Threat of pain influences social context effects on verbal pain report and facial expression
Introduction
Pain is a universal experience that affects human beings across the life span, and serves an important protective function. Pain urges to interrupt ongoing activity, to escape the source of threat to the body, and to withdraw for healing to take place (Eccleston & Crombez, 1999).
Over the past decade, there has been increasing interest in questions concerning the influence of social context on the experience of pain and associated pain behavior (Keefe and Porter, 2007, Tait, 2007). Traditionally, the role of social context was framed in social modeling (Craig, 1978) and operant conditioning processes (Fordyce, 1976). Indeed, important others have been shown to influence the experience of pain and how pain is expressed (Craig, 1975, Hadjistavropoulos and Craig, 2002, Turkat and Guise, 1983). These studies seem to suggest that punishing responses are associated with inhibited expression of verbal and non-verbal pain behavior, while empathic responses are associated with behaviors of greater magnitude (Flor et al., 2002, Jolliffe and Nicholas, 2004, Lousberg et al., 1992).
More recently, individual differences in the way how pain is catastrophically interpreted have also been examined in a social context of a refined communal coping model (CCM) (Lackner and Gurtman, 2004, Sullivan et al., 2001, Thorn et al., 2003). Pain catastrophizing has been conceptualized as a way of eliciting empathic responses from others (Sullivan et al., 2004, Sullivan et al., 2001, Thorn et al., 2004, Thorn et al., 2003). The CCM predicts that high pain catastrophizers will express pain in especially in the presence of others, because they feel vulnerable and feel the need to seek support from others through the expression of pain.
Evidence for the CCM is provided by Sullivan et al. (2004) who showed that during a cold pressor task, healthy subjects scoring high on pain catastrophizing displayed more pain expression in the presence of a neutral observer as compared those who performed the task alone. For the low pain catastrophizers, social context did not affect their pain expression during the pain task. Using a similar experimental pain task, Vervoort and colleagues found children high in pain catastrophizing displayed equal amounts of pain behavior in the presence of both of their parent and a stranger. Their low catastrophizing counterpart, however, were found to express significantly less pain in the presence of a stranger as compared to the presence of own their parent (Vervoort et al., 2008).
Of interest, however, is that studies finding support for CCM have not varied the threat value of the noxious stimulus. Indeed, a number of investigations have shown that threatening information about pain influences pain intensity and pain tolerance (Arntz and Claassens, 2004, Jackson et al., 2005, Vlaeyen et al., 1995). The central thesis of a cognitive appraisal model (CAM) is that idiosyncratic interpretation of a stimulus determines how strongly it is perceived, and which affect it elicits. The CAM assumes that individuals who catastrophize about pain habitually assign increased threat value to innocuous stimuli, thereby experiencing increased pain-related fear. There is accumulating evidence that catastrophic interpretations of pain produce increased pain-related fear and associated escape, avoidance and safety seeking behaviors, both in experimental and clinical settings (Lethem, Slade, Troup, & Bentley, 1983), for a review, see (Vlaeyen & Linton, 2000).
Although the role of the social context is not specified in the CAM it is arguable that certain social contexts might represent safety cues that signal to the individual that imminent threat will be reduced (e.g. (Lohr et al., 2007, Tang et al., 2007)). To our knowledge, no studies exist that have manipulated both the threat value of the pain as well as the social presence during a pain task in one single experiment. Manipulations of threat and social presence afford an interesting opportunity to examine competing predictions of CCM and CAM, and to elucidate the relative contribution of the threat value of pain and the presence of a neutral observer in subjects with varying levels of pain catastrophizing. Because both models are not specified in terms of the dependent variable, we decided to include a verbal and non-verbal measure of pain expression in the current study. This is also in line with the recommendation to use both kinds of measures in the assessment of pain because of their unique informational value (Hadjistavropoulos & Craig, 2002). A comparison of CCM and CAM models of pain catastrophizing is not only of theoretical importance, but also has potential clinical implications as tailored and specific treatment of patients who score high on pain catastrophizing are scarce (Thorn et al., 2002, Thorn et al., 2007). Additionally, current exposure-based treatments for patients with increased pain-related fear have not explicitly addressed the involvement of the social context (Leeuw et al., 2008, Vlaeyen et al., 2001).
Section snippets
Design
We have chosen a design that allows testing the predictions based on the CCM as well as those based on the CAM. High and low pain catastrophizing healthy subjects were exposed to a cold pressor task in a 2 × 2 factorial design in which both threat of pain (THREAT) and social context (SOCIAL) were experimentally manipulated. Participants were exposed to the pain stimulus for 60 s, followed by a 60 s recovery period. Perceived threat of the cold pressor task was assessed at baseline, after the
Participants
From a sample of 224 students and staff who responded favorably to advertisements that were posted at different campus sites of Maastricht University, 152 met the selection criteria and agreed to participate in the experiment. A screening procedure was used to exclude participants who had a medical condition that might be adversely affected by the cold pressor task procedure, and participants who were reporting current pain or a chronic pain condition. Five participants did not complete the
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Ger van Wunnik, Loek Peters and André van der Zanden for technical assistance during video recordings of facial expressions and to Annemarie Dautzenberg for her valuable assistance in the scoring of pain behavior. We also wish to thank two anonymous reviewers for their inspiring reflections and suggestions. Participation of Johan W.S. Vlaeyen was supported by the NWO Social Sciences Research Council of the Netherlands, Grant No. 453-04-003, and an Odysseus Grant by the Fund
References (55)
- et al.
The meaning of pain influences its experienced intensity
Pain
(2004) - et al.
Mind-body interactions in pain: the neurophysiology of anxious and catastrophic pain-related thoughts
Translational Research: The Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine
(2009) Social modelling determinants of pain processes
Pain
(1975)- et al.
Hypervigilance to pain: an experimental and clinical analysis
Pain
(2005) - et al.
Pain-related fear is more disabling than pain itself: evidence on the role of pain-related fear in chronic back pain disability
Pain
(1999) - et al.
Association of catastrophizing with interleukin-6 responses to acute pain
Pain
(2008) - et al.
The role of operant conditioning in chronic pain: an experimental investigation
Pain
(2002) - et al.
A theoretical framework for understanding self-report and observational measures of pain: a communications model
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2002) - et al.
Verbally reinforcing pain reports: an experimental test of the operant model of chronic pain
Pain
(2004) - et al.
Pain catastrophizing in the context of satisfaction with spousal responses: new perspectives and new opportunities
Pain
(2007)
Pain catastrophizing and interpersonal problems: a circumplex analysis of the communal coping model
Pain
Exposure in vivo versus operant graded activity in chronic low back pain patients: results of a randomized controlled trial
Pain
Outline of a fear-avoidance model of exaggerated pain perception–I
Behaviour Research and Therapy
A functional analysis of danger and safety signals in anxiety disorders
Clinical Psychology Review
The relationship between spouse solicitousness and pain behavior: searching for more experimental evidence
Pain
Agoraphobia–a safety-signal perspective
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Cortical responses to pain in healthy individuals depends on pain catastrophizing
Pain
Do we need a communal coping model of pain catastrophizing? An alternative explanation
Pain
Communicative dimensions of pain catastrophizing: social cueing effects on pain behaviour and coping
Pain
Increased use of safety-seeking behaviors in chronic back pain patients with high health anxiety
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Targeted treatment of catastrophizing for the management of chronic pain
Cognitive and Behavioral Practice
The communal coping model and interpersonal context: problems or process?
Pain
A randomized clinical trial of targeted cognitive behavioral treatment to reduce catastrophizing in chronic headache sufferers
Journal of Pain
Communal coping model of catastrophizing: conceptual model building
Pain
The effects of vicarious experience and stimulus intensity on pain termination and work avoidance
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Do beliefs, coping, and catastrophizing independently predict functioning in patients with chronic pain?
Pain
A confirmatory factor analysis of the pain catastrophizing scale: invariant factor structure across clinical and non-clinical populations
Pain
Cited by (58)
Familiarity From Facial Appearance Leads to Hypoalgesia
2023, Journal of PainDelivering transformative action in paediatric pain: a Lancet Child & Adolescent Health Commission
2021, The Lancet Child and Adolescent HealthEffects of (in)validation and plain versus technical language on the experience of experimentally induced pain: A computer controlled simulation paradigm
2020, Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental PsychiatryConceptual and methodological issues relating to pain assessment in mammals: The development and utilisation of pain facial expression scales
2019, Applied Animal Behaviour ScienceThe presence of others reduces dyspnea and cortical neural processing of respiratory sensations
2019, Biological PsychologyInvestigating the influence of social support on experimental pain and related physiological arousal: A systematic review and meta-analysis
2018, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsCitation Excerpt :There is evidence that stranger presence may signal ‘safety’ in the reduction of pain and related threat. But this effect was only observed in a high threatening context (Vlaeyen et al., 2009). Further evidence has suggested that the effects of stranger presence can be determined by attachment style.