Searching for a common currency: Critical appraisal of the scientific basis underlying European harmonization of the measurement of health related quality of life (EuroQol©)

doi:10.1016/0168-8510(93)90059-X

Health Policy

Volume 23, Issue 3, March 1993, Pages 219-228

https://doi.org/10.1016/0168-8510(93)90059-X Get rights and content

Abstract

The EuroQol© has recently been proposed as a measure of health-related quality of life based on individuals' valuations of health states. The derived values would be used in assessing cost-effectiveness and establishing priorities across a wide range of health-care activities. In this paper we identify some of the limitations of the EuroQol© in its role as a particular method for deriving the more generic QALYs. More specifically we explore the implications of using the EuroQol© as a measure of individuals' and communities' valuation of health outcomes. We show that the EuroQol© suffers from several major limitations and thus cannot be relied upon to provide a valid measure to be used in economic appraisals or studies concerned with establishing priorities as proposed by its proponents. An alternative approach is identified and discussed.

References (24)

A. Wagstaff
QALYs and the equity-efficiency trade-off
Journal of Health Economics
(1991)
G. Loomes et al.
The use of QALYs in health care decision making
Social Science and Medicine
(1989)
A. Gafni
The quality of QALYs: Do QALYs measure what they at least intend to measure?
Health Policy
(1989)
R.G. Brooks et al.
EuroQol©: Health-related quality of life measurement: Results of the Swedish questionnaire exercise
Health Policy
(1991)
A. Mehrez et al.
Evaluating health related quality of life: An indifference curve interpretation for the time trade-off technique
Social Science and Medicine
(1990)
U. Ben Zion et al.
Evaluation of public investment in health care: Is the risk irrelevant?
Journal of Health Economics
(1983)
A. Gafni et al.
Equity considerations in utility-based measures of health outcomes in economic appraisal: an adjustment algorithm
Journal of Health Economics
(1991)
G.W. Torrance
Utility approach to measuring health related quality of life
Journal of Chronic Diseases
(1987)
E. Nord
EuroQol©: Health-related quality of life measurement valuation of health states by the general public in Norway
Health Policy
(1991)
S.M. Hunt et al.
Cross cultural adaption of health measures
Health Policy
(1991)

A new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life

Health Policy

(1990)

M.C. Weinstein et al.

Foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis for health and medical practices

New England Journal of Medicine

(1977)

Cited by (21)

Sarcopenic obesity is associated with lower indicators of psychological health and quality of life in Koreans
2015, Nutrition Research
Citation Excerpt :
Because the negative conditions of SO are mainly attributable to physical dysfunction [14], the mental health of SO should be comprehensively measured, including physical and emotional conditions. Taken together, the result suggested that the depression measure of QoL could be a useful tool to determine psychological effect in SO because it reflects individuals’ physical health status as well as emotional conditions [36,37]. The mechanism underlying the association of SO with psychological health and QoL is not yet established.
Sarcopenic obesity (SO) is known to contribute to morbidity and mortality from chronic diseases. However, there exists limited information regarding its effect on psychological health. The aim of this study was to evaluate association of SO with several indices of psychological health and quality of life (QoL) in Korean adults. This cross-sectional study was conducted with 11 521 participants older than 20 years from the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2008-2011. Sarcopenic obesity was defined by a low appendicular skeletal muscle mass divided by body weight less than 1 standard deviation below the sex-specific mean for the young reference group, and by a high waist circumference of at least 90 cm for men and at least 85 cm for women. Psychological health status, including depressive symptoms, perceived stress, and suicidal ideation, as well as QoL, was assessed by a self-reporting questionnaire. Association between SO and psychological health status was assessed under a logistic regression model. After multivariate adjustment for demographics and lifestyle factors, SO was significantly associated with perceived stress (odds ratio, 1.24; 95% confidence interval, 1.07-1.44; P value = .004) and suicidal ideation (odds ratio, 1.26; 95% confidence interval, 1.06-1.50; P value = .010). In addition, SO was found to have a negative association with a range of QoL indicators. Interestingly, these association patterns were more significant in participants younger than 60 years. In conclusion, our results suggest that SO was associated with adverse psychological health and lower QoL more than body mass index–based general obesity.
Qigong training and effects on stress, neck-shoulder pain and life quality in a computerised office environment
2011, Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice
Citation Excerpt :
A DVD version was available for participants who were on business trips, so allowing subjects to continue training when staying in a hotel room. A week before the six week study period started, all participants answered a baseline questionnaire about health state, health grading Euroqol,31 grading of pain intensity in neck/shoulder14 lumbar spine35 and grading of stress.32 The same questionnaire was sent to all participants every second week during the six weeks period.
Qigong is a Chinese health promoting exercise with a rhythmic pattern of slow movements and breathing affecting the autonomous nervous system.
To examine the implementation of Qigong for half an hour daily in a computerised office, and to study effects on health state, general health, neck-shoulder and lumbar spine symptoms and stress after six weeks training
A crossover intervention study with 37 employees randomised in two groups. A questionnaire was completed one week before starting study and every second week during the training period. After 6 weeks the first group stopped and the second group started the training.
There was a small significant improvement of neck pain and disability following therapy.
Qigong training may reduce neck disability in office workers. A longer training period might be needed in further Qigong studies in healthy, normal populations.
Medico-economic evaluation of continuous intrathecal baclofen for treatment of severe chronic spasticity
1998, Annales de Readaptation et de Medecine Physique
Une évaluation médico-économique du baclofène (Liorésal^®) intrathécal dans le traitement symptomatique de la spasticité chronique sévère secondaire à des lésions médullaires (sclérose en plaque, traumatisme) a été réalisée selon une approche rétrospective comparative monocentrique où le sujet est son propre témoin (n = 22). Les résultats de cette étude confirment l'efficacité importante du traitement sur la symptomatologie et l'état fonctionnel des patients et sur une échelle de qualité de vie non spécifique. Inversement, la mise en route d'un tel traitement se traduit par une augmentation de près de 67 % des coûts de prise en charge annuels moyens de ces patients pour atteindre environ 173 500 F/an. Un tel surcoût peut sembler parfaitement acceptable au regard des bénéfices cliniques obtenus.
A medicoeconomic evaluation of continuous intrathecal baclofen (Lioresal^®) infusion for symptomatic treatment of severe spinal spasticity was realised using a monocentric, comparative, retrospective approach where subjects were their own controls (n = 22). Study results confirm the efficacy of baclofen on symptoms, functional status of patients and on a non specific quality of life scale. Conversely, use of baclofen lead to a 67% increase of average annual costs of care for these patients and reaches around 173,500 French francs (~29,000 US$)/year. Such a cost seems to be acceptable with respect to clinical benefits. © 1998 Elsevier, Paris
Preferences for outcomes in economic evaluation: An economic approach to addressing economic problems
1995, Social Science and Medicine
In this paper we critically appraise the appropriateness and validity from an economic perspective of alternative preference-based approaches to measuring outcomes in economic evaluations of health care interventions. We describe the properties of an outcome measure for economic evaluation to make it compatible with the principles of economics when applied to the problem of resource allocation. We also describe the difference and similarities between the psychometric and the economic approaches for the measurement of outcome. Using these properties we critically appraise the use of QALY and HYE methods of measuring individual and social preferences for health outcome. We argue that the most advanced measure currently available that meets these required properties is the HYE. Because the HYE, unlike the QALY, has its foundations in utility theory under uncertainty, it neither assumes particular formulations of the individual utility function, nor is it incompatible with the principles of economics. As such it represents a further stage in the continuing development of methods for economic evaluation of health care programmes.
Search for a critical appraisal of EuroQol: a response by the EuroQol -group to Gafni and Birch
1994, Health policy
Economics, health and health economics: HYEs versus QALYs
1993, Journal of Health Economics
This paper responds to Culyer and Wagstaff's (CW) and Buckingham's (B) arguments. We refute their claim about the equivalence of HYEs and QALYs; they fail to distinguish between choice under uncertainty and under certainty CW assume that all individuals have a specific form of utility function, which yields their conclusion of equivalence. B's arguments confuse the measurement technique and the utility theory from which it stems; his argument about the normative superiority of the QALY construct is inconsistent with economic thinking. The HYE, by being compatible with the principles of economics, is superior to the QALY for economic evaluations of health care interventions.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Searching for a common currency: Critical appraisal of the scientific basis underlying European harmonization of the measurement of health related quality of life (EuroQol©)

Abstract

Journal of Health Economics

Social Science and Medicine

Health Policy

Health Policy

Social Science and Medicine

Journal of Health Economics

Journal of Health Economics

Journal of Chronic Diseases

Health Policy

Health Policy

A new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life

Health Policy

Foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis for health and medical practices

New England Journal of Medicine