Elsevier

Disease-a-Month

Volume 37, Issue 5, May 1991, Pages 269, 271-318
Disease-a-Month

Management of solitary pulmonary nodules

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0011-5029(05)80012-4Get rights and content

Abstract

The solitary pulmonary nodule (SPN), a single intrapulmonary spherical lesion that is fairly well circumscribed, is a common clinical problem. About half of SPNs seen in clinical practice are malignant, usually bronchogenic carcinomas. Some nodules are primary tumors of other kinds or metastatic. Virtually all benign SPNs are tuberculous or fungal granulomas.

The standard management of the SPN of unknown cause is prompt surgical removal unless benignity is established by prior chest roentgenograms showing that the nodule has been stable (i.e., showing no growth) for 2 years or by the presence of a “benign” pattern for benignity include (1) transthoracic needle aspiration biopsy (TNAB) showing a specific benign process, and (2) patient's age under 30 to 35 years. Bronchoscopy has a low diagnostic yield, particularly for benign nodules.

SPNs usually grow at constant rates, expressed as the “doubling time” (DT). A nodule with a DT between 20 and 400 days is usually malignant. Benign nodules usually have a DT greater than 400 days. The prospective determination of DT by serial chest roentgenograms (the “wait and watch” strategy) is widely criticized but has clinical utility in special circumstances, particularly if the likelihood of malignancy is low and/or the anticipated surgical mortality is high.

The presence and pattern of calcification are best shown by high-resolution thin-section computed tomography (CT). Diffuse, laminated, central or “popcord” patterns of calcification indicate benignity. An eccentric calcium deposit or a stippled pattern does not rule out malignancy. CT densitometry will often show “occult” calcification in nodules that show no direct visual evidence of calcium deposition.

The characteristics of the edge of the nodule correlate with the likelihood of malignancy. Nodules with irregular or spiculated margins are almost always malignant.

The probability that the nodule is malignant (pCA) is related to the age of the patient, the diameter of the nodule, the amount of tobacco smoke inhalation, the overall prevalence of malignancy in SPNs, the nature of the edge of the lesion, and the presence or absence of occult calcification. It is possible by Bayesian techniques to combine these factors to calculate a more precise and comprehensive prediction of pCA in any given nodule.

The 5-year survival after nodule resection depends on the size of the nodule at the time of surgery; it may be as high as 80% with nodules that are 1 cm in diameter. Lymph node involvement is uncommon with small tumors, and many authorities question the need for CT staging in such cases.

Decision analysis studies show that the optimal management of an uncalcified SPN of unknown stability depends on the pCA. At low levels of pCA, the “wait and watch” strategy is equal or slightly superior to either a biopsy procedure or immediate thoracotomy. If pCA is greater than 5%, biopsy or thoracotomy are somewhat superior to “wait and watch” in terms of average life expectancy. The differences in expected value between the strategies are relatively small. When the choice of strategies is a “close call,” the wishes of the patient take on increased significance.

Section snippets

Glen A. Lillington is Professor of Medicine at the University of California (Davis) School of Medicine, and formerly Chief of the Division of Pulmonary/Critical Care Medicine, and Acting Chairman of the Department of Medicine. He graduated from the University of Manitoba and took his residency in Internal Medicine at the Mayo Graduate School. His research interests are the diagnostic process and the use of decision analysis techniques in pulmonary medicine. His book, A Diagnostic Approach to

References (189)

  • TrunkG et al.

    The management and evaluation of the solitary pulmonary nodule

    Chest

    (1974)
  • HarpoleDH et al.

    Alveolar cell carcinoma of the lung: a retrospective analysis of 205 patients

    Ann Thorac Surg

    (1988)
  • GoodmanN

    The “air bronchiologram” and the solitary pulmonary nodule

    Dis Chest

    (1967)
  • EpsteinDM

    Bronchioloalveolar carcinoma

    Semin Roentgenol

    (1990)
  • JackmanRJ et al.

    Survival rates in peripheral bronchogenic carcinomas up to four centimeters in diameter presenting as solitary pulmonary nodules

    J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg

    (1969)
  • AdkinsPC et al.

    Thoracotomy on the patient with previous malignancy: metastases or new primary?

    J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg

    (1968)
  • EfflerDB et al.

    Surgical treatment of the solitary lung metastasis

    J Thorac Surg

    (1948)
  • PogrebniakHW et al.

    Resection of pulmonary metastases from malignant melanoma: results of a 16-year experience

    Ann Thorac Surg

    (1988)
  • HeimburgerIK et al.

    Peripheral bronchial adenomas

    J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg

    (1966)
  • CagleP et al.

    Pulmonary melanoma: primary vs metastatic

    Chest

    (1984)
  • ReverterJC et al.

    Erythema nodosum and pulmonary solitary nodule as the first manifestation of a non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

    Brit J Dis Chest

    (1987)
  • GribetzAR et al.

    Solitary pulmonary nodules due to nontuberculous mycobacterial infection

    Am J Med

    (1981)
  • GaleAM et al.

    Solitary pulmonary nodule due to phycomycosis (mucormycosis)

    Chest

    (1972)
  • RavinCE et al.

    Cytomegaloviral infection presenting as a solitary pulmonary nodule

    Chest

    (1977)
  • WebbWA et al.

    Solitary pulmonary nodule due to Brucella suis

    Dis Chest

    (1966)
  • RoseRM et al.

    Solitary nodular sarcoidosis

    Clin Radiol

    (1985)
  • JollesH et al.

    Nodular pulmonary opacities in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: a diagnostic dilemma

    Chest

    (1989)
  • BatesonEM

    An analysis of 155 solitary lung lesions illustrating the differential diagnosis of mixed tumours of the lung

    Clin Radiol

    (1965)
  • LillingtonGA

    Pulmonary nodules: solitary and multiple

    Clin Chest Med

    (1982)
  • FraserRG et al.

    The solitary pulmonary nodule

  • HoodRT et al.

    Solitary circumscribed lesions of the lung

    JAMA

    (1953)
  • ComstockGW et al.

    Outcome of solitary pulmonary nodules discovered in an x-ray screening program

    New Engl J Med

    (1956)
  • SiegelmanSS et al.

    Solitary pulmonary nodules: CT assessment

    Radiology

    (1986)
  • StollerJK et al.

    Solitary pulmonary nodule

    Cleve Clin J Med

    (1988)
  • GoodCA et al.

    The solitary circumscribed pulmonary nodule: study of seven years

    JAMA

    (1958)
  • AlexanderJ

    Circumscribed intrathoracic neoplasms

    JAMA

    (1942)
  • EfflerDB et al.

    Problem of solitary lung tumors

    Surgery

    (1948)
  • GrowJB et al.

    Exploratory thoracotomy in the management of intrathoracic disease

    J Thorac Surg

    (1948)
  • NordenstromB

    Current concepts: transthoracic needle biopsy

    N Engl J Med

    (1967)
  • NathanM

    Management of solitary pulmonary nodules: an organized approach based on growth rate and statistics

    JAMA

    (1974)
  • ThorntonTF et al.

    Solitary circumscribed tumors

    Surg Gynecol Obstet

    (1944)
  • ToomesH et al.

    The coin lesion of the lung: a review of 955 resected coin lesions

    Cancer

    (1983)
  • NandiPL et al.

    Pulmonary coin lesions: a ten-year review of 239 cases

    Aust NZ J Surg

    (1981)
  • KatzS et al.

    The solitary pulmonary nodule

    Diseasea-Month

    (1961)
  • SprattJS et al.

    The detection and growth of intrathoracic neoplasms

    Arch Surg

    (1963)
  • GoldmeierE

    Limits of visibility of bronchogenic carcinoma

    Am Rev Respir Dis

    (1965)
  • WoodringJH

    Pitfalls in the radiologic diagnosis of lung cancer

    Am J Roentgenol

    (1990)
  • TherosEG

    Varying manifestations of peripheral pulonary neoplasms: a radiologic-pathologic correlative study

    Am J Roentgenol

    (1977)
  • FraserRG et al.

    Perception in chest roentgenology

  • GarlandLH

    Studies on the accuracy of diagnostic procedures

    Am J Roentgenol

    (1959)
  • Cited by (114)

    • Epidermal growth factor receptor mutations: Effect on volume doubling time of non-small-cell lung cancer patients

      2014, Journal of Thoracic Oncology
      Citation Excerpt :

      To determine the natural history of pulmonary masses, most recent studies have investigated changes in VDT by measuring pulmonary nodules detected on chest CT scan rather than those detected on chest radiograph.3,7,8 Tumor VDT helps to distinguish between benign and malignant lesions21 and is thought to provide a useful index of lung cancer aggressiveness.2,8 In addition, tumor VDT differed significantly among histology types.

    • How I manage pulmonary nodular lesions and nodular infiltrates in patients with hematologic malignancies or undergoing hematopoietic cell transplantation

      2012, Blood
      Citation Excerpt :

      The other half are mostly the result of infectious granulomata from mycobacteria or fungi and much less commonly from other infrequent benign etiologies, such as hamartomas, sarcoidosis, or arteriovenous malformations. The differential diagnosis of pulmonary nodules in patients who are not immunocompromised has been reviewed in multiple publications.8-11 Radiographic features described in “How do I make the diagnosis” can be useful in distinguishing the likelihood of benign or malignant etiology.

    View all citing articles on Scopus

    Glen A. Lillington is Professor of Medicine at the University of California (Davis) School of Medicine, and formerly Chief of the Division of Pulmonary/Critical Care Medicine, and Acting Chairman of the Department of Medicine. He graduated from the University of Manitoba and took his residency in Internal Medicine at the Mayo Graduate School. His research interests are the diagnostic process and the use of decision analysis techniques in pulmonary medicine. His book, A Diagnostic Approach to Chest Diseases, is in its third edition.

    View full text