Eat your troubles away: Electrocortical and experiential correlates of food image processing are related to emotional eating style and emotional state
Introduction
In today's industrialized societies, energy dense food is available almost any time and anywhere. It also seems that hedonic factors have become an important, if not predominant factor in food intake: stress, negative moods, and emotions can determine eating even in the absence of homeostatic hunger and energy need. Whereas some individuals decrease their food intake when stressed, others increase it (e.g., Wardle, Chida, Gibson, Whitaker, & Steptoe, 2011), raising the question about the individual difference variables that put someone at risk for weight gain.
Since stress is a very broad and all-encompassing concept, the present study focuses on the modulating effect of negative emotions and moods on appetitive responses. The original concept of emotional eating derives from early obesity theories (Bruch, 1969, Bruch, 1973) but has since been applied to a wide range of normal and abnormal eating. Emotional eating can be seen as learned emotion regulation strategy through which negative moods increase the motivation to eat, and actual eating reduced these negative moods. In the terms of classical learning theory, the first process would be due to classical conditioning (increased craving in negative mood) and the second one would be due to operant conditioning (eating reinforced by reduction in negative moods, e.g., Booth, 1994). A concurring account explains emotional eating via the disinhibiting effect of emotions on chronic dietary restraint (Ruderman, 1985) since emotions deplete self-control resources that are then missing in the control of eating (Baumeister, Zell, & Tice, 2007).
Since its original postulation, the concept of emotional eating has received considerable empirical support from behavioral, ambulatory, and psychometric studies (Macht and Simons, 2011, Munsch et al., 2012, van Strien et al., 2012). For example, van Strien et al. (2012) used the emotionality subscale of the Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire, DEBQ (Van Strien, 1986) to classify participants into high emotional eaters (HEE) and low emotional eaters (LEE). Negative mood was induced by means of a sad movie (Study 1) and social stressor task (Study 2). As expected, HEE participants tended to increase food intake whereas LEE participants tended to decrease food intake under the negative mood conditions in both studies (similar results reported by Oliver, Wardle, & Gibson, 2000).
However, the effects obtained in that study were relatively subtle, even in participants with extreme scores on the DEBQ (top and bottom 20% in large screening samples). This might be due to the strong cognitive control many individuals exert over their eating behavior, particularly in a laboratory context. More covert (and less regulated) aspects of food cue processing might be uncovered by assessing central nervous system activity. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging, Bohon, Stice, and Spoor (2009) showed that emotional eaters responded with stronger responses in the anterior cingulate cortex to milkshake anticipation and receipt under negative mood whereas non-emotional eaters showed a decrease in reward related areas. Furthermore, in bulimia nervosa patients, negative mood was correlated with regions implicated in reward processing (Bohon & Stice, 2012). To our knowledge, event related potentials (ERPs) have not yet been used to examine the interplay of negative emotions and appetitive food processing. ERPs are particularly promising in this context since they are not only modulated by emotional stimuli but also show sensitivity for food density (Toepel, Knebel, Hudry, le Coutre, & Murray, 2009), food deprivation (Stockburger, Weike, Hamm, & Schupp, 2008; LPP; Stockburger, Schmalzle, Flaisch, Bublatzky, & Schupp, 2009b) and disordered eating (Blechert, Feige, Joos, Zeeck, & Tuschen-Caffier, 2011; Nikendei et al., 2012). Furthermore, ERPs are associated with distinct cognitive processing stages that can speak to underlying mechanisms of emotion-motivation interactions. Thus, the present study examined ERPs and subjective ratings in response to appetizing food pictures as indices of appetitive responding under neutral and negative mood.
An important aspect of this kind of research is the efficient elicitation of negative emotion. How should negative emotional states be triggered in a powerful and yet ecologically valid way and food cue responses assessed simultaneously? Film viewing and social stress tasks make ERP measurements difficult. Furthermore, the individual triggers of emotion-induced eating vary greatly between individuals and a specific eating-relevant emotion has not yet been identified (Macht & Simons, 2011). Another line of emotion research has therefore relied on an idiosyncratic emotion elicitation technique. In this approach, participants are asked to report recent highly emotional events from their lives from which emotional or neutral scripts are generated and presented during the experimental task (e.g. Hilbert, Vogele, Tuschen-Caffier, & Hartmann, 2011). Neuroscientific studies have started to use this approach and successfully adapted it to the needs of event related, cue-reactivity designs by presenting cues and emotion elicitation scripts in an interleaved manner (Goldin, Manber-Ball, Werner, Heimberg, & Gross, 2009).
Drawing on these lines of research, the present study examined HEE and LEE participants on experiential and neuronal responding to high-calorie food images under script-driven neutral and idiosyncratic negative moods. We predicted increased food wanting (desire to eat) and food liking (palatability) in HEE and the opposite pattern in LEE (van Strien et al., 2012). Regarding ERPs, assuming that the late positive potential, LPP, reflects attention to stimuli that are salient due to motivational context (Stockburger et al., 2008, Stockburger et al., 2009b, Blechert et al., 2010) or eating habits/pathology (Blechert et al., 2011, Nikendei et al., 2012) we expected more positive amplitudes on this component in HEE relative to LEE. The LPP is also sensitive to cognitive regulation during viewing of emotional images (Hajcak, MacNamara, & Olvet, 2010) and appetitive foods (Meule et al., 2013, Sarlo et al., 2013). Thus, if food was rendered more salient under negative emotion, potentially due to its relevance for emotion regulation, HEE (but not LEE) might evidence an emotional modulation of the food-cue elicited LPP. Because of the evolutionary survival relevance of efficient food stimulus processing, earlier ERP activity might also discriminate groups and/or emotion states and will be looked at in an exploratory analysis (cf., Toepel et al., 2009).
Section snippets
Participants
A total of 45 participants (83.7% right-handed) were recruited in introductory psychology classes at the University of Salzburg, Austria, and participated in exchange for course credit or € 15. Only female participants were invited since women generally report more cravings than men (Cepeda-Benito, Fernandez, & Moreno, 2003) and are at higher risk for eating disorders (Jacobi, Hayward, Zwaan, Kraemer, & Agras, 2004). Exclusion criteria were current dermatological diseases or diabetes and mental
Manipulation check: Emotion elicitation
The condition × group ANOVA of negative affect scores on the PANAS revealed a main effect of Condition, F(1,414) = 45.8, p < 001, η2 = .51, in the absence of an interaction or Group main effect, Fs < 1.41, ps > .230. Successful emotion induction was demonstrated by higher values in the negative (MHEE = 19.7, SD = 6.46; MLEE = 17.5, SD = 5.57) compared to the neutral condition (MHEE = 12.5, SD = 2.58; MLEE = 11.8, SD = 2.69). The
Discussion
To our knowledge, the present study is the first to investigate electrocortical correlates of emotional eating. We assessed how habitual emotional eating styles interact with negative relative to neutral emotional states during food cue processing. To do so we developed a method allowing continuous idiosyncratic emotion elicitation by event scripts interleaved with food cue presentation and measured ERPs and craving ratings in individuals with high and low emotional eating styles (HEE and LEE,
References (66)
- et al.
The effects of caloric deprivation and negative affect on binge eating in obese binge-eating disordered women
Behavior Therapy
(1998) - et al.
Spatiotemporal dynamics of the hedonic processing of chocolate images in individuals with and without trait chocolate craving
Appetite
(2012) - et al.
To eat or not to eat? Availability of food modulates the electrocortical response to food pictures in restrained eaters
Appetite
(2010) - et al.
Negative affect and neural response to palatable food intake in bulimia nervosa
Appetite
(2012) - et al.
Relation of dietary restraint scores to activation of reward-related brain regions in response to food intake, anticipated intake, and food pictures
Neuroimage
(2011) - et al.
Relationship of gender and eating disorder symptoms to reported cravings for food: Construct validation of state and trait craving questionnaires in Spanish
Appetite
(2003) - et al.
The development and validation of the State and Trait Food-Cravings Questionnaires
Behavior Therapy
(2000) - et al.
Scalp electrode impedance, infection risk, and EEG data quality
Clinical Neurophysiology
(2001) - et al.
Neural mechanisms of cognitive reappraisal of negative self-beliefs in social anxiety disorder
Biological Psychiatry
(2009) - et al.
Motivated and controlled attention to emotion: Time-course of the late positive potential
Clinical Neurophysiology
(2009)
“You Say it's Liking, I Say it's Wanting…”. On the difficulty of disentangling food reward in man
Appetite
Psychophysiological responses to idiosyncratic stress in bulimia nervosa and binge eating disorder
Physiology and Behavior
Cortical and limbic activation during viewing of high- versus low-calorie foods
Neuroimage
Electrophysiological indices of biased cognitive processing of substance-related cues: A meta-analysis
Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews
Food cravings discriminate differentially between successful and unsuccessful dieters and non-dieters. Validation of the Food Cravings Questionnaires in German
Appetite
Binge eating in binge eating disorder: A breakdown of emotion regulatory process?
Psychiatry Research
Emotional eating in anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa
Comprehensive Psychiatry
Cognitive reappraisal fails when attempting to reduce the appetitive value of food: An ERP study
Biological Psychology
Emotion and attention: Event-related brain potential studies
Progress in Brain Research
Vegetarianism and food perception. Selective visual attention to meat pictures
Appetite
The impact of hunger on food cue processing: An event-related brain potential study
Neuroimage
The brain tracks the energetic value in food images
Neuroimage
Cerebral processing of food-related stimuli: Effects of fasting and gender
Behavioural Brain Research
Moderation of distress-induced eating by emotional eating scores
Appetite
How emotions facilitate and impair self-regulation
The effect of laboratory stressors on glycemic control and gastrointestinal transit time
Psychosomatic Medicine
Electrocortical processing of food and emotional pictures in anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa
Psychosomatic Medicine
Female emotional eaters show abnormalities in consummatory and anticipatory food reward: A functional magnetic resonance imaging study
International Journal of Eating Disorders
Food for thought: Cognitive regulation of food intake
British Journal of Health Psychology
Psychology of nutrition
Hunger and instinct
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease
Eating disorders. Obesity and anorexia nervosa
Brain activation in restrained and unrestrained eaters: An fMRI study
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Cited by (61)
Response inhibition training and measures of explicit and implicit food valuation
2022, Current Opinion in Behavioral SciencesCitation Excerpt :There is not one agreed definition on food valuation, but leading theoretical frameworks share the notion that eating behaviour can often be driven by impulsive responses, such as a strong positive affective reaction and tendency to approach a food cue in the environment even in the absence of conscious awareness (e.g. ‘automatic’ processes in dual-process models [30,61], ‘liking’ in the incentive-sensitisation theory [12,54]). Although there is evidence for cue-evoked affective reactions in the brain’s reward system (e.g. [11,13]) and these concepts have been studied extensively in the laboratory (e.g. see reviews by [53,62]), the definition and consequently the measurement of food valuation remains a controversial theoretical and empirical problem. In this review, we focus on valuation from the perspective of explicit evaluative judgements on the taste and attractiveness of food items (explicit), affective reactions and implicit attitudes towards target food categories.
Sadness-associated eating styles and visual food cue reactivity: An eye-tracking investigation
2022, Eating BehaviorsCitation Excerpt :We specifically focused on sadness. Second, the current design extended previous research designs by including groups that increase vs. decrease the amount eaten when feeling sad (Blechert, Goltsche, et al., 2014; Hummel et al., 2018). This extreme-group approach should have facilitated the detection of EE effects on attention and memorization.
Changing the visualization of food to reduce food cue reactivity: An event-related potential study
2021, Biological PsychologyMood-induced changes in the cortical processing of food images in bulimia nervosa
2021, Addictive BehaviorsCitation Excerpt :The experiment was presented with E-Prime 2.0 (Psychology Software Tools, Sharpsburg, PA). The experimental procedure was based on Blechert, Goltsche, and et al. (2014) and is depicted in Fig. 1. First, an idiosyncratic mood induction was performed, following Hilbert et al. (2011).