Clinical understanding and clinical implications of response shift
Section snippets
Background
The phenomenon of response shift can occur in any field where self-report data are collected. Clinicians may not consider clinical medicine a discipline characterized by self-report data, but much of the physician–patient interaction consists of talk, Roter and Hall, 1992, Lipkin et al., 1995 and the medical history is a critical component of the diagnostic process. The physician–patient relationship, physician–patient communication and interpersonal care are all increasingly the subject of
The absence of response shift: somatization and hypochondriasis
In this section, it will be argued that somatization and hypochondriasis are conditions in which `normal' or adaptive response shifts to physical symptoms do not occur. Population-based studies White et al., 1961, Verbrugge and Ascione, 1987 and studies of those presenting for medical care Backett et al., 1954, Hilkevitch, 1965, Garfield et al., 1976, Gough, 1977, Pilowsky et al., 1987, Kroenke and Mangelsdorff, 1989, Kroenke et al., 1990 show that physical symptoms are extremely common. The
Response shift and the placebo effect
This section examines the relationship between response shift and the placebo effect. There is no space to consider placebo effects in depth in this paper and interested readers are referred to more detailed recent treatments White et al., 1985, Chaput de Saintonge and Herxheimer, 1994, Gotzsche, 1994, Kleijnen et al., 1994, Laporte and Figueras, 1994, Thomas, 1994, Turner et al., 1994, Strauss and Cavanaugh, 1996.
Implications of response shift for the physician–patient relationship
According to Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine (Isselbacher et al., 1994), the following is expected of the physician:
The practice of medicine combines both science and art. The role of science in medicine is clear. Technology based on science is the foundation for the solution to many clinical problems... Yet still in the most sophisticated application of laboratory technology or the use of the latest therapeutic modality alone does not make a good physician... [the] combination of
Recommendations for further research
This paper attempts to knit together arguments from several different intellectual traditions, and progress in further understanding this topic will depend on interdisciplinary collaboration. For example, it is interesting that recent interest in placebo effects and recent interest in describing, measuring and improving physician–patient relationships have occurred contemporaneously, but these two literatures have little overlap. This paper argues that response shift is a construct shared by
Summary
In summary, this paper tries to define response shift in terms with which clinicians are familiar and to describe it using clinical examples. A principal goal of the first part of the paper was to show that response shift is a part of routine clinical care. Somatization and hypochondriasis were then discussed in some detail and it was argued that these are clinical conditions characterized by the absence of response shift. Next, response shift was placed in a broader therapeutic and conceptual
Acknowledgements
This work was done while IBW was supported by a Picker Commonwealth Scholars Award.
References (74)
Amplification, somatization and the somatoform disorders
Psychosomatics
(1992)- et al.
A cognitive-educational treatment for hypochondriasis
General Hospital Psychiatry
(1988) - et al.
Auranofin therapy and quality of life in patients with rheumatoid arthritis
The American Journal of Medicine
(1986) - et al.
Harnessing placebo effects in health care
The Lancet
(1994) - et al.
Stress and coping in caregiving partners of men with AIDS
Psychiatric Clinics of North America
(1994) Is there logic in the placebo
The Lancet
(1994)Diagnosis and treatments of hypochondriacal syndromes
Psychosomatics
(1992)- et al.
Placebo effect in double-blind clinical trials: a review of interactions with medications
The Lancet
(1994) - et al.
Common symptoms in ambulatory care: incidence, evaluation, therapy, and outcome
The American Journal of Medicine
(1989) - et al.
Placebo effects in psychiatry
The Lancet
(1994)