Predictors of resilience in abused and neglected children grown-up: The role of individual and neighborhood characteristics☆
Introduction
Childhood victimization has the potential to affect a number of domains of a person's functioning (Widom, 2000) and numerous papers have reported on the long-term negative consequences of child maltreatment (Augoustinos, 1987, Beitchman et al., 1992, Berliner, 1991, Widom, 1989b, Wolfe, 1987). However, researchers have also observed that there are children who appear resilient and do not manifest problem behaviors despite facing considerable adversity or trauma in childhood (Cicchetti, Rogosch, Lynch, & Holt, 1993; Egeland, Carlson, & Sroufe, 1993; Garmezy & Masten, 1986; Kaufman & Zigler, 1987; Luthar, Cicchetti, & Becker, 2000; Mannarino & Cohen, 1987; McGloin & Widom, 2001; Sirles, Smith, & Kusama, 1989; Widom, 1989c).
Operational definitions of resilience vary considerably. Some studies have used only one criterion (Chambers & Belicki, 1998; Widom, 1991), while others have used more than one criterion (Chandy, Blum, & Resnick, 1996). For example, researchers have defined resilience as: (1) performing at least above average in school, having no suicide risk, no history of marijuana use, and infrequent or no use of alcohol or tobacco (Chandy et al., 1996); (2) having a good quality of sleep (Chambers & Belicki, 1998); and (3) not being depressed in combination with having good levels of self-esteem (Liem, James, O’Toole, & Boudewyn, 1997).
There is also considerable variation in the methods and samples used in studies that have examined factors that contribute to resilience in abused and/or neglected children (for summaries, see Bolger & Patterson, 2003; Heller, Larrieu, D’Imperio, & Boris, 1999). Longitudinal studies have been used to investigate predictors of resilience among maltreated children, but have been limited to relatively small samples (Egeland et al., 1993, Herrenkohl et al., 1994). Studies that have examined predictors of resilience among adults have generally consisted of qualitative case studies of female victims of sexual abuse (Banyard, Williams, Siegel, & West, 2002; Himelein & McElrath, 1996; Hyman & Williams, 2001; Valentine & Feinauer, 1993).
Despite the lack of an extensive literature on predictors of resilience, a few factors have emerged as likely candidates. Clinicians and child protective service workers have stressed the importance of a significant person in the lives of abused and neglected children. Although Farber and Egeland (1987) found few competent “survivors” among physically or emotionally neglected children, the children more likely to be competent were those whose mothers showed some interest in them and were able to respond to them emotionally. For sexually abused children, one positive mediating variable appears to be the presence of a supportive, positive relationship with a non-abusive parent or sibling (Conte & Schuerman, 1988). Research has also suggested that high (or above average) intelligence or cognitive ability may exert a protective effect in the context of an abusive or neglectful environment (Frodi & Smetana, 1984; Zimrin, 1986). Although Werner and Smith (1982) were not studying abused children, they found that high child intelligence and high verbal skills were associated with resilience in their longitudinal study of children in Kauai where children were followed from birth to young adulthood. Intelligence may play a direct role or it may operate as a protective influence, mediating other factors such as school performance or problem-solving skills which may, in turn, be related to later outcomes.
Studies of the predictors of resilience have focused on how characteristics of the individual, rather than contextual factors—an individual's family, neighborhood, school, or work setting—might contribute to resilience. However, there is evidence that the long-term impact of childhood trauma may depend on characteristics of the family or community in which the child lived at the time of the abuse or neglect experience (Terr, 1983). Drillen (1964) found that the long-term disadvantage for premature infants was especially marked if the child was raised in an unstable, disturbed family setting, whereas premature children raised in stable homes showed minimal or no disadvantage. For some abused and neglected children, Widom (1991) reported that out-of-home placement did not appear to be detrimental to their long-term development and early stable placements were associated with better outcomes. Similarly, children who were reared in stable households tended to be more resilient than those with foster care placements or frequent moves (Banyard et al., 2002, Siegel, 2000).
Other contextual factors may interfere with or promote resilience in abused and neglected children. First, individual and neighborhood level poverty are associated with the risk of child maltreatment (e.g., Coulton & Pandey, 1992; Finkelhor, 1980, Kotch et al., 1997; Newberger, Hampton, Marx, & White, 1986). Studies have also shown links between neighborhood disadvantage and adult outcomes (DeFrances, 1996, Goldsmith et al., 1998; Phillips, 1996, Ross, 2000, Sampson et al., 1997) and between neighborhood disadvantage, stressful life events, and children's adjustment (Dubow, Edwards, & Ippolito, 1997; Gephart, 1997). Growing up in poverty may increase a person's risk of experiencing stressful life events and psychological distress (Bronfenbrenner, 1986, McLoyd, 1990), as well as reduce resources available to cope with stressors (Wandersman & Nation, 1998). However, Duncan, Brooks-Gunn, Yeung, & Smith (1998) have suggested that parental income during early childhood has the most influence later in the life of the child, particularly on achievement and attainment, despite the fact that children who grow up in poverty often move in and out of poverty later in life (Duncan & Rodgers, 1988; Hill, Wei-Jun, & Duncan, 2001). Similarly, researchers have found that living in an economically advantaged neighborhood is associated with higher scores on cognitive indicators for preschool and early school-age children (Klebanov, Brooks-Gunn, Chase-Lansdale, & Gordon, 1997). Thus, it is possible that abused and neglected children living in communities or neighborhoods that are economically advantaged (presumably with higher levels of resources) will be more likely to emerge as resilient compared to those reared in disadvantaged neighborhoods.
Another aspect of resilience that few researchers have examined is whether resilience is stable across different developmental periods (Heller et al., 1999, Kinard, 1998). Some research has focused on shifts in resilience from early childhood to school entry (Cicchetti & Rogosch, 1997; Egeland et al., 1993) and from school entry to adolescence (Herrenkohl et al., 1994), but little is known about whether shifts in resilience occur after adolescence and during adulthood. Shifts in contributing factors or predictors of resilience have also not undergone scrutiny.
This paper has four goals: (1) to examine individual and family factors in maltreated children that may facilitate better functioning (resilience) during adolescence and young adulthood; (2) to evaluate the role of neighborhood resources on resilience and to examine the interaction between individual and neighborhood resources; (3) to determine the extent to which there is stability or change in resilience from adolescence to young adulthood; and (4) to explore characteristics associated with the stability or change in resilience from adolescence to young adulthood. Our study is a prospective examination of predictors of resilience during late adolescence as well as in young adulthood, using a large sample of men and women, documented cases of physical and sexual abuse and neglect, and examination of contextual (neighborhood) factors.
Section snippets
Subjects
The data are from a prospective cohort design (Leventhal, 1982; Schulsinger, Mednick, & Knop, 1981) study in which abused and/or neglected children were matched with non-abused and non-neglected children (the control group) of similar age, race/ethnicity, gender, and approximate family social class at the time and followed prospectively into young adulthood. Since we are only considering resilience in the context of overcoming known childhood adversities or traumas, we restrict these analyses
How prevalent is resilience among maltreated children?
Table 1 shows the extent of resilience in adolescence and young adulthood for abused and neglected children for each specific domain and overall. Overall, 48.0% of individuals with documented cases of child abuse and neglect showed resilience in adolescence, that is, success in at least four of the five domains. In contrast, 61% of individuals in the control group (those without a documented history of child abuse or neglect), showed resilience in adolescence (χ2 = 19.75, p = .000). Overall, 30.2%
Discussion
After facing an adverse childhood experience of documented maltreatment, nearly half of the abused and neglected sample was resilient in adolescence. However, by young adulthood this percentage dropped to roughly 30%. In an effort to understand how contributions from individuals and their social environment can aid or impede the promotion of resilience following abuse and/or neglect in childhood (Bonanno, 2004, Harvey, 1996), the current study examined predictors of resilience at two points in
References (85)
Developmental effects of child abuse: Recent findings
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1987)- et al.
A review of the long-term effects of child sexual abuse
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1992) - et al.
Using sleep dysfunction to explore the nature of resilience in adult survivors of childhood abuse or trauma
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1998) - et al.
Gender specific outcomes for sexually abused adolescents
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1996) - et al.
The Life Events Inventory: A measure of relative severity of psycho-social stressors
Journal of Psychosomatic Research
(1973) Risk factors in the sexual victimization of children
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1980)- et al.
Abused, neglected, and nonmaltreated preschoolers’ ability to discriminate emotions in others: The effects of IQ
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1984) - et al.
Stress, competence, and resilience: Common frontiers for therapist and psychopathologist
Behavior Therapy
(1986) - et al.
Neighborhood characteristics and mental illness
Evaluation and Program Planning
(1998) - et al.
Resilient child sexual abuse survivors: Cognitive coping and illusion
Child Abuse & Neglect
(1996)
Methodological issues in assessing resilience in maltreated children
Child Abuse & Neglect
Stress, social support, and substantiated maltreatment in the second and third years of life
Child Abuse & Neglect
Biomarkers in psychiatry: Methodological issues
American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
Research strategies and methodologic standards in studies of risk factors for child abuse
Child Abuse & Neglect
Psychiatric status of intrafamilial child sexual abuse victims
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
The compulsion to repeat the trauma: Re-enactment, revictimization, and masochism
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
A profile of survival
Child Abuse & Neglect
The Quick Test (QT): Provisional manual
Psychological Reports
Child sexual abuse and sexual revictimization
Clinical Psychology-Science and Practice
Childhood sexual abuse in the lives of Black women: Risk and resilience in a longitudinal study
Women & Therapy
Effects of sexual abuse on children
Violence Update
Sequalae of child maltreatment: Vulnerability and resilience
Loss, trauma, and human resilience: Have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events?
American Psychologist
Ecology of the family as a context for human development: Research perspectives
Developmental Psychology
Psychobiological mechanisms of resilience and vulnerability: Implication for successful adaptation to extreme stress
American Journal of Psychiatry
The role of self-organization in the promotion of resilience in maltreated children
Development and Psychopathology
Resilence in maltreated children: Process leading to adaptive children
Development and Psychopathology
The effects of sexual abuse on children: A multidimensional view
Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Geographic concentration of poverty and risk to children in urban neighborhoods
American Behavioral Scientist
Moving research on resilience into the 21st century: Theoretical and methodological considerations in examining the biological contributors to resilience
Development and Psychopathology
Direct and moderating effects of community context on the psychological well-being of African-American women
Journal of Personality & Social Psychology
The effects of racial ecological segregation on quality of life: A comparison of middle-class Blacks and middle-class Whites
Urban Affairs Review
Relationship between Quick test and WAIS IQs for brain-injured and schizophrenic subjects
Psychological Reports
The growth and development of the prematurely born infant
Life stressors, neighborhood disadvantage, and resources: A focus on inner-city adjustment
Journal of Clinical Child Psychology
Neighborhood context and psychological distress among poor African-American and Latina women and their 7–10-year-old children
Dissertation Abstracts International
How much does childhood poverty affect the life chances of children?
American Sociological Review
Longitudinal aspects of childhood poverty
Journal of Marriage and the Family
Resilience as process. Special issue: Milestones in the development of resilience
Development and Psychopathology
Life Events Scale: Unpublished test
Invulnerability among abused and neglected children
Cited by (303)
Weaving culture with consequence: Immigrant status and child maltreatment outcomes in early adulthood
2023, Child Abuse and Neglect
- ☆
This research was supported in part by grants from the National Institutes of Mental Health (MH49467 and MH58386), Justice (86-IJ-CX-0033 and 89-IJ-CX-0007), Child Health and Human Development (HD40774), and Drug Abuse (DA017842) to the second author. Points of view are those of the authors and do not reflect the position of the US Department of Justice.