Childhood adversity and the risk of substance use and delinquency: The role of protective adult relationships
Introduction
Early life adversity has significant long-term effects on psychological, emotional, and behavioral outcomes. Research indicates that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) can threaten a youth’s development and well-being, and contribute to issues including substance abuse (Dube et al., 2003) and delinquency (Duke, Pettingell, McMorris, & Borowsky, 2010), in addition to other negative mental and physical health problems that occur later in life (Schilling, Aseltine, & Gore, 2007). ACEs are stressful and/or traumatic events that may include abuse, neglect, household dysfunction, and exposure to violence and crime (Felitti et al., 1998). Youth involved in the child welfare system are often more likely than other youth to experience multiple risks, such as exposure to abuse and neglect and living with a caregiver who is unable to adequately meet their needs due to substance misuse (Smith, Johnson, Pears, Fisher, & DeGarmo, 2007), mental health (Park, Solomon, & Mandell, 2006), or domestic violence (Renner & Slack, 2006). Prior studies on ACEs have found that these differential forms of adversity tend to co-occur (Anda, 1999, Felitti et al., 1998), and may thus increase the likelihood of engagement in harmful behaviors among this vulnerable population.
Childhood adversity may lead to the development of risk-taking behaviors. Compared to youth in the general population, child welfare-involved youth are at increased risk of engaging in substance use (Fettes, Aarons, & Green, 2013; Traube, James, Zhang, & Landsverk, 2012) and delinquency (Grogan-Kaylor, Ruffolo, Ortega, & Clarke, 2008; Ryan & Testa, 2005). Youth who have experienced at least one substantiated report of abuse or neglect are 47% more likely to participate in delinquent acts than youth without substantiated maltreatment (Ryan & Testa, 2005). Baglivio, Wolff, Piquero, & Epps, 2015 found, when identifying delinquency trajectories, that youth with higher ACE scores had a younger age at first arrest and significantly higher total number of arrests during adolescence. In addition, many child welfare-involved youth experience various substance related ACEs, such as residing with a substance-abusing parent, and are therefore at greater risk to abuse substances themselves (Schuck & Widom, 2001). Substance use rates, for those with child welfare experiences, are around 47% for alcohol or tobacco combined, and 17% for other illicit use (Traube et al., 2012). Furthermore, a strong bidirectional link between illicit drug use and delinquency exists, such that substance use has been shown to be associated with criminal and delinquent behavior in adolescents (Ford, 2005, Loeber and Farrington, 2000), with research also suggesting that early delinquency precipitates initiation in later drug use (Mason, Hitchings, & Spoth, 2007).
Prior researchers have also conceptualized substance use and delinquency as forms of coping behaviors (Agnew, 1985, Cooper, 1994). For example, the use of substances may be a method by which youth cope or, “self-medicate,” with stress and trauma (Dixon, Leen-Feldner, Ham, Feldner, & Lewis, 2009; Leeis, Pagura, Sareen, & Bolton, 2010; Rothman, Edwards, Heeren, & Hingson, 2008). The self-medication hypothesis suggests that individual’s suffering from post-traumatic stress reactions may use substances to cope with negative affect associated with traumatic event exposure (Haller & Chassin, 2014). Cooper (1994) also postulates that, in addition to alleviating negative affective states, youth exposed to traumatic stress may be motivated to consume substances to increase positive feelings. In addition, based upon strain theory, youth may engage in delinquent acts to cope with problems involving undesirable social environments, thereby allowing youth to adapt to the negative emotional consequences of early environmental stress (Brezina, 1996).
While some early adversity may not impact youths’ well-being and behavioral outcomes, exposure to multiple adversities in childhood may become toxic. Indeed, Shonkoff et al. (2009) propose that much of what contributes to the long-term consequences associated with prolonged exposure to early adversity is the lack of a supportive buffering adult. Research has demonstrated that disrupted social networks influence the relationship between multiple early adversities and negative life trajectories (Wickrama, Conger, Lorenz, & Jung, 2008), and that maltreated youth identify significantly fewer individuals in their support systems compared to other youth (Negriff, James, & Trickett, 2015). For example, ACEs that include abuse and neglect perpetrated by a primary caregiver or living with a parent with substance abuse, may constitute toxic stress that further threatens long-term health and development, particularly among child welfare-involved youth. Conversely, early adversity may be considered as “tolerable stress” when youth are surrounded by protective relationships, specifically those that facilitate adaptive coping skills (Shonkoff, Boyce, & McEwen, 2009). Prospective studies suggest that promoting supportive networks may reduce long-term substance use (Laudet, Cleland, Magura, Vogel, & Knight, 2004) and delinquency (Bender & Lösel, 1997). Thus, enhancing the support systems for youth who have experienced multiple ACEs may help foster healthy well-being and long-term prosocial behavior.
Although the links between childhood adversity and substance use and delinquency, independently, have been identified, there is a paucity of research that identifies protective factors and the influence of potentially modifiable factors that could buffer against the effects of early adverse experiences (Baglivio et al., 2015). Without identifying the factors influencing youths’ engagement in delinquency and substance use and the possible protective factors that may attenuate these high-risk behaviors, important opportunities to isolate targets to intervene with vulnerable youth may be missed. Therefore, the current study extends the existing body of literature in this area by using data from a nationally representative child welfare sample to examine whether protective adult relationships moderate the relationships between cumulative ACEs and substance use and delinquency. It was hypothesized that cumulative ACEs would be associated with increased substance use and delinquency among child welfare-involved youth. In addition to these main effects, it was also hypothesized that there would be interaction effects of ACEs and adult support on substance use and delinquency. Specifically, higher levels of protective adult relationships and the presence of ACEs would be associated with decreased substance use and delinquency. Conversely, lower levels of protective adult relationships and the presence of ACEs would be associated with increased substance use and delinquency.
Section snippets
Sample design and procedures
This study used data collected from Wave I of the National Survey of Child and Adolescent Well-being (NSCAW II). NSCAW II is a national longitudinal study of 5873 children and youth ages birth to 18 years who had investigations of child maltreatment by child welfare agencies in the United States. NSCAW II used a two-stage stratified cluster sample of children. First, eight sampling strata were identified based on the states having the largest child protective services (CPS) caseloads. A ninth
Sample characteristics
The study sample included 1054 (weighted N = 772,530) youth, ages 11–17, who were assessed for maltreatment in Wave I of NSCAW II. Youth ethnically identified primarily as White/Non-Hispanic (unweighted = 38.1%; weighted = 43.2%), followed by Black/Non-Hispanic (unweighted = 27.2%; weighted = 20.0%), Hispanic (unweighted = 24.2%; weighted = 27.5%), and other (unweighted = 10.5%; weighted = 9.3%). The sample included 55.3% female (weighted = 59.1%) and 44.7% male (weighted = 40.9%) youth. On average, youth
Discussion
There is strong empirical evidence that the experiences of traumatic events in childhood impacts both physical and behavioral health across the lifespan (Shern, Blanch, & Steverman, 2016). Such deleterious outcomes include health related consequences (obesity, sleep disturbances, smoking, lung disease), mental health, and addiction related consequences (depression, anxiety, PTSD, suicidality). In fact, one study found that preventing ACEs related to physical abuse, witnessed abuse, or sexual
Conclusion
Overall, our findings suggest that ACEs are associated with youth risk-taking behaviors such as substance use and delinquency, and that the relationship between early adversity and these behaviors may be influenced by youths’ protective adult relationships. Specifically, youth with histories of ACEs and fewer protective adult relationships were more likely to engage in substance use. In order to mitigate the effects of early life stress among youth involved in the child welfare system, better
Conflict of interest
All authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgements
Data used for this study is from the National Survey on Child and Adolescent Well-Being II and were provided by the National Data Archive on Child Abuse and Neglect. The authors are solely responsible for the information presented in this article.
References (74)
- et al.
Qualitative exploration of relationships with important non-parental adults in the lives of youth in foster care
Children and Youth Services Review
(2011) - et al.
The relationships between adverse childhood experiences (ACE) and juvenile offending trajectories in a juvenile offender sample
Journal of Criminal Justice
(2015) - et al.
Protective and risk effects of peer relations and social support on antisocial behaviour in adolescents from multi-problem milieus
Journal of Adolescence
(1997) - et al.
Alcohol use motives among traumatic event-exposed, treatment-seeking adolescents: Associations with posttraumatic stress
Addictive Behaviors
(2009) - et al.
Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
(1998) - et al.
Trauma changes everything: Examining the relationship between adverse childhood experiences and serious, violent and chronic juvenile offenders
Child Abuse & Neglect
(2015) - et al.
Behaviors of youth involved in the child welfare system
Child Abuse & Neglect
(2008) - et al.
Child neglect: Developmental issues and outcomes
Child Abuse & Neglect
(2002) - et al.
A longitudinal study of developmental trajectories to young adult cigarette smoking
Drug and Alcohol Dependence
(2002) - et al.
A steady presence in the midst of change: Non-kin natural mentors in the lives of older youth exiting foster care
Children and Youth Services Review
(2010)
Intimate partner violence and child maltreatment: Understanding intra- and intergenerational connections
Child Abuse & Neglect
Parenting stress among child welfare involved families: Differences by child placement
Children and Youth Services Review
Child maltreatment and juvenile delinquency: Investigating the role of placement and placement instability
Children and Youth Services Review
Childhood victimization and alcohol symptoms in females: Causal inferences and hypothesized mediators
Child Abuse & Neglect
In search of connection: The foster youth and caregiver relationship
Child and Youth Services Review
Risk behaviors in maltreated youth placed in foster care: A longitudinal study of protective and vulnerability factors
Child Abuse & Neglect
A national study of risk and protective factors for substance use among youth in the child welfare system
Addictive Behaviors
Does parental absence reduce cognitive achievements? Evidence from rural China
Journal of Development Economics
Population attributable fractions of psychiatric disorders and suicide ideation and attempts associated with adverse childhood experiences
American Journal of Public Health
A revised strain theory of delinquency
Social Forces
Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions
Adverse childhood experiences and smoking during adolescence and adulthood
Journal of the American Medical Association
Self-reported abuse history and adolescent problem behaviors. II. Alcohold and drug use
Journal of Adolescent Health
Adapting to strain: An examination of delinquent coping responses
Criminology
The next generation of moderator research in personality psychology
Journal of Personality
Child welfare information gateway, children’s bureau, administration for children, youth, and families
Differential Response to Reports of Child Abuse and Neglect
Treating trauma and traumatic grief in children and adolescents
Supporting youth in the transition from foster care: Formal and informal connections
Child Welfare
Motivations for alcohol use among adolescents: Development and validation of a four-factor model
Psychological Assessment
Adolescent sexuality: Disentangling the effects of family structure and family context
Journal of Marriage and Family
Can data evelopment analysis provide a scalar index of value? DEA index of value
Health Economics
Childhood abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction and the risk of illicit drug use: The adverse childhood experiences study
Pediatrics
Adolescent violence perpetration: Associations with multiple types of adverse childhood experiences
Pediatrics
Does father absence place daughters at special risk for early sexual activity and teenage pregnancy?
Child Development
Higher rates of adolescent substance use in child welfare versus community populations in the United States
Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs
Stress, coping, and high-risk sexual behavior
Health Psychology
Substance use, the social bond, and delinquency*
Sociological Inquiry
Cited by (97)
The cortisol/DHEA ratio mediates the association between early life stress and externalizing problems in adolescent boys
2024, PsychoneuroendocrinologyMeasuring adverse childhood experiences with latent class trajectories
2023, Child Abuse and NeglectAdverse childhood experiences and delinquency: Does age of assessment matter?
2023, Journal of Criminal JusticeNo one runs alone: Combining community-based program evaluation with photo elicitation interviewing among people experiencing homelessness
2023, Evaluation and Program PlanningCitation Excerpt :Poor health outcomes associated with homelessness is well documented throughout the literature. Compared to housed individuals, people experiencing homelessness have higher rates of morbidity and mortality associated with chronic physical and mental illness, and elevated rates substance use disorders (Fleisch and Nash, 2019; Baxter, Tweed, Katikireddi, & Thomson, 2019; Hwang, Kirst, & Chiu, 2009; Watson, Crawley, & Kane, 2016; Fazel, Khosla, Doll, & Geddes, 2008; Fazel, Geddes, & Kushel, 2014; Lee, Jun, & Kim, 2017; Anon, 2022a; Hodgetts, Radley, Chamberlain, & Hodgetts, 2007; Patterson, 2022; Schutt, Meschede, & Rierdan, 1994; Greenberg and Rosenheck, 2010; SAMHSA, 2022). For example, approximately 30 percent of people experiencing chronic homelessness have mental health conditions and approximately 50 percent have co-occurring substance use problems (SAMHSA, 2022).