The effectiveness of a bibliotherapy in increasing the self-management ability of slightly to moderately frail older people
Introduction
“To know how to grow old is the master work of wisdom, and one of the most difficult chapters in the great art of living”. As this quotation from the Swiss author Henri Frederic Amiel suggests, successful aging is not just a matter of growing old. It requires the proactive management of resources in an environment of increasing losses and declining gains [1]. In modern society, this process of self-management is becoming increasingly important. Due to medical and social developments, the number of healthy years after retirement has increased. Because this is a relatively unstructured stage of life with few clear social roles [2], giving meaning to this period requires a certain amount of pro-activity. Self-management interventions can provide older people with the abilities necessary for this. Furthermore, with a growing elderly population and increasing cutbacks in health care, our society faces the difficult task of making all ends meet. Increasing the self-management of older people could in part relieve this burden on the health care system: with higher levels of Self-management ability (SMA), older people will be better able to maintain an independent and autonomous lifestyle for a longer period of time. In this study, we developed a bibliotherapy aimed at increasing the SMA of slightly to moderately frail older people, which differs in a number of ways from existing self-management interventions.
First, most self-management interventions focus on teaching people how to cope with specific age-related problems, like depression (e.g., [3], [4]), loneliness (e.g., [5]), the increased risk of falling (e.g., [6]), insomnia (e.g., [7]), or chronic illnesses [8], [9], [10]. However, a substantial number of older people suffers from a mixture of problems in multiple life domains. This mixture of problems can create a gerontological condition called frailty. Frail older people are vulnerable to adverse outcomes like the dependence on others, chronic illness, and admission to an institution (e.g., [11]). Because frail older people lack reserves in multiple life domains, they may benefit more from a self-management intervention that provides them with a general cognitive and behavioural repertoire for dealing with different kinds of age-related problems rather than from interventions focusing on one specific problem.
Second, many interventions address the problems of older people who have already suffered substantial loss, like those residing in nursing homes. However, an increasing number of studies suggest that preventing age-related decline may be more effective than dealing with its consequences (e.g., [11], [12]). This is why self-management interventions may best be aimed at older people with beginning problems in physical or psychosocial life domains, without these problems being so serious as to have already resulted in substantial loss.
Third, although many intervention-studies of self-management have succeeded in affecting outcomes like depression [3], psychosocial functioning [13], and pain perception [9], there has been little theorizing concerning the specific self-management abilities underlying such effects. In some studies, it was suggested that general abilities like self-efficacy were responsible for the positive effects of self-management interventions (e.g., [14]). However, abilities like self-efficacy are quite unspecific unless they are aimed at a certain goal. The self-management intervention developed in the current study is based on the theory of successful self-management of aging (SSMA [15]), which gives a specification of the abilities that constitute an effective self-manager, and the goals at which these abilities should be directed. Because of its specificity, this framework offers clear guidelines for the development and evaluation of a self-management intervention.
Fourth, the format of a bibliotherapy may provide an important alternative to more traditional interventions. Although self-management interventions aim at increasing the autonomy of older people in the long-term, many of these interventions use extensive counseling and group sessions in the short-term (e.g., [6], [16]). Bibliotherapy, i.e., reading a self-help book for the treatment of psychosocial problems [17], may provide an important cost- and time-saving alternative to these extensive interventions. Because a bibliotherapy does not require face-to-face counselling, it can be effective in reaching a large group of older people who do not yet require institutionalized care. Furthermore, there is evidence indicating that bibliotherapy can be just as effective as more traditional interventions. For example, in studies aimed at reducing depression among older people [4], [18], or at the improvement of mind-body wellness for older adults with chronic illness [19], written or videotaped self-help treatments resulted in a clinically significant change compared to the change noted in a delayed-treatment control condition.
To extend the existing self-management interventions in respect of the four aspects mentioned above, we developed a self-management bibliotherapy for slightly to moderately frail older persons. The aim of this bibliotherapy was to increase SMA as defined by the SSMA theory [15]. According to this theory, SMA are the abilities people need for managing resources in such a way that sustainable positive well-being is reached. The SSMA theory distinguishes six self-management abilities: having a positive frame of mind, being self-efficacious, taking initiative, investing in resources for long-term benefits, taking care of a variety of resources, and taking care of a multifunctionality of resources.
Based on the social production functions theory [20], Steverink et al. argue that these abilities should be directed at the realization of physical and social dimensions of well-being in order to lead to successful aging. Physical well-being is realized when people obtain enough comfort, that is, the satisfaction of basic physical needs (e.g., food, drink, rest, and warmth), and stimulation, that is, the pleasant range of physical and mental activation ([20] also see [21]). Social well-being is realized when people receive enough affection, behavioural confirmation, and status [20], “as forms of positive evaluations for what a person is (affection), does (behavioural confirmation) and has (status)” [21].
To examine whether the bibliotherapy indeed increased the SMA of slightly to moderately frail elderly, and whether this increase helped them to maintain their present levels of well-being, we tested the following hypotheses. We expected that older people who received our bibliotherapy would show a greater increase in SMA than those who participated in the control condition. We expected to find this effect using a specific instrument addressing the underlying theoretical framework of the bibliotherapy, i.e., the Self-Management Ability-Scale (SMA-S [22]), and using an instrument measuring a more general concept of control, i.e., the mastery scale of Pearlin and Schooler [23]. We expected that this effect of our bibliotherapy on SMA would still exist after 6 months. Furthermore, we expected that older people who had received our bibliotherapy would show more maintenance of subjective well-being than those who participated in the control condition, because of the increase in SMA. Last, we expected that this effect of our bibliotherapy on well-being would still exist after 6 months.
Section snippets
Intervention
To increase the SMA of slightly to moderately frail older people, and influence their subjective well-being, we developed a bibliotherapy, which was called “GRIP on life”. This bibliotherapy was introduced as a correspondence course on how to maintain a firm grip on life with increasing age. It consisted of five different parts, each composed of 11–19 pages, which were printed one-sided in black and white. For the layout of the text, we hired a graphic design agency with experience in the field
Evaluation of the self-management intervention
To examine how the experimental group regarded the self-management bibliotherapy, we asked them to answer a few questions concerning their views of each part. Furthermore, we left some spaces on each questionnaire for the participants to write down their personal remarks. In general, participants did not evaluate the five parts very differently. As shown in Table 3, most participants indicated that they liked the different parts and the assignments, and that they did not perceive the text, the
Discussion and conclusion
In this study, we investigated whether increasing the SMA of slightly to moderately frail older people would result in the maintenance of well-being among these persons. The bibliotherapy we designed to increase SMA proved to have significant effects: older persons who received the bibliotherapy showed an increase in SMA while those who participated in the control condition showed a decrease. This positive effect of our bibliotherapy still existed after 6 months. Furthermore, this increase in
Acknowledgment
This research was supported in part by Grant 014-90-046 from ZonMw (The Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development).
References (32)
- et al.
Implementation, generalization and long-term results of the “choosing well” diabetes self-management intervention
Patient Educ Couns
(2002) - et al.
Structural models for the mediation of salience effects on attribution
J Exp Soc Psychol
(1982) - et al.
Psychological perspectives on successful aging: the model of selective optimization with compensation
- et al.
Structural lag: past and future
- et al.
Mental health in residential homes: a role for care staff
Ageing Soc
(2001) - et al.
Comparative efficacy of cognitive and behavioral bibliotherapy for mildly and moderately depressed older adults
J Consult Clin Psych
(1989) Intervention against loneliness in a group of elderly women: process evaluation
Hum Relat
(1984)- et al.
Attempts to prevent falls and injury: a prospective community study
Gerontologist
(1992) - et al.
Cognitive-behavior therapy for late-life insomnia
J Consult Clin Psych
(1993) - et al.
Arthritis self-management: a study of the effectiveness of patient education for the elderly
Gerontologist
(1984)
Development, content, and process evaluation of a short self-management intervention in patients with chronic diseases requiring self-care behaviours
Patient Educ Couns
Frailty in elderly people: an evolving concept
Can Med Assoc J
Functional decline in old age
Can Med Assoc J
Impact of self-management education on the functional health status of older adults with heart disease
Gerontologist
Age-related macular degeneration: a randomized clinical trial of a self-management intervention
Ann Behav Med
Can self-management ability help to maintain subjective well-being in frail elderly people?
Gerontologist
Cited by (69)
A Bibliotherapeutic discourse on aging and masculinity in continuing care retirement communities
2022, Journal of Aging StudiesCitation Excerpt :It provided a unique space in which participants felt acknowledged, accepted, challenged, and inspired (Malyn et al., 2020). Bibliotherapy was also found to be effective in increasing the self-management abilities of community-dwelling slightly to moderately frail older people (Frieswijk et al., 2006), and beneficial in providing a positive enduring impact on various aspects of older adults' well-being (Poerio and Totterdell, 2020). In institutional settings, a bibliotherapy intervention combined with reading aloud contributed to the emergence of empathy, confidence, and a sense of self-identity among older adults in psychiatric care.
Sustaining program effectiveness after implementation: The case of the self-management of well-being group intervention for older adults
2017, Patient Education and CounselingCitation Excerpt :Regarding the effectiveness of the implemented SMW group intervention, we found its effects on self-management ability and well-being were medium in size and not significantly different from those in the RCT. These findings add to previous findings from two other RCTs using the SMW intervention in which effect sizes were small to medium [33–35]. Not only was effectiveness in the IMP comparable to that in the RCT, but drop-out rates and session attendance, indicating similar participant adherence, were also comparable.
Self-management tasks to improve mobility and reduce fall risk are not leading to lower research participation in older adults
2018, Archives of Gerontology and GeriatricsCitation Excerpt :A personal initial approach to the older person did not alter the inclusion rate, but an introductory meeting seemed to benefit inclusion. Our recruitment rate is comparable with a range of recruitment rates (20%–38%) found in self-management studies with older persons (Elzen et al., 2008; Eyles et al., 2015; Frieswijk, Steverink, Buunk, & Slaets, 2006; Reed, Barton, Isherwood, Baxter, & Roeger, 2013; Wylde, Marques, Artz, Blom, & Gooberman-Hill, 2014). However, all these studies included younger (years of age ranging from 37 to 91) and/or chronically ill persons.
Fostering Development in Midlife and Older Age: A Positive Psychology Perspective
2023, Fostering Development in Midlife and Older Age: A Positive Psychology PerspectiveInstruments for measuring self-management and self-care in geriatric patients – a scoping review
2023, Frontiers in Public Health