Elsevier

Journal of Neuroscience Methods

Volume 222, 30 January 2014, Pages 175-188
Journal of Neuroscience Methods

Clinical Neuroscience
The measurement of visual sampling during real-world activity in Parkinson's disease and healthy controls: A structured literature review

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jneumeth.2013.11.018Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Techniques for objective measurement of visual sampling lack consistency.

  • Reliability and validity of instruments has not been yet established.

  • Testing recommendations include assessment of basic visual function and cognition.

  • This review informs the development of robust protocols.

Abstract

Background

Visual sampling techniques are used to investigate the complex role of vision during real-world activities in Parkinson's disease. Earlier research is limited to static simple tasks or measurement of eye movements alone, but more recent investigations involve more real-world activities. The approach to the objective measurement of eye movements varies with respect to instrumentation, testing protocols, and mediating factors that may influence visual sampling.

Objectives

The aim of this review was to examine previous work measuring visual sampling during real-world activities in Parkinson's disease to inform the development of robust protocols. Within this review a real-world activity was considered to be a goal-orientated motor task involving more than one body segment such as reaching or walking.

Methods

Medline, Embase, PsychInfo, Scopus, Web of Knowledge, PubMed and the Cochrane library databases were searched. Two independent reviewers and an adjudicator screened articles that described quantitative visual sampling in people with Parkinson's disease and healthy controls.

Results

Twenty full-text articles were screened and 15 met inclusion/exclusion criteria. A wide range of instruments and outcome measures were reported which were generally used in a task-dependent manner. Instrument reliability and validity was insufficiently reported in all studies. Few studies considered mediators of visual sampling such as visual or cognitive deficits.

Conclusions

Future research is required to accurately characterise visual impairments in Parkinson's disease and during real-world activities. Composite use of instruments may be required to achieve reliability and validity of visual sampling outcomes which need to be standardised. Recommendations also include assessment of cognition and basic visual function.

Introduction

Visual sampling (VS) is the combination of fixations and saccades that are required to gather information about our environment when performing a real-world activity. VS has been assessed using a variety of methods since the 1700s, evolving from simple photographic technology to more recently the use of mobile infra-red eye-tracking (Land, 2006, Porterfield, 1752). Eye-tracking involves two distinguishable movements of the eye; activity that stabilises the fovea (fixations) on areas of interest (AOI), and activity that rapidly shifts the fovea to bring AOI into high visual acuity (saccades) (Anderson and MacAskill, 2013). A combination of fixations and saccades provide the mechanisms through which we sample our visual environment (McPeek et al., 2000, Deubel, 2003, Tatler, 2009). Advancements in eye-tracking technology have enabled VS to be monitored during real-world activity (e.g. walking, obstacle crossing, driving). This progress is vital as VS is a critical feature of motor control, which is task-dependent and relates to specific goals (Marigold and Patla, 2007). For example: during locomotion over even ground in healthy control subjects long fixation durations are not necessarily required, yet saccadic frequency, amplitude and duration of fixations increase in healthy subjects when walking over uneven terrain (Land, 2006, Patla and Greig, 2006). The co-ordination of the eyes, head, trunk and other body segments during real-world activity requires visuomotor control to guide and organise linked-segment interactions. Motor control and visual mechanisms are also inter-linked with attentional networks, which are governed by cognitive (‘top-down’) processes (Botha and Carr, 2012). Therefore, disease-specific impairments of motor control (Joti et al., 2007, Konczak et al., 2009) and cognition (Archibald et al., 2013) potentially mediate visual function.

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease associated with impaired motor control (Konczak et al., 2009) and a range of cognitive and visual deficits. Motor symptoms such as bradykinesia (slow movement) and akinesia (impaired movement) are evident in limb and eye movements in PD during real-world activity. For example, bradykinesia can affect reaching (Schettino et al., 2006), pointing (Adamovich et al., 2001, Bekkering et al., 2001, Boisseau et al., 2002, Klockgether and Dichgans, 1994) and force control (Vaillancourt et al., 2001b, Vaillancourt et al., 2001a). In addition, impaired visuo-perceptual and basic visual functions such as reduced contrast sensitivity are reported by up to 81% (Verbaan et al., 2007) and 78% (Davidsdottir et al., 2005) of PD subjects respectively. These symptoms are seen at an early stage in PD and are associated with functional decline, freezing of gait (FOG) and falls. Investigation into VS during real-world activity in PD is warranted, to further clarify the links between these motor, cognitive and visual impairments. Eye-tracking technology has been used to further understand the visual strategies of PD subjects since the 1960's (Terao et al., 2011, van Stockum et al., 2012), demonstrating VS impairments, such as hypometric voluntary (van Stockum et al., 2012, Anderson and MacAskill, 2013) and variable reflexive (Chambers and Prescott, 2010) saccades. However until recently most research using eye-trackers involved small sample sizes (Anderson and MacAskill, 2013). Similarly most PD studies of VS are limited to static examination of eye movements alone or involve simple single-segment motor tasks (e.g. mouse clicks). Of the PD studies investigating VS during real-world activity, a wide range of protocols has been used indicating a lack of standardisation, which limits VS interpretation. Investigators who want to conduct similar research are left with the choice between numerous protocols, which differ in many respects. In the process of developing robust protocols it is often helpful to have evidence-based recommendations. We therefore examined previous work that assessed VS during real-world activities in PD and healthy control (HC) participants, in order to provide some guidance regarding the selection of appropriate methodology.

We focused the review on the following: (1) VS instrumentation used during real-world activities involving both PD and HC; (2) commonly reported VS outcomes; (3) PD specific influences on these visual outcomes; and, (4) recommendations concerning protocol. For the purpose of this review a real-world activity was considered to be a goal-orientated motor task, which involved more than one body segment (such as walking, reaching, turning etc.).

Section snippets

Search strategy

The key terms were “Parkinson's disease”, “visual sampling” and a “motor task”. A list of synonyms was created for each key term (Fig. 1). Key terms were matched and exploded with medical subject headings (MeSH) in each separate database where appropriate. Databases searched included Medline (from 1950), Embase (from 1974), PsychInfo (from 1806), Scopus, Web of Knowledge (from 1900), PubMed (from 1950) and the Cochrane library (from 1800) to February 2013. Studies were relevant if they

The evidence base

The search strategy yielded 2814 articles, excluding duplicates (Fig. 2 – adapted from Moher et al., 2009). An initial screening resulted in 287 articles of interest of which 14 were identified for inclusion by the first reviewer (SS) and 20 by the second reviewer (LA), with 6 disagreements. A consensus was made for inclusion of 15 articles for review after consultation with the third reviewer (SL).

Reasons for exclusion were: performance of a simple motor task (n = 3) (Shimizu et al., 1981,

Discussion

This review examined 15 studies reporting VS in PD subjects during real-world activities. Explicitly reviewing; (i) how VS was measured; (ii) the specific outcomes assessed and how they were defined; and (iii) the differences reported between PD and HC subjects in these outcomes during real-world activities. This review has demonstrated that the measurement of VS during real-world activities in PD is emerging, but further work is warranted to establish the validity and reliability of VS

Conclusions

The functional implications of VS during real-world activities remain unclear, but research in this area is emerging. Precise quantitative measures of VS during real-world activities are essential for characterising the VS impairments involved in PD. However, no single measure or combination of outcomes has been established as the most informative indicator of these processes. Although mobile infra-red eye–trackers are the most comprehensive method available to date, the validity and

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Erika Gavillet, Medical Librarian at Newcastle University, for her contribution to the articles search strategy. The research was supported/funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Newcastle Biomedical Research Unit based at Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust and Newcastle University. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NHS, the NIHR or the Department of Health.

References (88)

  • U.S. Clark et al.

    Visual exploration of emotional facial expressions in Parkinson's disease

    Neuropsychologia

    (2010)
  • S. Davidsdottir et al.

    Visual and spatial symptoms in Parkinson's disease

    Vision Research

    (2005)
  • R.P. Di Fabio et al.

    Aging and saccade-stepping interactions in humans

    Neuroscience Letters

    (2003)
  • B. Galna et al.

    Visual sampling during walking in people with Parkinson's disease and the influence of environment and dual-task

    Brain Research

    (2012)
  • M.M. Hayhoe et al.

    Eye movements in natural behavior

    Trends in Cognitive Sciences

    (2005)
  • M.F. Land

    Eye movements and the control of actions in everyday life

    Progress in Retinal and Eye Research

    (2006)
  • S. Lord et al.

    Dorsal rather than ventral visual pathways discriminate freezing status in Parkinson's disease

    Parkinsonism and Related Disorders

    (2012)
  • D.S. Marigold et al.

    Gaze fixation patterns for negotiating complex ground terrain

    Neuroscience

    (2007)
  • H. Matsumoto et al.

    Basal ganglia dysfunction reduces saccade amplitude during visual scanning in Parkinson's disease

    Basal Ganglia

    (2012)
  • R.M. Mcpeek et al.

    Concurrent processing of saccades in visual search

    Vision Research

    (2000)
  • C. Owsley

    Aging and vision

    Vision Research

    (2011)
  • A.E. Patla et al.

    Any way you look at it, successful obstacle negotiation needs visually guided on-line foot placement regulation during the approach phase

    Neuroscience Letters

    (2006)
  • A. Peltsch et al.

    Age-related trends in saccade characteristics among the elderly

    Neurobiology of Aging

    (2011)
  • J.B. Pelz et al.

    Oculomotor behavior and perceptual strategies in complex tasks

    Vision Research

    (2001)
  • L.A.R. Sacrey et al.

    Drug treatment and familiar music aids an attention shift from vision to somatosensation in Parkinson's disease on the reach-to-eat task

    Behavioural Brain Research

    (2011)
  • Y. Terao et al.

    Initiation and inhibitory control of saccades with the progression of Parkinson's disease – changes in three major drives converging on the superior colliculus

    Neuropsychologia

    (2011)
  • G. Tropini et al.

    Altered directional connectivity in Parkinson's disease during performance of a visually guided task

    Neuroimage

    (2011)
  • D.E. Vaillancourt et al.

    Visual control of isometric force in Parkinson's disease

    Neuropsychologia

    (2001)
  • S. van Stockum et al.

    Don’t look now or look away: two sources of saccadic disinhibition in Parkinson's disease?

    Neuropsychologia

    (2008)
  • S. Van Stockum et al.

    Impairment of voluntary saccades and facilitation of reflexive saccades do not co-occur in Parkinson's disease

    Journal of Clinical Neuroscience

    (2012)
  • J. Ventre-Dominey et al.

    Dissociable processing of temporal structure in repetitive eye-hand movements in Parkinson's disease

    Neuropsychologia

    (2002)
  • J. Ventre-Dominey et al.

    Asymmetric influences of pointing on saccade latency in hemi-Parkinson's disease

    Neuropsychologia

    (2001)
  • R. Vitório et al.

    The role of vision in Parkinson's disease locomotion control: free walking task

    Gait and Posture

    (2012)
  • T. Yoshida et al.

    Visuomotor dependency on an initial fixation target involved in the disorder of visually-guided manual movement in Parkinson's disease

    Neuroscience Research

    (2005)
  • D.E. Young et al.

    Visuospatial perception and navigation in Parkinson's disease

    Vision Research

    (2010)
  • D. Anastasopoulos et al.

    Altered eye-to-foot coordination in standing parkinsonian patients during large gaze and whole-body reorientations

    Movement Disorders

    (2011)
  • T.J. Anderson et al.

    Eye movements in patients with neurodegenerative disorders

    Nature Reviews Neurology

    (2013)
  • A. Antal et al.

    Parkinson's disease, aging, and visual cognition

    Topics in Geriatric Rehabilitation

    (2008)
  • N.K. Archibald et al.

    The retina in Parkinson's disease

    Brain

    (2009)
  • N.K. Archibald et al.

    Visual exploration in Parkinson's disease and Parkinson's disease dementia

    Brain

    (2013)
  • J.P. Azulay et al.

    Visual control of locomotion in Parkinson's disease

    Brain

    (1999)
  • I. Bodis-Wollner et al.

    Fovea and foveation in Parkinson's disease

    Behavioral Neuroscience

    (2013)
  • E. Boisseau et al.

    Eye-hand coordination in aging and in Parkinson's disease

    Aging, Neuropsychology, and Cognition

    (2002)
  • G.J. Chapman et al.

    Age-related differences in stepping performance during step cycle-related removal of vision

    Experimental Brain Research

    (2006)
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text