For whom, and for what, is experience sampling more accurate than retrospective report?☆
Section snippets
Study 1
The first aim of study 1 was to investigate the extent of the memory-experience gap for momentary stress and self-esteem states, including both aggregated information (average stress and self-esteem) and disaggregated information (moment-by-moment stress and self-esteem states, and dynamic covariance of stress and self-esteem). The second aim was to investigate the relationship of trait alexithymia to the discrepancy between these variables rated in an experience-sampling protocol and
Study 2
The results of Study 1 suggested that individuals high in alexithymia more accurately recognized the mean levels and variability in their stress over time. This finding was opposite of what we hypothesized. We reasoned that this surprising effect may have been due to the recognition-based nature of the memory tasks used in this study. If people high in alexithymia had distinctive stress patterns compared to those with more moderate levels of alexithymia, this may have strengthened their ability
General discussion
The current two studies allow us to quantify the degree to which ESM may be more accurate than retrospective self-report for momentary (disaggregated) psychological data. Participants recognized time plots of their momentary stress and self-esteem data only two-thirds of the time, and roughly 20–30% of the area of participants' drawings of these time plots was “error.” Although this degree of inaccuracy does not indicate an absolute advantage for ESM over self-report, it does suggest that in
CRediT authorship contribution statement
William D. Ellison:Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis, Data curation, Writing - original draft.Alec C. Trahan:Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Investigation, Data curation, Writing - review & editing.Joseph C. Pinzon:Methodology, Formal analysis, Investigation, Writing - review & editing.Megan E. Gillespie:Formal analysis, Investigation, Data curation, Writing - review & editing.Logan M. Simmons:Formal analysis, Investigation, Writing - review & editing.Kendel Y. King:
References (56)
- et al.
The twenty-item Toronto alexithymia scale—I. item selection and cross-validation of the factor structure
Journal of Psychosomatic Research
(1994) - et al.
Alexithymia increases the discordance between implicit and explicit self-esteem
Personality and Individual Differences
(2010) - et al.
Whole trait theory
Journal of Research in Personality
(2015) - et al.
Accuracy of retrospective memory and covariation estimation in patients with obsessive–compulsive disorder
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2008) Alexithymia and attachment style in relation to locus of control
Personality and Individual Differences
(2003)- et al.
Alexithymia and levels of processing: Evidence for an overall deficit in remembering emotion words
Journal of Research in Personality
(2006) - et al.
Taxometric analysis of alexithymia in a general population sample from Finland
Personality and Individual Differences
(2010) - et al.
Memory for emotionally provocative words in alexithymia: A role for stimulus relevance
Consciousness and Cognition
(2010) - et al.
Is alexithymia characterised by impaired interoception? Further evidence, the importance of control variables, and the problems with the heartbeat counting task
Biological Psychology
(2018) - et al.
A model for personality at three levels
Journal of Research in Personality
(2015)
Understanding recall of weekly pain from a momentary assessment perspective: Absolute agreement, between- and within-person consistency, and judged change in weekly pain
Pain
Alexithymia factors and memory performances for neutral and emotional words
Personality and Individual Differences
Memory for emotional information and alexithymia: A systematic review
Dementia & Neuropsychologia
The relationships among momentary emotion experiences, personality descriptions, and retrospective ratings of emotion
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
Comparing retrospective reports to real-time/real-place mobile assessments in individuals with schizophrenia and a nonclinical comparison group
Schizophrenia Bulletin
Accuracy of hospitalized depressed patients’ and healthy controls’ retrospective symptom reports: An experience sampling study
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease
Retrospective recall of affect in clinically depressed individuals and controls
Cognition and Emotion
Repressive coping style and the experience and recall of emotion: A naturalistic study of daily affect
Journal of Personality
Alexithymia and automatic processing of emotional stimuli: A systematic review
Reviews in the Neurosciences
Ecological momentary assessment of mood disorders and mood dysregulation
Psychological Assessment
Can retrospective interviews assess instability? A comparison of ambulatory assessment and expert interviews regarding DSM–IV criteria for borderline personality disorde
Enhancing the personalization of psychotherapy with dynamic assessment and modeling
Assessment
Exploring the idiographic dynamics of mood and anxiety via network analysis
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Computer methods for mathematical computations
The retrospective evaluation of positive and negative affect
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
The fading affect bias begins within 12 hours and persists for 3 months
Applied Cognitive Psychology
“I feel better when…”: An analysis of the memory-experience gap for peoples’ estimates of the relationship between health behaviors and experiences
Psychology & Health
Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives
Structural Equation Modeling
Cited by (22)
Momentary versus retrospective reports of alcohol or cannabis use, sexual activity, and their co-occurrence
2021, Addictive BehaviorsCitation Excerpt :Substance-involved sexual activity is common (Herbenick et al., 2010), but reported associations between substance use and sexual activity may be affected by people’s ability to accurately remember each of these behaviors. Because evidence suggests that momentary data—which assess behavior shortly after it happens and in natural environments—are more accurate than retrospective reports (Ellison et al., 2020; Graham, Catania, Brand, Duong, & Canchola, 2003), researchers can investigate recall biases for behaviors like substance use and sexual activity by comparing reports from retrospective surveys to more proximal assessments from the same participants. Extant literature indicates that substance use and sexual activity may be differentially affected by recall biases.
Competition or Silence? The Double-Edged Sword Effect of ESM Affordance on Employee Creativity
2024, Sustainability (Switzerland)On Personality Measures and Their Data: A Classification of Measurement Approaches and Their Recommended Uses
2024, Personality and Social Psychology Review
- ☆
William D. Ellison, Department of Psychology, Trinity University; Alec C. Trahan, Department of Psychology, Trinity University; Joseph C. Pinzon, Department of Psychology, Trinity University; Megan E. Gillespie, Department of Psychology, Trinity University; Logan M. Simmons, Department of Psychology, Trinity University; Kendel Y King, Department of Psychology, Trinity University. Joseph Pinzon is now at the Department of Psychology, Pepperdine University. Megan Gillespie is now at the Independent Living Research Utilization Program, TiRR Memorial Hermann Research Center. We thank Kai de Sequera for assistance in developing study materials. Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to William D. Ellison, Department of Psychology, Trinity University, One Trinity Place, San Antonio, TX 78212. Email: [email protected].