Shorter communicationImagery-enhanced cognitive behavioural group therapy for social anxiety disorder: A pilot study
Introduction
Social anxiety disorder (SAD) is characterised by significant and persistent fear or anxiety in situations where an individual is exposed to possible scrutiny by others, such as interacting socially, being observed, or performing in front of others (American Psychiatric Association, APA, 2013). SAD is common, chronic, debilitating, and is one of the earliest onset anxiety disorders (Andrews et al., 2001, McEvoy et al., 2011). Cognitive behavioural therapy for SAD has demonstrated efficacy within randomised controlled trials (RCTs, Rapee, Gaston, & Abbott, 2009) and effectiveness within real world community clinics (Lincoln et al., 2003, McEvoy et al., 2012). However, a substantial proportion of patients completing gold-standard treatments remain symptomatic so treatment innovations are required.
Cognitive theories suggest that negative images are important maintaining factors of emotional disorders in general (Holmes & Mathews, 2010) and SAD in particular (Rapee & Heimberg, 1997). According to Clark and Wells' (1995) model of SAD, self-focused attention results in the construction of negative self-images viewed from the perspective of others. Rather than being an accurate impression, these negative images reflect the individual's feared outcome (Hackmann, Clark, & McManus, 2000) and are imbued with a threatening meaning, such as “I look like an idiot and will be rejected” (Chiupka, Moscovitch, & Bielak, 2012). Consistent with these theories, studies of SAD (e.g., Hackmann et al., 2000) and high social anxiety (Chiupka et al., 2012) have demonstrated that between 90% and 100% of individuals report experiencing negative social images. Experimental studies have also found that holding a negative image in mind is associated with greater anxiety, higher self-ratings of anxiety visibility, more negative self-cognitions and performance appraisals, increased safety behaviours, poorer performance ratings by conversational partners, increased self-focus, and more negative post-event processing (e.g., Hirsch, Meynen, & Clark, 2004). Contemporary CBT protocols incorporate video-feedback to correct distorted self-images and associated meanings (e.g., Rapee et al., 2009).
Hackmann et al. (2000) found that recurrent intrusive images in their SAD sample were often associated with early traumatic social experiences occurring around the time of disorder onset. Imagery rescripting (IR) targeting past traumatic events has been incorporated in comprehensive manuals or as a stand-alone treatment for a range of clinical problems, including post-traumatic stress disorder (Grunert, Smucker, Weis, & Rusch, 2003), depression (Brewin et al., 2009), and more recently in SAD (Wild, Hackmann, & Clark, 2008). One CBT trial for SAD found that a protocol including IR was superior to in vivo exposure with applied relaxation (Clark et al., 2006). Subsequent small clinical trials have found that IR in SAD is associated with significant improvements in negative social beliefs, the vividness and distress of negative images and early memories, fear of negative evaluation, and social anxiety symptoms (Frets et al., 2014, Lee and Kwon, 2013, Nilsson et al., 2012, Wild et al., 2007, Wild et al., 2008). These studies provide proof of concept and suggest that IR may be a powerful technique for treating SAD. However, to date IR has only been conducted individually, so it is unknown whether it could potentiate greater improvements within cognitive behavioural group therapy (CBGT).
Imagery is characterised as sensory-perceptual representations that may have visual, somatic, auditory, olfactory, and/or gustatory elements, and which have particularly strong links to both positive and negative emotions (Holmes & Mathews, 2010). For instance, one study found that compared to verbal processing instructions, cognitive bias modification training involving imagery was more powerful at changing emotion and interpretations (Holmes, Lang, & Shah, 2009). Compared to verbal thoughts, images are more potent in triggering emotional responses because they share similar neural mechanisms as the perceptual experiences one obtains from direct sensory experiences (Brewin, Gregory, Lipton, & Burgess, 2010). These findings have been replicated and extended to naturalistic settings (e.g., Holmes, Mathews, Dalgleish, & Mackintosh, 2006). A review by Holmes and Mathews (2010) concluded that “…images appear to act as ‘emotional amplifiers’ for both positive and negative information” (p. 353), and speculated that cognitive restructuring using imagery, rather than verbal representations, would have greater impacts on therapeutic outcomes. It may be that integrating imagery-based techniques into all treatment components (e.g., behavioural experiments, attention retraining) could enhance emotional change, and there is evidence that imagery facilitates access to negative core beliefs (Pratt, Cooper, & Hackmann, 2004).
The main aim of this study was to pilot a new, imagery-enhanced CBGT protocol (IE-CBGT) for SAD. In addition to including video-feedback and IR, the IE-CBGT protocol exploits the strong relationship between imagery and emotion by using imagery-based techniques in all components of the program. The first hypothesis was that IE-CBGT would be acceptable to patients and thus attrition would be low. The second hypothesis was that effect sizes on symptoms of social interaction and performance anxiety would be large. The third hypothesis was that the IE-CBGT would compare favourably to historical controls, who completed a gold standard CBGT protocol, in terms of attrition, effect sizes, and reliable and clinically significant change.
Section snippets
Participants
Participants comprised 19 consecutive referrals by health professionals (General Medical Practitioners, Psychiatrists, Psychologists) with a diagnosis of SAD to a specialist community mental health clinic. Mean age was 29.7 (SD = 11.6), 10 (53%) were women, and most were born in Australia or New Zealand (n = 14), with the remainder from Britain (n = 2), Asia (n = 2), and North America (n = 1). Inclusion criteria were (a) a Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV; APA, 1994
Attrition
Most (18/19, 95%) IE-CBGT participants completed eight or more sessions, with an average of 10.68 (SD = 2.29). Eight patients (42.1%) attended all 12 sessions, six (31.6%) attended 11 sessions, 3 (15.8%) attended 10 sessions, and 1 (5.3%) attended 9 sessions.
Symptom change
Repeated-measures ANOVAs demonstrated significant main effects of Time for the SIAS, F(5, 85) = 27.39, p < .001, Partial ɳ2 = .62, and SPS, F(5, 85) = 19.94, p < .001, Partial ɳ2 = .54. Paired-samples t-tests were not significant between T0
Discussion
CBGT for SAD is efficacious in research settings and effective within real world clinics, however a substantial proportion of patients remain in the clinical range. The aim of this study was to pilot an imagery-enhanced CBGT protocol. It was hypothesised that IE-CBGT would be acceptable to patients as shown by low attrition, that effect sizes for social interaction and performance anxiety would be large, and that outcomes would compare favourably to historical CBGT controls in terms of
Acknowledgement
The authors are grateful to David Erceg-Hurn for assistance with data imputation.
References (39)
- et al.
Treatment of childhood memories: theory and practice
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1999) - et al.
Imagery rescripting as a brief stand-alone treatment for depressed patients with intrusive memories
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2009) - et al.
Imagery rescripting as a stand-alone treatment for patients with social phobia: a case series
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
(2014) - et al.
Recurrent images and early memories in social phobia
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2000) - et al.
Mental imagery in emotion and emotional disorders
Clinical Psychology Review
(2010) - et al.
Positive interpretation training: effects of mental imagery versus verbal training on positive mood
Behavior Therapy
(2006) - et al.
The efficacy of imagery rescripting (IR) for social phobia: a randomized controlled trial
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
(2013) - et al.
Effectiveness of an empirically supported treatment for social phobia in the field
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2003) - et al.
Development and validation of measures of social phobia scrutiny fear and social interaction anxiety
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1998) - et al.
Exposure and cognitive restructuring for severe social phobia: a controlled study
Behavior Therapy
(1989)
Cognitive behavioural group therapy for social phobia: evidence of transportability to community clinics
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Imagery rescripting of early memories in social phobia: an experimental study
Behaviour Research and Therapy
A cognitive-behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia
Behaviour Research and Therapy
The validity of the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI) according to the SCID-P and its reliability
European Psychiatry
Iterative stepwise regression imputation using standard and robust methods
Journal of Computational Statistics and Data Analysis
Imagery rescripting of early traumatic memories in social phobia
Cognitive and Behavioral Practice
When the present visits the past: updating traumatic memories in social phobia
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
Rescripting early memories linked to negative images in social phobia: a pilot study
Behavior Therapy
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
Cited by (42)
Internet videoconferencing delivered cognitive behavioral therapy for social anxiety disoder: Protocol for a randomized controlled trial
2023, Contemporary Clinical TrialsWhat explains the failure to identify replicable moderators of symptom change in social anxiety disorder?
2023, Journal of Anxiety DisordersImagery-Enhanced Cognitive Restructuring of Hostile Beliefs: A Narrative Description
2022, Cognitive and Behavioral PracticeThe efficacy of incorporating mental imagery in cognitive restructuring techniques on reducing hostility: A randomized controlled trial
2021, Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental PsychiatryCan words be worse than stones? Understanding distressing social events and their relationship with social anxiety
2020, Journal of Anxiety DisordersCitation Excerpt :Imagery rescripting involves restructuring a traumatic memory through imaginal exposure and cognitive restructuring to help minimize overly biased interpretations, similar to common PTSD treatments (Wild & Clark, 2011). Evidence supports the use of imagery rescripting in treating SAD (e.g., Frets, Kevenaar, & van der Heiden, 2014; McEvoy & Saulsman, 2014; Wild & Clark, 2011). The current results suggest that inquiring about the experience of antagonistic and non-antagonistic distressing social events, as well as any related symptoms (e.g., symptoms of intrusion, avoidance, hyperarousal, negative alterations in cognitions and mood), may help with clinical case conceptualization and treatment customization through the inclusion of memory-focused exposures as appropriate.