Research articlePreventive counseling during prenatal care: Pregnancy risk assessment monitoring system (PRAMS)
Introduction
O ne of the main premises behind preventive health care is to identify behaviors that may put an individual at risk for a specific morbidity or mortality and to affect change in that individual’s risk-taking behavior. This is a two-step process that involves assessing a patient’s risk-taking or health-promoting behaviors and then providing counseling about risks and benefits in a supportive, clear, and unbiased manner.1
In an effort to advance the mission of preventive health practice, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force compiled the landmark Guide to Clinical Preventive Services.1 The collection of expert review and testimony led to recommendations for the types of preventive interventions that should be performed during clinical visits. These interventions are grouped into three categories, including screening, counseling, and chemoprophylaxis. In an effort to promote preventive health practice in clinical settings, the Task Force recommended that preventive health practices “must specifically address patients’ personal health practices” and healthcare providers “must take every opportunity to deliver preventive services.”1
Despite the literature and protocols that support the practice of preventive health care in medicine, there are important differences between recommended practices and actual provider performances in preventive health counseling.1, 2, 3 The prevalence of preventive health counseling has been examined from different perspectives, including that of the provider2, 3 and of the patient.4 The current literature that evaluates the prevalence of preventive health counseling involves a variety of practice settings and is often limited to a specific topic such as cardiovascular health5 or smoking cessation.6 In general, this literature demonstrates that the prevalence of preventive healthcare counseling is low, and even women at highest behavioral risk for particular health problems, such as women who smoke6 or women with cardiovascular risk factors,5 are not often given focused counseling about their specific risks.
The Task Force’s recommendations, in some cases, are pertinent to specific groups of patients. One of the patient-specific groups included is pregnant women. Preventive healthcare counseling during prenatal care is particularly important, as it promotes health for both the mother and the developing fetus.1 Many adverse outcomes of pregnancy can be linked to a limited number of high-risk behaviors, such as substance use7 and poor diet,8 which could be modified by behavioral changes. For example, behaviors both before and during pregnancy, such as cigarette smoking,9 illegal drug use,10 and alcohol use,11 may negatively influence pregnancy outcomes and newborn health status. Given this outcome, the Task Force recommends that pregnant women be counseled on a variety of prevention health topics, including tobacco cessation, alcohol and other drug use, benefits of breast-feeding, and use of seat belts during pregnancy.1 Some recommendations, including counseling about tobacco cessation, alcohol, and breast-feeding, are associated with strong evidence in support of the intervention improving specific outcomes (“A” recommendations). Other topics, such as use of seat belts during pregnancy and other drug use, have weaker evidence that counseling on these issues improves outcomes. However, as the Task Force noted, “this lack of evidence does not constitute evidence of ineffectiveness.”1 Hopefully, preventive health counseling during prenatal care can identify behaviors and experiences that increase the likelihood of adverse health outcomes and provide information and counseling that would lead to health promotion.
Prenatal care is an optimal time to provide preventive health counseling because of the large number of women who obtain such care. It is estimated that approximately 98% of the 4 million women who delivered a live birth in 1997 received some prenatal care.12 In addition, pregnant women may have a variety of behaviors or experiences that may increase the likelihood of adverse maternal and fetal outcomes, including smoking during pregnancy, experiences of partner violence during pregnancy, or lack of intention to breast-feed.13 These behaviors and experiences may be amenable to change with focused preventive health counseling.
Despite the high prevalence of behaviors and experiences that increase the likelihood of adverse health outcomes, we do not know the extent to which pregnant women are asked about preventive health topics. We also do not know the extent to which pregnant women who exhibit behaviors or who have had experiences that increase the likelihood for a specific health problem are counseled about that specific topic. To improve preventive health counseling practice during prenatal care, we need a better understanding of patients’ current preventive counseling experiences, and how this counseling may be related to patients’ behaviors and experiences. This study extends research in this area by examining Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS) data in 14 states to document three areas. The first area is the prevalence of preventive health counseling during prenatal care for 13 specific topics, including cigarette smoking, alcohol use, nutrition, breast-feeding, partner violence, preterm labor, seat belt use, family planning after delivery, use of medicines during pregnancy, illegal drug use, fetal development, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) risk and HIV testing. The second area is the prevalence of women’s behaviors and experiences that increase the likelihood for adverse health outcomes related to cigarette smoking, alcohol use, lack of breast-feeding, risk of domestic violence, and risk of preterm labor. The third area is whether the women with behaviors and experiences that increase the likelihood for these five health concerns were more or less likely than women in lower need of counseling to have received counseling for these issues during prenatal care.
Section snippets
Methods
Data concerning preventive health counseling during prenatal care and women’s risk status were obtained from the PRAMS.14 This system was established by the-then Centers for Disease Control in 1987 to provide state-specific, population-based surveillance of selected maternal behaviors both before and during pregnancy. PRAMS is currently in place in 22 states and in New York City. Each month in each participating state, a stratified systematic sample of 100–200 new mothers is selected from birth
Results
Sociodemographic characteristics for the 24,620 PRAMS participants varied widely among the 14 states (Table 3). Within individual states, women who reported their race as white ranged from 58% to 97%, as black from 1% to 40%, or as “other” from 1% to 30%. Maine had the highest percentage of white study participants, and Louisiana had the highest percentage of black study participants. Alaska had the highest percentage of women who were in the “other” race category because of the large
Discussion
This study advances current knowledge about the practice of preventive health counseling during prenatal care. This study finds that preventive counseling during prenatal care is relatively high for 9 of 13 preventive health concerns. However, preventive health counseling during prenatal care is relatively low for partner violence, seat belt use, illegal drug use, and HIV risk. Additionally, except for smoking and alcohol use, women in higher need for the other health concerns addressed in this
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the PRAMS Working Group for their dedication to PRAMS. Members of the PRAMS working group include: Albert Woolbright, Alabama; Kathy Perham-Hester, Alaska; Gina Redford, Arkansas; Darci Cherry, Colorado; Richard Hopkins, Florida; Tonya Johnson, Georgia; Loretta Fuddy, Hawaii; Bruce Steiner, Illinois; Suzanne Kim, Louisiana; Martha Henson, Maine; Diana Cheng, Maryland; Debbi Barnes-Josiah, Nebraska; Susan Nalder, New
References (15)
Policy tools for building health education and preventive counseling into managed care
Am J Prev Med
(1999)- U.S. Preventive Health Services Task Force. Guide to clinical preventive services, 2nd ed. Alexandria, VA:...
- et al.
The counseling practices of internists
Ann Intern Med
(1991) - et al.
Periodic health evaluation of adultsa survey of family physicians
J Fam Pract
(1995) - et al.
Prevalence and correlates of physician advice for preventionimpact of type of insurance and regular source of care
J Health Care Finance
(1999) - et al.
Including smoking status as a new vital signit works
J Fam Pract
(1995) Effect of cocaine use on the fetus
N Engl J Med
(1992)
Cited by (36)
Racial/Ethnic Differences in Prenatal and Postnatal Counseling About Maternal and Infant Health-Promoting Practices Among Teen Mothers
2021, Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent GynecologyPrevalence and maternal characteristics associated with receipt of prenatal care provider counseling about medications safe to take during pregnancy
2019, Preventive MedicineCitation Excerpt :Reported prenatal care counseling on medications safe to take during pregnancy was high overall and by demographic subgroup (>84%), in our sample of women with recent live births. These findings mirror results from prior studies using PRAMS data from 2004 to 2008 and from 1997 to 1998, suggesting no change over time in the prevalence (Petersen et al., 2001; Handler et al., 2012). Both previous studies reported prevalence around 90%, and the study from 2004 to 2008 found that the reported prevalence of discussion of medications safe to take during pregnancy was higher than other topics covered including alcohol and tobacco use, seatbelt use, and intimate partner violence (Petersen et al., 2001).
Psychosocial risk, prenatal counseling and maternal behavior: Findings from PRAMS, 2004-2008
2013, American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyCitation Excerpt :In contrast, only 67% reported prenatal counseling regarding alcohol cessation, 68% regarding tobacco cessation and 65% regarding illegal drug use cessation.8 Of concern, when compared to1997-1998 PRAMS data from 14 participating states, fewer women now report prenatal counseling regarding tobacco use (73% vs 81%) and alcohol use (73% vs 81%).12 Likewise, fewer mothers now report counseling regarding illegal drug use (66% vs 73%).
In person versus computer screening for intimate partner violence among pregnant patients
2012, Patient Education and CounselingInformation-Seeking and its Predictors in Low-Income Pregnant Women
2009, Journal of Midwifery and Women's HealthCitation Excerpt :These topics were chosen for two reasons. First, they had been recommended by numerous previous studies.12,23,24,35–37,41–43 Second, several topics were shown to link to positive maternal health behaviors or infant outcomes.10,11,43