Predicting self-regulation and vocabulary and academic skills at kindergarten entry: The roles of maternal parenting stress and mother-child closeness
Introduction
Researchers have found that parenting stress, or parents’ subjective experience of distress regarding the parenting role (Abidin, 1992), can hinder children’s early academic skills, including vocabulary and approaches to learning, in part via diminished parental cognitive stimulation (Ayoub, Vallotton, & Mastergeorge, 2011; Chazan-Cohen et al., 2009; Noel, Peterson, & Jesso, 2008). Importantly, the contributions of parental stress to children’s early academic skills are likely to operate indirectly via intervening factors, such as parent-child relationship qualities and children’s socioemotional adjustment. However, research that examines these indirect processes in early childhood is limited. The goal of the present study was to investigate how low-income mothers’ parenting stress may indirectly impact vocabulary and early academic skills of children just before kindergarten entry via mother-child closeness and children’s self-regulation skills.
For children to succeed when they reach kindergarten, they must be ready for the demands of a school day, such as following directions, paying attention, and understanding basic academic terms (Rimm-Kaufman, Pianta, & Cox, 2000). Children who enter school with strong early academic and social skills are likely to adjust well to school and to complete high school (Ensminger & Slusarcick, 1992). Unfortunately, kindergarten teachers seem to be in wide agreement that many of their students are not ready to succeed academically, with a nationally representative sample of kindergarten teachers reporting that just 26% of first-time kindergarten students demonstrated positive approaches to learning “very often.” Supporting the validity of teachers’ views, fall approaches to learning scores were positively associated with mathematics, reading, and science scores in kindergarten and first grade (Kena et al., 2015). School readiness is an especially serious problem for children in low-income families (Duncan & Magnuson, 2013). Thus, it is important to identify the factors that affect children’s academic skills, particularly for children growing up in poverty.
Research identifying the skills most important for children’s readiness to start school commonly focuses on aspects of socioemotional functioning, early numeracy, and language skills. One key aspect of socioemotional functioning is self-regulation, or the ability to focus attention and exercise inhibitory control – that is, control automatic responses by restraining irrelevant responses while initiating nondominant adaptive solutions (Duncan et al., 2007; Son, Lee, & Sung, 2013). Self- regulation skills are critical for school success because children who are strong self-regulators are able to focus attention and engage in classroom content (Blair & Razza, 2007; McClelland, Cameron, Wanless, & Murray, 2007). Additionally, researchers have found that children’s self-regulation skills predict math and reading scores concurrently and longitudinally (Guimard, Hubert, Crusson-Pondeville, & Nocus, 2012; McClelland, Acock, & Morrison, 2006).
Unfortunately, much research suggests that poverty hinders the development of these skills and that low-income children are more likely than middle-income children to experience negative outcomes in school, in part due to regulatory deficits (Blair et al., 2011; Brock, Rimm-Kaufman, Nathanson, & Grimm, 2009; Evans & English, 2002). For example, Duncan and Murnane (2014) found that at the start of the school year, kindergarten teachers rate higher-income students ahead of children from low-income families on measures of attention, engagement in schoolwork, and early math and literacy skills, and these gaps had not decreased at 5th grade. The individual and relational mechanisms through which poverty affects families likely underlie such deficits (Yoshikawa, Aber, & Beardslee, 2012).
Rates of depression and general stress are high among low-income mothers with young children. For example, among mothers participating in the Early Head Start Research and Evaluation Project (EHSREP), almost half (48%) suffered from a moderate to severe number of depressive symptoms at the study’s outset. At this time, a quarter of the mothers were pregnant; the rest had infants younger than 12 months of age. Pregnant women were especially likely to be at risk of depression; 68% reported clinically significant levels of depressive symptoms. When children were 1 year old, and two years later when children were age 3, 33% of mothers scored above a clinical cutoff for depressive symptoms. For 12% of the mothers, depression was chronic as reflected by high scores at both time-points (Administration for Children and Families, 2006). A recent study of low-income mothers in Maryland uncovered the same pattern; over half reported feeling depressed, hopeless, or sad (Goldhagen, Harbin, & Forry, 2013).
Families living in poverty contend with many more stress-inducing circumstances than more advantaged families, including higher probabilities of family instability, food insecurity, substandard housing, inadequate transportation, low-status work with little job security, mismatch between work hours and the hours of most child care establishments, and neighborhood violence (Evans, Chen, Miller, & Seeman, 2012; Heberle, Thomas, Wagmiller, & Briggs-Gowan, 2014; Ispa, Thornburg, & Fine, 2006). Such contextual barriers contribute to difficulties coping with the psychological demands of parenting (Conger, Ge, Elder, Lorenz, & Simons, 1994; Garbarino, Vorrasi, & Kostelny, 2002; Magnuson & Duncan, 2002). Moreover, low life satisfaction, greater general psychological distress, and parenting stress tend to co-occur (Crnic & Greenberg, 1990; Thompson, Merritt, Keith, Bennett, & Johndrow, 1993). This problem is compounded by very limited access to affordable mental health treatment (Ayoub, Bartlett, Chazan-Cohen, & Raikes, 2014).
Parenting stress differs from general depression in that general depression is typically defined in broader terms and as involving feelings of malaise or sadness in regards to many aspects of daily living, whereas parenting stress involves negative feelings stemming specifically from the parenting role. For example, in addition to tapping general distress, the subscales of the widely used Parenting Stress Index assess the degree to which parents find parenting overly restrictive and emotionally burdensome, and the extent to which they feel that their children have less desirable qualities than other children (Abidin, 1990).
We focus on parenting stress in toddlerhood because this developmental period is challenging for many parents due to heightened negativity and oppositionality as children strive for autonomy (Keenan & Wakschlag, 2000; Williford, Calkins, & Keane, 2007). In fact, Ayoub et al. (2011) found that in the EHSREP sample, children’s self-regulation scores dipped at 24 months as compared to their scores at 14 and 36 months. Moreover, parenting stress during children’s first years may have implications for future developmental outcomes. For instance, Benzies, Harrison, and Magill-Evans (2004) found that parenting stress during infancy predicts behavior problems in later childhood. Given the positive association between depressive symptomatology and parenting stress (Whiteside-Mansell et al., 2007), studies indicating that maternal depression during infancy is more strongly linked to long-term adjustment than maternal depression when children are older underscore the importance of examining the longitudinal implications of early parenting stress (Bureau, Easterbrooks, & Lyons-Ruth, 2009; Murray, Cooper, & Hipwell, 2003).
Belsky (1984) asserted that parents’ psychological well-being is a key factor in parenting and children’s development because it affects parents’ functioning in the childrearing role, and because parents who are psychologically healthy are better able to enlist valuable outside support. In support of this idea, others have found that parenting stress, an indicator of psychological well-being, predicts low child-directed nurturance and positivity, low dyadic pleasure, and the use of inconsistent, strict, and power-assertive disciplinary practices (Anthony et al., 2005; Crnic, Gaze, & Hoffman, 2005; Crnic and Greenberg, 1987, Deater-Deckard, 2004, Deater-Deckard and Scarr, 1996). Further, multiple studies show negative linkages among various measures of maternal stress and children’s pre-academic skills, including receptive and expressive language skills and approaches to learning (Ayoub et al., 2011; Chazan-Cohen et al., 2009; Noel, Peterson, & Jesso, 2008).
Attachment theory (Ainsworth, Blehar, Waters, & Wall, 1978; Bowlby, 1969) complements the process model of parenting in highlighting parent-child closeness as central in children’s development. A large body of research supports this premise, suggesting that maternal sensitivity and positive regard, behaviors that promote mother-child closeness, predict a range of concurrent and future positive child outcomes, including verbal and math ability (Downer & Pianta, 2006; Harris, Sideris, Sipwell, Burchinal, & Pickett, 2014). Maternal sensitivity and positive regard also predict children’s scores on tests of language development, math skills, and general cognitive development, perhaps in part because self-regulation is compromised when mothers are less sensitive (Connell and Prinz, 2002, Downer and Pianta, 2006, Harris et al., 2014; Pungello, Iruka, Dotterer, Mills-Koonce, & Reznick, 2009; Tamis-LeMonda, Shannon, Cabrera, & Lamb, 2004).
Early caregiving is a central mechanism influencing self-regulation; it is through interactions with caregivers that children are exposed to regulatory strategies and given the chance to develop their own self-regulation skills (Kopp, 1989). Some hypothesize that exposure to parenting stress directly impacts children’s self-regulation in part because parents who are stressed may model ineffective coping strategies (Halberstadt, Crisp, & Eaton, 1999). This may be one reason why high parenting stress is directly linked to deficits in children’s self-regulation skills and behavior problems (Ayoub et al., 2011, Burkhardt, 2014, Deater-Deckard and Scarr, 1996, Mathis and Bierman, 2015). It may also be that parenting stress indirectly impacts child regulatory skills because it compromises parents’ ability to respond to children in warm and sensitive ways (Anthony et al., 2005). Indeed, research indicates that mothers’ sensitive parenting links to children’s abilities to regulate their emotions and control their attention in both early and middle childhood (Ayoub et al., 2011, Blair and Razza, 2007, Bradley and Corwyn, 2007; Kochanska, Aksan, Prisco, & Adams, 2008; Kochanska, Coy, & Murray, 2001; Kopp, 1989, Perry et al., 2013, Thompson, 1998; von Suchodoletz, Trommsdorff, & Heikamp, 2011). Conversely, others have found that low nurturance and highly directive parenting typified by negativity link to child non-compliance, externalizing behavior, and other indicators of regulatory deficits (Bates, Petit, Dodge, & Ridge, 1998; O’Leary, Slep, & Reid, 1999; Olson, Bates, Sandy, & Schilling, 2002; von Suchodoletz, Trommsdorff, & Heikamp, 2011).
It would seem to follow from an integration of these literatures that parenting stress exerts its influence on children’s early vocabulary and academic skills indirectly, in part by threatening the establishment of parent-child closeness, and thereby compromising children’s regulatory capabilities. However, the few studies that test this hypothesis have yielded mixed results. In a study demonstrating an important benefit of participation in Early Head Start, Ayoub et al. (2011) found that maternal parenting behavior mediated the relation between parenting stress and child vocabulary at 24 months, but only for families in the comparison group. Also only in the comparison group, parenting stress had direct effects on children’s later self-regulatory skills; however, this effect was not mediated by parenting quality. The researchers explained the absence of any mediation effects in the intervention group as likely due to program efforts to promote positive parent-child interactional qualities; interventionists’ efforts appear to have protected parenting by helping mothers engage in supportive childrearing behaviors even when they were feeling stressed. In other studies, Anthony et al. (2005), Crnic et al. (2005), and Mathis and Bierman (2015) similarly found direct relations between parenting stress and preschoolers’ social competence and self-regulation, but parenting quality did not explain the connections.
Despite these mixed findings, strong conceptual support for the mediating roles of parent-child relationship quality and children’s self-regulation skills in explaining relations between maternal parenting stress and children’s early vocabulary and academic skills motivated us to examine this hypothesis anew. We used longitudinal data collected from low-income families and a set of measures not previously employed in investigations testing these relations. Specifically, we examined the extent to which maternal parenting stress when children were 15 months old predicted mother-child closeness when children were 25 months old and children’s self-regulation and vocabulary and academic skills just before kindergarten entry (see Fig. 1). Based on prior research, we hypothesized that maternal parenting stress would be negatively related to mother-child closeness. We expected diminished mother-child closeness, in turn, to have negative implications for children’s self-regulation skills, which were expected to positively relate to children’s vocabulary and academic skill levels.
We also tested a three-path mediational model to examine relations among maternal parenting stress at 15 months, mother-child closeness at 25 months, self-regulation skills just before kindergarten entry, and vocabulary and academic skills just before kindergarten entry. Three-path mediational models involve a series of consecutive mediators, with the first predicting the second – in this case, mother-child closeness and child self-regulation mediating the relations between maternal parenting stress and kindergarten entry vocabulary and academic skills, consecutively. We predicted that maternal parenting stress would be inversely related to children’s vocabulary and academic skills just before kindergarten entry, and that mother-child closeness and self-regulation skills would consecutively mediate this relation.
Section snippets
Participants
Participants for this study were drawn from the 3001 families participating in the EHSREP, an experimental study conducted at 17 Early Head Start (EHS) sites across the United States (Administration for Children and Families, 2002). EHS is a two-generation program that serves low-income families with pregnant mothers and children up to age 3. Eligibility for the study included being the caregiver of a child younger than 12 months at time of application and meeting federal income eligibility
Analytic plan
Preliminary analyses were conducted to examine the distribution of study variables and to determine whether the patterns of associations varied by EHS program versus comparison group or by children’s gender and ethnoracial group. Next, we used structural equation modeling to examine the contribution of maternal parenting stress to mother-child closeness, self-regulation, and vocabulary and academic skills, and to test for mediation between maternal parenting stress and vocabulary and academic
Discussion
The goals of this study were to examine the longitudinal relations between maternal parenting stress, mother-child closeness, children’s self-regulation skills, and children’s vocabulary and academic skills. In our diverse sample of low-income families, maternal parenting stress when children were 15 months old was predictive of mother-child closeness when children were 25 months old, and of children’s vocabulary and academic skills just before kindergarten entry. In addition, mother-child
Acknowledgements
The findings reported here are based on research conducted as part of the national Early Head Start Research and Evaluation Project funded by the Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services under contract under Contract 233-02-0086/HHSP233200600003T, to Mathematica Policy Research, Princeton, NJ and Columbia University’s National Center for Children and Families, Teachers College, in conjunction with the Early Head Start Research Consortium. The
References (104)
- et al.
Maternal psychological functioning and children’s school readiness: the mediating role of home environments for African American children
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2013) - et al.
The contributions of hot and cool executive function to children’s academic achievement, learning-related behaviors, and engagement in kindergarten
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2009) - et al.
The impact of childcare and parent-child interactions on school readiness and social skills development for low-income African-American children
Journal of School Psychology
(2002) - et al.
Behavioral regulation and academic performance in kindergarten
Psychologie Française
(2012) Promoting toddlers’ language development through community-based intervention
Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology
(2000)- et al.
The impact of kindergarten learning-related skills on academic trajectories at the end of elementary school
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2006) - et al.
Family and social risk, and parental investments during the early childhood years as predictors of low-income children’s school readiness outcomes
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2010) - et al.
Teachers’ judgments of problems in the transition to kindergarten
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2000) Parenting stress index/short form
(1990)The determinants of parenting behavior
Journal of Clinical Child Psychology
(1992)
Making a difference in the lives of infants and toddlers and their families: the impacts of Early Head Start
Depression in the lives of early head start families: research to practice brief
Patterns of attachment: a psychological study of the Strange Situation
Relations between inhibitory control and the development of academic skills in preschool and kindergarten: a meta-analysis
Developmental Psychology
The relationships between stress, parenting behavior, and preschoolers’ social competence and behavior problems in the classroom
Infant and Child Development
Preschool care center quality effects on academic achievement: an instrumental variables analysis
Developmental Psychology
Developmental pathways to integrated social skills: the roles of parenting and early intervention in raising healthy children
Child Development
Early Head Start: mental health, parenting, and impacts on children
Interaction of temperamental resistance to control and restrictive parenting in the development of externalizing behavior
Developmental Psychology
Parenting, attention and externalizing problems: testing mediation longitudinally, repeatedly and reciprocally
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines
The determinants of parenting: a process model
Child Development
Parenting stress, marital quality, and child behavior problems at age 7 years
Public Health Nursing
Links between childbearing age and observed maternal behaviors with 14-month-olds in the Early Head Start Research and Evaluation Project
Infant Mental Health Journal
Relating effortful control, executive function, and false belief understanding to emerging math and literacy ability in kindergarten
Child Development
Salivary cortisol mediates effects of poverty and parenting on executive functions in early childhood
Child Development
School readiness: integrating cognition and emotion in a neurobiological conceptualization of children’s functioning at school entry
American Psychologist
Attachment and loss, Vol. 1: attachment
Externalizing problems in fifth grade: relations with productive activity, maternal sensitivity and harsh parenting from infancy through middle childhood
Developmental Psychology
Mother-infant interactions in Early Head Start: a person-oriented within-ethnic group approach
Parenting: Science and Practice
The effects of poverty on children
The Future of Children
The contribution of parenting to ethnic and racial gaps in school readiness
The Future of Children
Alternative ways of assessing model fit
Maternal depression in infancy: critical to children’s depression in childhood and adolescence?
Development and Psychopathology
Evidence-based assessment of cognitive functioning in pediatric psychology
Journal of Pediatric Psychology
It takes time: impacts of Early Head Start that lead to reductions in maternal depression two years later
Infant Mental Health Journal
Low-income children’s school readiness: parent contributions over the first five years
Early Education and Development
Statistical power analysis for behavioral sciences
A family process model of economic hardship and adjustment of early adolescent boys
Child Development
Economic stress, coercive family process: and developmental problems of adolescents
Child Development
It takes two to replicate: a mediational model for the impact of parents’ stress on adolescent adjustment
Child Development
Preschool social-emotional skills training: a controlled pilot test of the making choices and strong families programs
Research on Social Work Practice
Maternal stress, social support, and coping: influences on early mother-child relationship
Minor parenting stresses in young children
Child Development
Cumulative parenting stress across the preschool period: relations to maternal parenting and child behaviour at age 5
Infant and Child Development
Parenting stress among dual-earner mothers and fathers: are there gender differences?
Journal of Family Psychology
Parenting stress
Academic and cognitive functioning in first grade: associations with earlier home and child care predictors and with concurrent home and classroom experiences
School Psychology Review
Investing in preschool programs
Journal of Economic Perspectives
Restoring opportunity: the crisis of inequality and the challenge for American education
Cited by (31)
The long arm of adversity: Children's kindergarten math skills are associated with maternal childhood adversity
2023, Child Abuse and NeglectInteractions between child temperament and family environment in relation to school readiness: Diathesis-stress, differential susceptibility, or vantage sensitivity?
2022, Early Childhood Research QuarterlyCitation Excerpt :Some aspects of the family environment directly influence children's development and are identified as proximal factors, (e.g., the quality of daily parent-child interactions, discipline, stimulation) while others are qualified as distal (e.g., sociodemographic risks such as low family income, mother's young age at child's birth, parents’ level of education, etc.) as they indirectly influence child development through proximal processes. Both have shown significant relationships with school readiness (Ansari & Gershoff, 2016; Chazan-Cohen et al., 2009; Dotterer et al., 2012; Harmeyer et al., 2016; Hindman & Morrison, 2012; Micalizzi et al., 2019; Oxford & Lee, 2011). For example, Harmeyer and her collegues (2016) found that observed mother-child closeness was associated with children's self-regulatory and cognitive skills in the preschool years.
Academic implications of insensitive parenting: A mediating path through children's relational representations
2020, Journal of Applied Developmental PsychologyCitation Excerpt :For example, although the majority of extant research on parenting and child achievement has emphasized the quantity of parental reading activities and school involvement (Goldfield & Snow, 1984; Justice & Kaderavek, 2002; Lonigan, Anthony, Bloomfield, Dyer, & Samwel, 1999), a growing number of studies have considered the implications of parents' sensitive and supportive caregiving beyond school-specific settings for understanding children's educational success (e.g., Vasquez, Patall, Fong, Corrigan, & Pine, 2016). Indeed, building on attachment studies demonstrating that sensitive and responsive parenting supports healthy emotional development in early childhood (Ainsworth, 1969; Sroufe, 1983), researchers have documented clear and convincing relations between early caregiving sensitivity (e.g., exchanges characterized by high warmth and support, and low intrusiveness and hostility) and young children's adjustment in preschool (Bono, Sy, & Kopp, 2016; Bornstein et al., 2020; Harmeyer, Ispa, Palermo, & Carlo, 2016; Zvara, Keim, Boone, & Anderson, 2019). Extending beyond the preschool period, some data point to significant relations between insensitive parenting and children's compromised academic achievement (Monti, Pomerantz, & Roisman, 2014), but there is a need for further research, particularly to evaluate theoretically-specified mechanisms thought to underlie such relations.
Factors associated with early school readiness profiles for Black girls
2020, Early Childhood Research QuarterlyLatina mothers' mental health and children's academic readiness: Moderation by maternal education
2019, Journal of Applied Developmental PsychologyCitation Excerpt :Ultimately, the impact of familism may thus enhance children's academic skills by fostering mothers' mental health and ability to engage in warm parenting behaviors (Calzada et al., 2013; Kim et al., 2018). The toll that parenting stress and mental health difficulties such as depression can take on Latina mothers is critical because they compromise affectionate parenting behaviors that support children's academic skills, in part by fostering self-regulatory abilities (Halberstadt, Crisp, & Eaton, 1999; Harmeyer et al., 2016; Ispa, Su-Russell, Palermo, & Carlo, 2017). For example, Kopystynska, Spinrad, Seay, and Eisenberg (2016) found that when mothers used gentle control strategies such as polite suggestions and affectionate encouragement to guide toddlers' behavior at 18 months of age, and they conveyed such control strategies with high sensitivity, their children were likely to exhibit enhanced self-regulation abilities a year later (measured by delay of gratification tasks and parent reports of effortful control).
Has maternal sensitivity been comprehensively investigated in Sub-Saharan Africa? A narrative scoping review
2023, Acta Neuropsychiatrica