The effects of imagery rescripting on memory outcomes in social anxiety disorder
Introduction
Cognitive models of social anxiety disorder (SAD) posit that negative self-imagery is central to the maintenance of the disorder (Clark & Wells, 1995; Rapee & Heimberg, 1997). Negative self-images often originate as a result of significant, socially painful autobiographical experiences (Hackmann, Clark, & McManus, 2000; Moscovitch et al., 2018), tying them thematically to negative core beliefs derived from these earlier ‘social failures’ (Çili & Stopa, 2015). Persistent experiences of negatively distorted self-imagery may therefore prevent socially anxious individuals from updating negative schema in the face of disconfirming evidence (Hirsch, Clark, & Mathews, 2006; Ng, Abbott, & Hunt, 2014; Wild & Clark, 2011). As such, therapeutic interventions that work by harnessing these affectively-charged memory-derived images may be particularly fruitful for targeting social anxiety symptoms (e.g., Iyadurai et al., 2018; McEvoy, Erceg-Hurn, Saulsman, & Thibodeau, 2015).
Imagery rescripting (IR) is a therapeutic technique that aims to modify negative mental self-representations (Holmes, Arntz, & Smucker, 2007; Morina, Lancee, & Arntz, 2017). In IR, which can be delivered within a single therapy session during the course of CBT, patients are guided to re-imagine past negative experiences in order to meet the needs of the younger self within the memory (Arntz & Weertman, 1999; Arntz, 2012). Patients’ rescripting of the memory typically involves actively imagining and guiding their younger selves to behave in ways they wished they could have at the time of the event, or having their older selves protect, nurture, or stand up for their younger selves in their moments of need. These interventions aim to make the event more positive or satisfying for the younger self such that new information is incorporated into the scene that can help to change the meaning of the memory. For example, by having the younger self stand-up to a critical other or receive compassion from the older self, the patient may observe that they did not deserve the harsh treatment they received at the time. By allowing the patient to change the memory in any way that they feel is right, IR can induce new perspectives on what happened at the time of the event (Arntz, 2011; Edwards, 2007).
Prior research has shown that IR delivered as a brief stand-alone intervention over the course of one or more sessions, either with or without cognitive restructuring, reduces social anxiety symptoms as well as the emotional impact and salience of negative autobiographical memories and associated memory-derived negative core beliefs (e.g., Frets, Kevenaar, & Heiden, 2014; Lee & Kwon, 2013; Nilsson, Lundh, & Viborg, 2012; Norton & Abbott, 2016; Reimer & Moscovitch, 2015; Wild, Hackmann, & Clark, 2007; Wild, Hackmann, & Clark, 2008). Though still empirically untested, a number of hypotheses have been proposed to account for the effects of IR, which correspond with differing views on what happens to the episodic memory itself as a result of treatment. Arntz has suggested that IR may modify the fear memory directly so that it becomes reconsolidated with a different meaning (Arntz & Weertman, 1999; Arntz, 2011). This account does not imply that IR erases the original memory representation, but rather that the meaning of the experience – particularly the automatic emotional processes associated with the memory – changes so that the original emotional memory no longer elicits the original emotional response. It is also possible that IR creates an alternative memory (or schema) that competes with the original for preferential retrieval (e.g., Brewin, 2006; Craske, Treanor, Conway, Zbozinek, & Vervliet, 2014).
At present, it is unknown whether the actual content of the rescripted autobiographical memory changes as a result of IR, or whether it is only its appraised meaning that changes. If memory content and/or meaning change during IR, is rescripting primarily responsible for this, or could similar changes occur by processing the memory in other ways, without explicit attempts to modify or rescript the memory itself? For example, imaginal exposure (IE) guides patients to relive a traumatic event repeatedly or over a prolonged period of time in as much sensory and emotional detail as possible (Foa & Rothbaum, 1998). Doing so is thought to facilitate emotional processing by activating the fear memory and enabling corrective information to be incorporated (Foa & Kozak, 1985, 1986; Lang, 1977). Research on IE for PTSD has shown that it promotes habituation to the fear response associated with the memory, reappraisal of the memory, and generation of a more coherent memory narrative (Foa & Cahill, 2001; Foa, 2011). Given that there are a number of similarities between Criterion A traumatic events and the socially painful or traumatic experiences described by socially anxious individuals (Carleton, Peluso, Collimore, & Asmundson, 2011; Erwin, Heimberg, Marx, & Franklin, 2006), IE may be similarly effective for modifying negative memories in SAD even in the absence of explicit rescripting (see Foa, Huppert, & Cahill, 2006).
The current study aimed to isolate the unique effects of rescripting on memory outcomes by examining the effects of single-session IR alongside two single session control conditions: (a) IE, in which patients were exposed deliberately and repeatedly to the negative memory content in their imagination without rescripting, and (b) supportive counselling (SC), in which patients were exposed to non-specific therapeutic components without repeated exposure to the memory narrative or rescripting. Though these brief interventions represent standalone protocols, they are best conceptualized as components of therapy rather than comprehensive treatments. As the modification of memory is thought to be central to the salutary benefits of IR, we were particularly interested in examining intervention-related changes in memory content, memory appraisals, and memory-derived schema (core beliefs). Given the relative brevity of the interventions and small sample size, we have conceptualized the present study as a preliminary investigation that would require replication and extension in future research.
We advanced several specific hypotheses. First, given that IR explicitly aims to rescript the content of episodic memory representations, we predicted that the content of participants’ autobiographical memory narratives would change uniquely in the IR condition such that positive and neutral memory details would increase over time, but that such enhancements in positive and neutral details would not occur in the other two conditions. Second, we anticipated that rescripting would facilitate significant changes in memory appraisals. Because Arntz has suggested that changes in meaning may be represented by changes in automatic emotional processes associated with the memory (Arntz & Weertman, 1999; Arntz, 2011), we operationalized memory appraisals as the amount of negative affect experienced upon memory retrieval as well as subjective ratings of memory intrusiveness and vividness. We expected that negative affect, intrusiveness, and vividness would decrease significantly over time for IR participants. Further, we expected that similar changes in memory appraisals would occur for those in the IE condition due to the effects of repeated imaginal exposure to the memory, but not for those in the SC condition in the absence of rescripting or exposure. Third, since IR is designed to facilitate new perspectives on the event, we hypothesized that rescripting would promote significant updating of participants’ negative core beliefs about the self and others, whereas the same would not be true of either IE or SC.
Section snippets
Participants
The study sample consisted of 33 community participants who met DSM-5 (American Psychiatric Association, 2013) criteria for a current principal DSM-5 diagnosis of SAD. Diagnoses were based on the administration of the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview 7.0 (MINI-7.0; Sheehan, 2014) and sections of the Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-5 (ADIS-5; Brown & Barlow, 2014) by trained graduate students. Exclusion criteria included endorsement of active and clinically significant
Preliminary analyses
Participant demographic and pre-intervention clinical and memory characteristics are presented in Table 1 and Supplementary Materials (Table S1). Groups did not differ on any measured characteristics at baseline, except for the total number of WIMI internal positive/neutral details. Bonferroni adjusted post-hoc comparisons revealed an unexpected significant difference between the IR and SC conditions, such that IR participants reported more internal positive/neutral details (M = 27.91, SD
Discussion
By randomly assigning participants with SAD to receive a single session of IR, IE, or SC, the present study was designed to advance our understanding of the effects of rescripting on memory outcomes, including representations of memory content, subjective memory appraisals, and memory-derived core beliefs.
Declaration of Competing Interest
None.
Acknowledgments
Funding: This work was supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research [grant numbers PJT-364337 to DM and MOP-49566 to MM].
We wish to thank research assistants Kerri Adams, Nick Zabara, Zoya Amir, Maggie Michealis, Prabhjot Saini, Ruofan Ma, Taylor Hudd, Kevin C. Barber, and Jessica R. Dupasquier whose hard work was integral to the completion of this study.
References (68)
Imagery rescripting for personality disorders
Cognitive and Behavioral Practice
(2011)- et al.
Treatment of childhood memories: Theory and practice
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1999) - et al.
The impact of social skills training for social anxiety disorder: A randomized controlled trial
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
(2014) Understanding cognitive behaviour therapy: A retrieval competition account
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2006)- et al.
Psychological theories of posttraumatic stress disorder
Clinical Psychology Review
(2003) - et al.
Social anxiety and posttraumatic stress symptoms: The impact of distressing social events
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
(2011) - et al.
An empirical review of potential mediators and mechanisms of prolonged exposure therapy
Clinical Psychology Review
(2017) - et al.
Homework “dose,” type, and helpfulness as predictors of clinical outcomes in prolonged exposure for PTSD
Behavior Therapy
(2017) - et al.
Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2014) - et al.
Psychometric properties of the credibility/expectancy questionnaire
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
(2000)
Restructuring implicational meaning through memory based imagery: Some historical notes
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Traumatic and socially stressful life events among persons with social anxiety disorder
Anxiety Disorders
Does reconsolidation occur in natural settings? Memory reconsolidation and anxiety disorders
Clinical Psychology Review
Neurobiology of schemas and schema-mediated memory
Trends in Cognitive Sciences
Emotional processing in psychological therapies
Imagery rescripting as a standalone treatment for patients with social phobia: a case series
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Recurrent images and early memories in social phobia
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Imagery and interpretations in social phobia: Support for the combined cognitive biases hypothesis
Behavior Therapy
Imagery rescripting in cognitive behaviour therapy: Images, treatment techniques and outcomes
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Efficacy of imagery rescripting and imaginal exposure for nightmares: A randomized wait-list controlled trial
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Imagery in therapy: An information processing analysis of fear
Behavior Therapy
The efficacy of imagery rescripting (IR) for social phobia: A randomized controlled trial
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Imagery enhancements increase the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural group therapy for social anxiety disorder: A benchmarking study
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Imagery rescripting as a clinical intervention for aversive memories: A meta-analysis
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Retrieval properties of negative vs. Positive mental images and autobiographical memories in social anxiety: Outcomes with a new measure
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Autobiographical memory retrieval and appraisal in social anxiety disorder
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Out of the shadows and into the spotlight: Social blunders fuel fear of self-exposure in social anxiety disorder
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
The effect of self-imagery on symptoms and processes in social anxiety: A systematic review
Clinical Psychology Review
Imagery rescripting of early memories in social anxiety disorder: an experimental study
Behaviour Research and Therapy
The efficacy of imagery rescripting compared to cognitive restructuring for social anxiety disorder
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
A cognitive-behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia
Behaviour Research and Therapy
The impact of imagery rescripting on memory appraisals and core beliefs in social anxiety disorder
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Imagery rescripting of early traumatic memories in social phobia
Cognitive and Behavioral Practice
When the present visits the past: Updating traumatic memories in social phobia
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Cited by (35)
Effects of imagery rescripting and imaginal exposure on voluntary memory
2023, Behaviour Research and TherapyImagery rescripting as a short intervention for symptoms associated with mental images in clinical disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis
2023, Journal of Psychiatric ResearchEfficacy of imagery rescripting in treating mental disorders associated with aversive memories – An updated meta-analysis
2023, Journal of Anxiety DisordersInternet videoconferencing delivered cognitive behavioral therapy for social anxiety disoder: Protocol for a randomized controlled trial
2023, Contemporary Clinical TrialsBrief imaginal exposure exercises for social anxiety disorder: A randomized controlled trial of a self-help momentary intervention app
2023, Journal of Anxiety DisordersAn online contextual schema therapy workshop for social anxiety symptoms – A randomized controlled trial
2023, Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science