bilateral activities (Gordon, Charles, & Wolf, 2005). The basic notion behind learned non-use following unilateral brain damage is that certain residual motor capacities of the affected extremity remain hidden due to a learning process favouring the easier movements with the non affected extremity (Taub, Uswatte, & Pidikiti, 1999). As a result, motor performance is often better during forced activities than during spontaneous activities of the affected upper limb (Taub, Uswatte, Mark, & Morris, 2006). In the paediatric literature, this phenomenon has been referred to as ‘developmental disregard’, because the learned non-use does not so much relate to a relatively short period of adaptation to an acute lesion (such as in stroke), but rather reflects a developmental process or strategy through which children with unilateral CP fail to integrate the potentials of their affected upper limb in daily life routines (Deluca et al., 2006, Hoare et al., 2007b, Sutcliffe et al., 2009, Taub et al., 2004). In children with unilateral spastic CP, there may be a critical lack of movement stimulation during developmental periods when movement repertoires are rapidly being acquired in typically developing children. This creates a situation in which, in theory, new neural substrates for entire classes of behaviour are not well established, refined, and coordinated (Deluca et al., 2006). In addition to this lack of movement stimulation, children with unilateral CP often suffer from upper limb spasticity and loss of motor selectivity, leading to stereotypical movement patterns such as internal rotation of the shoulder, elbow flexion with pronation of the forearm, ulnar deviation and flexion of the wrist and thumb-in-palm and/or finger-swan neck deformities (Burtner et al., 2008). These children often tend to maintain the wrist in flexion and show difficulties in extending this joint during manual activities, even when they are able to actively extend the wrist and fingers at least 30 degrees from the resting position (Vaz et al., 2008). As a result, the wrist flexors and extensors may show tissue remodelling to generate more grip strength with the wrist in flexion (Vaz, Cotta, Fonseca, Vieira, & de Melo Pertence, 2006), after which a normal movement pattern of the hand is unlikely to return and children may become prone to develop developmental disregard.
The goal of this study was to investigate how the above-mentioned improvements in spontaneous use of the affected limb during play and self-care activities were established as a result of 8 weeks mCIMT–BiT. Developmental disregard was assessed with the Video Observations Aarts and Aarts module Determine Developmental Disregard (VOAA-DDD) (Aarts, Jongerius, Geerdink, & Geurts, 2009) as were upper limb capacity and performance as measures at the activity level of the ICF. Indeed, recent research has shown that both unimanual capacity and bimanual performance are important aspects of bimanual activities in children with CP (Sakzewski, Ziviani, & Boyd, 2010). In addition, active and passive range of (extension) motion of the affected wrist and elbow were assessed as measures at the ICF level of bodily functions. The results of a previous study (Sutcliffe et al., 2009) led us to the hypothesis that developmental disregard would be reduced or even resolved after mCIMT–BiT. In addition, it was hypothesized that changes in active or passive range of joint motion would not underlie the improvements found at the activity level.
Section snippets
Participants
The children for this study were recruited from eight rehabilitation centres in the Netherlands. Inclusion criteria were: (1) cerebral palsy with a unilateral or severely asymmetric, bilateral spastic movement impairment, (2) age 2.5–8 years, and (3) Manual Ability Classification System (MACS) (Eliasson et al., 2006) scores I, II or III. Exclusion criteria were: (1) intellectual disability such that simple tasks could not be understood or executed (i.e. developmental age below 2 years), (2)
Participants
A total of 52 children with unilateral spastic CP were included (Aarts et al., 2010), of which 28 children were allocated to the mCIMT–BiT group and 24 to the UC group. Immediately after randomization, two children withdrew from the UC group due to family circumstances. Thereafter, no participants were lost to follow-up or changed group allocation. Hence, the data of 22 participants in the UC group are presented. The mCIMT–BiT group (n = 28) and the UC group (n = 22) had similar baseline
Discussion
In a previous publication it was shown that, in young children with unilateral spastic CP, 6 weeks of modified Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy followed by 2 weeks of task-specific Bimanual Training (mCIMT–BiT) improved the spontaneous use of the upper limb during play and self-care activities in both qualitative and quantitative terms more than usual care of the same duration (Aarts et al., 2010). The goal of the present study was to investigate how the above-mentioned improvements were
Acknowledgements
A grant from the Johanna Children Fund (JKF) supported the conduct of this study. We thank Jan Wielders (OT), Ingrid van den Tillaar (OT), Ruth van den Heuvel (PT) and Mariëtte Tissen (Therapy Assistant) for their excellent therapeutic work with the children in the Pirate Group. We want to express our gratitude to the children and their families who participated in this study. We would also like to thank Michel Aarts and Brigitte Croonen for their assistance in constructing the database.
References (41)
- et al.
Methods of constraint-induced movement therapy for children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: Development of a child-friendly intervention for improving upper-extremity function
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(2005) - et al.
Efficacy of forced-use therapy in hemiplegic cerebral palsy
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(2005) - et al.
Forced use of hemiplegic upper extremities to reverse the effect of learned nonuse among chronic stroke and head-injured patients
Experimental Neurology
(1989) - et al.
Validity and reliability of the VOAA-DDD to assess spontaneous hand use with a video observation tool in children with spastic unilateral cerebral palsy
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders
(2009) - et al.
Effectiveness of modified constraint-induced movement therapy in children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled trial
Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair
(2010) - et al.
ABILHAND-Kids: A measure of manual ability in children with cerebral palsy
Neurology
(2004) - et al.
Effects of constraint-induced movement therapy in adolescents with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A day camp model
Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy
(2006) - et al.
Constraint-induced movement therapy (CIMT): Pediatric applications
Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews
(2009) - et al.
Adapted version of constraint-induced movement therapy promotes functioning in children with cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled trial
Clinical Rehabilitation
(2010) - et al.
Effect of wrist hand splints on grip, pinch, manual dexterity, and muscle activation in children with spastic hemiplegia: A preliminary study
Journal of Hand Therapy
(2008)
Three-dimensional kinematics of the upper limb during a reach and grasp cycle for children
Gait and Posture
Efficacy of a child-friendly form of constraint-induced movement therapy in hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A randomized control trial
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
Forced use of the upper extremity in cerebral palsy: A single-case design
American Journal of Occupational Therapy
Intensive pediatric constraint-induced therapy for children with cerebral palsy: Randomized, controlled, crossover trial
Journal of Child Neurology
Quality of upper extremity skills test
The Manual Ability Classification System (MACS) for children with cerebral palsy: Scale development and evidence of validity and reliability
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Effects of constraint-induced movement therapy in young children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: An adapted model
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Constraint-induced movement therapy in the treatment of the upper limb in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A Cochrane systematic review
Clinical Rehabilitation
Constraint-induced movement therapy in the treatment of the upper limb in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
Cited by (51)
Constraint-induced movement therapy improves upper limb activity and participation in hemiplegic cerebral palsy: A systematic review
2016, Journal of PhysiotherapyCitation Excerpt :On the other hand, when only the studies of CIMT against an equivalent dose of practice were analysed, the estimated effect size was 0.37, which is larger than our estimated effect size of 0.05 for activity and –0.02 for participation. This may be because Chen et al5 included seven studies in their analysis that were not considered dose equivalent by our definition.12,13,26,36,40,43,44 Since the control groups in these studies received less practice than the CIMT groups, this may explain why the effect that Chen et al found was larger than in our review.
Effect of Modified Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy Combined with Auditory Feedback for Trunk Control on Upper Extremity in Subacute Stroke Patients with Moderate Impairment: Randomized Controlled Pilot Trial
2016, Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular DiseasesCitation Excerpt :Furthermore, in a recent review of the effect of extrinsic feedback on motor learning in the UE post stroke, auditory feedback was found to improve movement quality immediately following training than artificial device.32 Previously conducted studies have suggested that mCIMT and trunk restraint for trunk control are useful for recovery of motor function and for improvement in the activity levels.14,33 To my knowledge, however, there are no previous studies involving combination interventions using the mCIMT and auditory feedback.
Goal-Directed Personalized Upper Limb Intensive Therapy (PULIT) for Children with Hemiparesis: A Retrospective Analysis
2022, American Journal of Occupational Therapy