Elsevier

Gait & Posture

Volume 32, Issue 3, July 2010, Pages 342-347
Gait & Posture

Gait patterns comparison of children with Duchenne muscular dystrophy to those of control subjects considering the effect of gait velocity

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2010.06.003Get rights and content

Abstract

3D analysis of the gait of children with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) was the topic of only a few studies and none of these considered the effect of gait velocity on the gait parameters of children with DMD. Gait parameters of 11 children with DMD were compared to those of 14 control children while considering the effect of gait velocity using 3D biomechanical analysis. Kinematic and kinetic gait parameters were measured using an Optotrak motion analysis system and AMTI force plates embedded in the floor. The data profiles of children with DMD walking at natural gait velocity were compared to those of the control children who walked at both natural and slow gait velocities. When both groups walked at similar velocity, children with DMD had higher cadence and shorter step length. They demonstrated a lower hip extension moment as well as a minimal or absent knee extension moment. At the ankle, a dorsiflexion moment was absent at heel strike due to the anterior location of the center of pressure. The magnitude of the medio-lateral ground reaction force was higher in children with DMD. Despite this increase, the hip abductor moment was lower. Hip power generation was also observed at the mid-stance in DMD children. These results suggest that most of the modifications observed are strategies used by children with DMD to cope with possible muscle weakness in order to provide support, propulsion and balance of the body during gait.

Introduction

Locomotor system impairments such as progressive muscle weakness, muscle fatigue and the development of joint contractures alter the gait abilities of children with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) [1], [2] (for review, see Gaudreault et al. [3]). Natural gait velocity is reduced in these children due to decreased step length [4], [5]. As regards kinematics and kinetics, children with DMD modify their trunk and lower limb position so that the flexor muscles sustain the effort rather than the extensors during the stance phase [5], [6]. Patte et al. [5] and Khodadadeh et al. [7] observed that during the initial part of the stance phase, children with DMD straightened their knee in order to rely on an internal knee flexion moment for stability. Conversely, Boccardi et al. [4] observed a knee flexion position and an extension moment as seen in healthy children. These authors concluded that children with DMD can effectively use their quadriceps to sustain an external flexion moment. At the ankle, an ankle plantarflexion position for children with DMD upon foot strike and during the stance phase has been observed [8]. This foot or forefoot contact is associated with an internal plantar flexion moment observed for the entire duration of the stance phase. Again, Boccardi et al. [4] do not entirely support the above description. These investigators observed a dorsiflexion position of the supporting foot upon initial contact and during the stance phase. In their opinion, this position facilitates the forward progression of the pelvis over the supporting foot, thus compensating for hip extensor weakness.

Although more is known about the gait of children with DMD, there is still no consensus on the interpretation of the kinetics and kinematics at the ankle and knee joints. Possible reasons for this disagreement might either be related to variability in the children strength profiles or to the effect of gait velocity. None of the previous studies has considered this factor. The effect of a lower gait velocity on the magnitude of the peak knee flexion angle and peak extension moment during the stance phase is documented in other patient populations [9]. Moreover, Diop et al. [10] and Stansfield et al. [11] report that gait velocity modifies pediatric gait kinematics and kinetics. Therefore, consideration should be given to this confounding variable to determine the pure effect of the disease on gait characteristics of children with DMD. The objective of this study is to compare the gait patterns of children with DMD to those of control children while considering the effect of gait velocity. We hypothesize that consideration for gait velocity attenuates the difference between normal and DMD gait patterns observed at natural velocity, thus revealing the true difference between both groups.

Section snippets

Participants

The study involved 11 children between 7 and 15 years of age who had a confirmed diagnosis of DMD by genetic testing and/or muscle biopsy (9.1 years (2.5); 30.2 kg (8.1); 1.27 m (0.06)). All children were on corticosteroid medication. They were able to walk independently, without braces. Based on the Vignos scale [12], the functional status of the children ranged from grade 2 to grade 5 (Table 1). At grade 2, the child can walk unassisted and climb stairs using a railing; whereas at grade 5, the

Clinical characteristics and time distance variables

Table 1 shows the clinical characteristics of the DMD children whereas Table 2 presents the peak values (mean ± SD) of the gait variables. At natural gait velocity, the children with DMD had a slower gait velocity and a shorter step length than the control children. However, cadence was similar in both groups. By contrast, when the control children walked slower, their mean velocity was similar to that of the DMD children, yet their cadence was lower.

Kinematics and kinetics, sagittal plane

The angular displacements, moments and power

Discussion

In this study, the gait parameters of children with DMD were compared to those of control children with consideration for the effect of velocity. This approach was substantiated by the fact that the natural gait velocity of children with DMD in our sample was effectively reduced in comparison with that of the control children. A decrease in gait velocity in children with DMD is a consistent finding reported by other authors [4], [5]. In this study, since cadence was not different between the

Study limitations

The small number of subjects and the variability in the clinical profiles of the children with DMD represents the main limitation in this study. However, the alterations described in the mean curve profiles are very similar among children with DMD of our sample. Also, data related to the pelvic and trunk segments would have helped in interpreting some findings and should be included in future studies.

Conclusion

For the first time, children with DMD gait characteristics were described relative to healthy children while considering the effect of gait velocity. Low magnitude of the hip extension moment and energy generation during the stance phase as well as the lack of involvement of the knee extensor muscles are not an effect of a lower gait velocity observed in children with DMD. These factors reflect the influence of muscle weakness on the gait of these children. The results of this study highlight

Conflict of interest statement

I confirm that no commercial relationships which may lead to conflict of interest were associated with this work.

Acknowledgements

The project was supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) in partnership with Muscular Dystrophy Canada. N. Gaudreault holds a scholarship from the CIHR and S. Nadeau has a junior II scientist salary from Fonds de la Recherche en Santé du Québec.

References (18)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (49)

  • Kinematic changes in gait in boys with Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy: Utility of the Gait Deviation Index, the Gait Profile Score and the Gait Variable Scores

    2023, Gait and Posture
    Citation Excerpt :

    If a measure similar to GPS and GVS were developed based on kinetic variables, this may be the ideal tool to identify the early biomechanical alterations secondary to muscle weakness in young boys with DMD. While the gait patterns of boys with DMD have been compared to TD children [8,23,27,28], there is minimal research examining the influence of steroids on gait patterns longitudinally. In contrast to our study findings, D’Angelo et al. [27] found that there were no significant differences in the kinematic patterns of boys on CS (N = 10) and those who are SN (N = 11); although, ankle power was decreased in the SN group in comparison to the CS group [27].

  • Gait deviations in Duchenne muscular dystrophy—Part 2. Statistical non-parametric mapping to analyze gait deviations in children with Duchenne muscular dystrophy

    2018, Gait and Posture
    Citation Excerpt :

    In part 1 of this study on gait pathology in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) we conducted a systematic literature search to map the gait deviations in children with DMD [1]. Our literature review indicated that the most consistent reported changes in gait kinematics in DMD were an increased total range of motion of the knee [2,3] and a decreased dorsiflexion angle in swing [2–5]. Additionally, a decrease in maximal power generation at the hip [2,5], maximal net knee extension torque [3,5,6], maximal net dorsiflexion torque [3,5,7], and maximal power generation at the ankle during push off [2,3,5] were reported in previous studies.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text