Social anxiety in children: social skills deficit, or cognitive distortion?
Introduction
There has been a widely held assumption that people suffering from social anxiety are experiencing some kind of social skills deficit, and the treatment of choice for this client group has, therefore, been ‘social skills training’ (e.g. Bijstra and Jackson, 1999, Hayward, Varady, Albano, Thienemann, Henderson and Schatzberg, 2000, Spence, Donovan and Brechman-Toussaint, 2000). This approach has met with some success, which has often been interpreted as giving support to the social skills deficit theory. However, more recently, these assumptions have been questioned.
Recent cognitive models of social anxiety (derived mainly for adult clients) have proposed that sufferers do not generally lack adequate social skills. They do, however, believe that they lack social skills—a belief that may seriously undermine their confidence in social situations (e.g. Clark and Wells, 1995, Rapee and Heimberg, 1997). Cognitive interventions designed to modify these deleterious beliefs about social skills deficits have met with early success (e.g. Wells & Papageorgiou, 2001).
In addition, there is now direct evidence that the socially anxious do not necessarily lack social skills. Several studies have reported that individuals with social anxiety (or non-clinical participants with high levels of reported social anxiety) do not lack social skills compared to their low socially anxious counterparts (e.g. Rapee and Lim, 1992, Strahan and Conger, 1998).
A number of studies, however, have reported social skill deficits in the socially anxious, (e.g. Beidel, Turner and Dancu, 1985, Segrin and Flora, 2000, Spence, Donovan and Brechman-Toussaint, 1999), but it is possible that there is a simple explanation for some of the discrepant results reported by these studies. In particular, most of the studies that reported deficits had asked participants to self-report on their own social skills. In two studies where both objective and subjective reports of social skills were taken, it was only on the subjective reports that any deficits were apparent. (Segrin, 1999, Segrin and Kinney, 1995). This indicates that self-reporting of social skills may produce biased results—and supports the new conceptualisations of social anxiety as a deficit in confidence in social skills, rather than a deficit in social skills per se. In several studies where small observable differences were apparent in socially anxious adults, these were substantially magnified by self-reports of performance, when compared with observer ratings (e.g. Norton & Hope, 2001). Futhermore, most studies recognise that there is considerable overlap in the performance of the socially anxious and non-socially anxious groups, such that some socially anxious participants receive very good performance ratings from observers. These facts suggest that impaired social skills cannot be the major cause of social anxiety in all cases.
To date, little work has examined the role of social skills in the development of social anxiety in children. However, examination of social skills in the early stages of social anxiety is crucial to the understanding not only of child anxiety, but to the understanding of any deficits that may be apparent in adults with long-standing disorders. It is quite possible that any deficits in social skill that are apparent in adults may not be the cause of their anxiety, but arise as a consequence. Many adults with severe social anxiety avoid social encounters, and report having done so for many years. It is quite possible that the consequent lack of social activity could result in under-rehearsed social skills. If this theory is correct, we may hypothesise that socially anxious children, who have had less opportunity to engage in social avoidance, will not yet show rusty or diminished social skills. In order to test this hypothesis, Cartwright-Hatton, Hodges, and Porter (2003) invited school children aged between 8 and 11 years, to take part in a public speaking task. Participants were asked to rate their own performance in a number of domains. Videotapes of their performance were then rated by objective observers. In particular, the authors were interested in examining the effect of self-reported symptoms of social anxiety on micro-social skills (eye gaze, clarity/loudness of voice, smiling); global performance (how well they did generally, how clever and how friendly they appeared); and nervous behaviour (stuttering and generally looking nervous). The results of this study showed that trait social anxiety was associated with scoring highly on both the objective and subjective measures of nervous behaviours only. A measure of state social anxiety was associated with poorer self-reports on all aspects of performance, but was not significantly correlated with any of the objective performance ratings. The authors concluded that although there was little evidence of any actual social skill deficits, socially anxious children were concerned with their levels of social skills. In particular, they were very concerned with appearing nervous. These results echo those reported by Baker and Edelmann (2002), who found slight observable differences between their socially anxious and non-anxious adult participants, but only in behaviours that could be interpreted as signs of nervousness or as safety behaviours.
The present study aimed to replicate and extend the results of Cartwright-Hatton et al. (2003). Two groups of children were recruited. The first were an analogue socially anxious group, the second were a group of children who scored below average on a measure of childhood social anxiety. In the present study, children were asked to engage in a conversation with an adult confederate—rather than a public speaking task as used previously. It was felt that this would represent a more commonplace social situation for the children, and we were interested to see whether the results of the previous study would generalise to this potentially less anxiety provoking setting. Performance was rated by the children and by independent adult observers. It was hypothesised that there would be an interaction between social anxiety level (high/low) and rater (observer/self) on reported levels of social skills, with socially anxious children rating themselves as displaying poorer skills than their less anxious peers, and with the observers detecting no significant differences between the groups. In order to examine the relationship between social anxiety and separate domains of social skill behaviours, analyses were repeated for ratings of micro-social skills, global performance, and nervous behaviours.
Section snippets
Participants
Participants were 40 children (31 female) between the ages of 10 and 12 years (mean 11.0 years). The children were recruited from several state primary and secondary schools in the Greater Manchester area. Participants were recruited to either the ‘high social anxiety’ or ‘low social anxiety’ group, according to their scores on a measure of social anxiety (see below).
Spielberger state–trait anxiety inventory for children (STAIC)—state version (Spielberger, 1973)
This questionnaire is designed to measure state anxiety in children aged 9–12 years. The instrument consists of 20 items,
Results
All variables used in the foregoing analyses were approximately normally distributed. Therefore, parametric statistics were employed.
Modified versions of the PQ-O and PQ-C were used in this study. Therefore, an analysis of their internal consistency was performed. For the PQ-O, the Cronbach alpha was 0.79. For the PQ-C, the Cronbach alpha was an acceptable 0.69.
An intraclass correlation was conducted to examine inter-rater agreement on the PQ-O. The correlation between the two raters’ scores
Discussion
The self-rated total social skills of the high socially anxious children in this study were poorer than the self-rated total social skills of the less socially anxious children. Despite this, the independent observers were unable to distinguish between the two groups.
However, examination of the subfactors of performance revealed that this effect was only significant for nervous behaviours. The high socially anxious children reported that they looked significantly more nervous than their low
References (21)
- et al.
Physiological, cognitive and behavioral aspects of social anxiety
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1985) - et al.
Social anxiety and self-impression: cognitive preparation enhances the beneficial effects of video feedback following a stressful social task
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2000) - et al.
Cognitive-behavioral group therapy for social phobia in female adolescents: results of a pilot trial
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(2000) - et al.
Kernels of truth or distorted perceptions: self and observer ratings of social anxiety and performance
Behavior Therapy
(2001) - et al.
A cognitive-behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1997) - et al.
Social anxiety and its effects on performance and perception
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
(1998) - et al.
Brief cognitive therapy for social phobia: a case series
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2001) - et al.
Is social phobia related to lack of social skills? Duration of skill-related behaviours and ratings of behavioural adequacy
British Journal of Clinical Psychology
(2002) - et al.
Social skills training with early adolescents: effects on social skills, well-being, self-esteem and coping
European Journal of Psychology of Education
(1999) - et al.
Social anxiety in childhood: the relationship with self and observer rated social skills
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
(2003)
Cited by (140)
Youth social functioning interacts with treatment arm, diagnosis, and gender to predict anxiety treatment outcome
2022, Behaviour Research and TherapyCitation Excerpt :The scant research examining differences in social functioning between youth with SoAD and youth with other anxiety disorders finds that youth with SoAD have fewer positive social interactions compared with other anxious youth (e.g., Etkin et al., 2022). The literature is mixed regarding whether youth with SoAD have social skills deficits compared with other anxious youth (Schneider & Turk, 2014), although they do consistently rate themselves as having poor social skills even when peers or independent observers do not (e.g., Cartwright-Hatton et al., 2005). Positive social interactions and social skills may therefore predict better treatment outcome for anxious youth without SoAD compared to youth with SoAD, who may think themselves too unskilled to perform certain therapy tasks, have fewer opportunities to practice therapy skills due to limited social interactions, or are less attuned to positive feedback during social interactions.
Social anxiety in children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorders
2022, International Review of Research in Developmental DisabilitiesPerceived friendship network of socially anxious adolescent girls
2022, Social NetworksAssessing Visual Avoidance of Faces During Real-Life Social Stress in Children with Social Anxiety Disorder: A Mobile Eye-Tracking Study
2024, Child Psychiatry and Human DevelopmentThe longitudinal link between popularity, likeability, fear of negative evaluation and social avoidance across adolescence
2023, Journal of Research on AdolescenceSocial Skills Deficits and Self-appraisal Biases in Children with Social Anxiety Disorder
2023, Journal of Child and Family Studies