Racial and ethnic differences in psychopathic personality
Introduction
This paper offers a contribution to a problem posed by Herrnstein and Murray (1994) in The Bell Curve. Herrnstein and Murray argue that racial and ethnic differences in a number of social phenomena such as crime, poverty, long-term unemployment, teenage pregnancy and the like are partly explicable in terms of differences in intelligence. They show, however, that differences in intelligence cannot explain entirely the racial and ethnic differences in these phenomena and they therefore conclude that some other factor or factors must also be involved. They conclude that “Some ethnic differences are not washed away by controlling for either intelligence or for any other variables that we examined. We leave those remaining differences unexplained and look forward to learning from our colleagues where the explanations lie” (p. 340).
In this paper it is proposed that a component in the solution to this problem lies in racial and ethnic differences in psychopathic personality considered as a continuously distributed personality trait. It is argued that of the major racial and ethnic groups, East Asians score lowest on psychopathic personality, whites score next lowest followed by Hispanics, while blacks and Native Americans score highest. Of these five populations, East Asians, whites, blacks and Native Americans can be considered as racial groups while Hispanics are an ethnic group from Latin America and the Caribbean with a common Spanish heritage. The first part of the paper sets out the evidence for this thesis. The second part applies the thesis to the solution of the problem raised by Herrnstein and Murray. The third part of the paper discusses the relation between the present thesis and Rushton’s r-K theory of race differences.
Section snippets
Psychopathic personality
We begin by describing the nature of psychopathic personality. The condition was identified in the early nineteenth century by the British physician John Pritchard (1837) who proposed the term “moral imbecility” for those deficient in moral sense but whose intellectual ability was unimpaired. The term psychopathic personality was first used in 1915 by the German psychiatrist Emile Kraepelin (1915) and has been employed as a diagnostic label throughout the twentieth century. In 1941 the
The Bell Curve
We noted in the introduction that Herrnstein and Murray raised the problem that while differences in intelligence can explain some portion of racial and ethnic differences in a number of important social phenomena including crime, unemployment, poverty, illegitimacy, welfare dependence, rates of marriage and low birth weight babies, differences in intelligence cannot explain the totality of these differences. They showed that when blacks, Hispanics and whites are matched for intelligence and
Relation of the present theory to Rushton’s r-K theory of race differences
We turn now to the relation between the present theory and Rushton’s (2000) r-K theory of racial differences. Rushton’s theory proposes that there is a Mongoloid–Caucasoid–Negroid gradient of r-K reproductive strategies such that Mongoloids are more K and devote resources to producing small numbers of children, investing heavily in them and providing them with a high level of parental care; Negroids are more r and devote resources to producing greater numbers of children, investing less heavily
References (180)
- et al.
Self-reported risk-taking behaviors and hospitalization for motor vehicle injury among active duty personnel
American Journal of Preventative Medecine
(2000) - et al.
Prevalence of psychiatric symptoms and their relation to adjustment among Chinese-American youth
Journal of the Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1995) - et al.
Depression and conduct disorder in native and non-native children
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1998) - et al.
Identifying adolescents at risk for hard drug use: racial/ethnic variations
Journal of Adolescent Health
(1999) - et al.
Black-white differences in cigarette smoking uptake: progression from adolescent experimentation to regular use
Preventative Medicine
(1998) - et al.
Seat belts pay off: the evaluation of a community-wide incentive program
Journal of Safety Research
(1986) - et al.
Race, ethnicity and child maltreatment: an empirical analysis
Child Abuse and Neglect
(1980) Development and risk factors of juvenile anti-social behavior and delinquency
Clinical Psychology Review
(1990)- et al.
Women’s degree of control over first sexual intercourse
Family Planning Perspectives
(1998) Manual for the child behavior checklist
(1992)
Three cheers and two quibbles for Professor Kennedy
Harvard Law Review
Highlights of official child neglect and abuse reporting
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
The MMPI-A: assessing adolescent psychopathology
Death and violence on the reservation: homicide, family violence and suicide in American Indian populations
Relinquishment of premarital births
Family Planning Perspectives
Youth in transition
The unheavenly city revisited
Behavioral inhibition, sustained attention, and executive functions: constructing a unifying theory of ADHD
Psychological Bulletin
Violent death in Alaska: who is most likely to die?
Alaska Review of Economic and Social Conditions
Childhood antecedents of adolescent personality disorder
American Journal of Psychiatry
The impact of school climate on suspension rates in the Jefferson county public schools
The Urban Review
A picture of male and female unemployment among Britain’s ethnic minorities
Scottish Journal of Political Economy
American Indian-Alaskan youth health
Journal of the American Medical Association
Predictors of risk for sexually transmitted diseases in ninth grade urban high school students
Journal of Adolescent Research
Race differences in marital well-being
Journal of Marriage and the Family
Trends and compositional changes in fertility: California circa 1970-1990
Population and Environment
Condom use in multi-ethnic neighborhoods of San Francisco
American Journal of Public Health
Race, class, network embeddedness and family violence: a search for potent support systems
Journal of Comparative Family Studies
Man between past and future
Black and white children in America
Extramarital sex and HIV risk behavior among US adults: results from the National AIDS Behavioral Survey
American Journal of Public Health
The mask of sanity
Correlates and consequences of early initiation into sexual intercourse
Journal of School Health
Race, belief in destiny and seat belt usage: a pilot study
American Journal of Public Health
Conners’ rating scales manual
A mental health profile of federally sentenced offenders
Forum on Corrections Research
School suspension: a survey of current policies and practices
NASSP Bulletin
MMPI patterns of American minorities
Age differences between sexual partners
Family Planning Perspectives
Teacher ratings of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder symptoms: factor structure and normative data
Psychological Assessment
Validity of the MMPI Pd scale among black males
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Self-reported delinquency estimates by sex, race, class and age
Racial differences on the Conners Teacher Rating Scale
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
The causes and cures of criminality
Social skill assessment of inner city Asian, African and European American students
School Psychology Review
Sexual partnership patterns as a behavioral risk factor for sexually transmitted diseases
Family Planning Perspectives
Cited by (52)
Why do middle-class couples of European descent adopt children from Africa and Asia? Some support for the differential K model
2018, Personality and Individual DifferencesCitation Excerpt :It is expensive to adopt a child and blacks are, on average, poorer than whites. In addition, black women are less likely to marry (Lynn, 2002) and until quite recently it was difficult for single women to adopt. However, this explanation is countered by the fact that black people exhibit more negative attitudes to adoption.
A review of the relationship between sociocultural factors and juvenile psychopathy
2014, Aggression and Violent BehaviorLynn's r/k selection theory of criminality revisited: Consideration of individual differences and developmental life history contributions to the patterning of population differences in antagonistic social strategies
2018, Journal of Criminal JusticeCitation Excerpt :We will proceed to argue that Life History Theory in particular provides a more objectively neutral language for the description of both group and individual-level evolutionary strategies. Prior to and subsequent to Lynn (2002), several scholars have articulated the need for integration between evolutionary models and criminology to better explain and predict criminal behavior (e.g., Boutwell et al., 2015; Ellis, 1988, 2005). Ellis (1988, 2005) has stated the biological and physiological explanations of behavior have steadily progressed across different areas within the social sciences; despite this steady growth of biological bases of behavior, criminal justice lags behind.
Race and (antisocial) personality
2018, Journal of Criminal JusticeCitation Excerpt :However, whites had greater ADHD symptoms and prevalence than Hispanics and Eats Asians. Lynn, 2002) also reviewed several forms of externalizing behaviors including school suspensions and exclusions, moral values, responsibility with honoring financial obligations, and diverse forms of crime spanning homicide, rape, robbery, burglary, auto theft, assault, domestic abuse/violence, indices of violent crime, recidivism, and imprisonment. Among these data, a clear gradient was found with blacks having the greatest involvement followed by Hispanics, whites, and Asians.
Racial Differences in Sexuality: A Sex Worker Survey
2023, Mankind Quarterly