Stimulus rise time, intensity and the elicitation of unconditioned cardiac and electrodermal responses

doi:10.1016/0167-8760(92)90041-9

International Journal of Psychophysiology

Volume 12, Issue 1, January 1992, Pages 41-51

https://doi.org/10.1016/0167-8760(92)90041-9 Get rights and content

Abstract

In recent discussions on the differentiation of orienting, startle and defense responses, the importance of stimulus rise time for the elicitation of different cardiac response patterns was re-emphasized. Especially, it has been claimed that phasic accelarative heart rate (HR) responses-interpreted as indicators of startle-might not only be evoked by auditory stimuli with instantaneous rise times and high intensities, but also by low to moderate stimulus intensities with sudden onsets. The present study examined this question by manipulating rise time (instantaneous vs. 50 ms) and intensity (60 vs. 95 dB). Subjects (N = 120) were randomly assigned to one of the four independent groups. They performed a habituation experiment in which 12 tones of 1000 Hz with a constant interstimulus interval of 90 s were presented. On trial 13, a change in rise time was introduced by reversing the rise time condition in each group (i.e., from instantaneous to 50 ms and vice versa). Examination of HR changes across 4 poststimulus seconds, of maximal HR deceleration and acceleration, as well as examination of magnitude of skin conductance responses (SCRs) indicated clear intensity effects. Rise time, on the other hand, had no effects on HR and SC that could be interpreted as indicative of startle. Thus, it could neither be observed that instantaneous rise time led to stronger accelerative HR responses nor that the combination of instantaneous rise time and high intensity elicited anything but a dominant accelerative response pattern. These findings were also obtained when the first four trials were analyzed separately. As a consequence of stimulus change, larger SCRs as well as larger decelerative HR responses were observed without, however, being affected by the direction of the change in rise time. In sum, the present study suggests that the role attributed to rise time with respect to eliciting qualitatively different cardiac response patterns has been exaggerated. The consequences for the differentiation of different unconditioned responses are briefly addressed.

References (26)

F.K. Graham
Habituation and dishabituation of responses innervated by the autonomic nervous system
G. Turpin et al.
Cardiac and forearm plethysmographic responses to high intensity auditory stimulation
Biol. Psychol.
(1978)
R.J. Barry
Novelty and significance effects in the fractionation of phasic OR measures: A synthesis with traditional OR theory
Psychophysiology
(1982)
R.J. Barry
Preliminary processes in orienting response elicitation
R.J. Barry et al.
Heart rate deceleration is not an orienting reflex; heart rate acceleration is not a defensive reflex
Pavlovian J. Biol. Sci.
(1985)
W.K. Berg et al.
Tone intensity and rise-decay time effects on cardiac responses during sleep
Psychophysiology
(1975)
T.D. Blumenthal
The startle response to acoustic stimuli near startle threshold: Effects of stimulus rise and fall time, duration, and intensity
Psychophysiology
(1988)
T.D. Blumenthal et al.
Stimulus rise time, intensity, and bandwidth effects on acoustic startle amplitude and probability
Psychophysiology
(1986)
P.J. Dallos et al.
Integration of energy at threshold with gradual rise-fall tone pips
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
(1964)
P. Ekman et al.
Is the startle reaction an emotion?
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
(1985)

D.C. Fowles et al.

Publication recommendations for electrodermal measurements

Psychophysiology

(1981)

F.K. Graham

Distinguishing among orienting, defense, and startle reflexes

H.M. Hatton et al.

Effects of acoustic rise time on heart rate response

Psychonom. Sci.

(1970)

Cited by (19)

Perturbation-evoked electrodermal responses are sensitive to stimulus and context-dependent manipulations of task challenge
2010, Neuroscience Letters
Recent work has demonstrated that postural instability evokes an electrodermal response (EDR) that is temporally coupled to perturbation onset. The purpose of this study was to determine whether arousal linked to balance recovery is associated with the size of the perturbation (stimulus-dependent variations); and/or the challenge of executing a motor response to recover stability (context-dependent task variations). Twelve healthy subjects received whole-body perturbations while seated in a tilting chair that required a compensatory upper limb reaction to regain balance following instability. The influence of perturbation amplitude (stimulus-dependent challenge- slow vs. fast perturbations) and task condition (context-dependent challenge- unrestricted vs. restricted movement) on EDR timing and magnitude parameters were examined. While EDR latency was consistent across conditions with onset occuring approximately 2 s after the perturbation, peak-to-peak EDR amplitude was influenced by both stimulus-dependent and context-dependent challenges and also mirrored postural response amplitude. Compared to the Slow condition, EDR amplitude was 27 ± 6% larger in the Fast condition (p = 0.0004). Similarly, EDR amplitude was 244 ± 86% larger in the Restricted task condition relative to the Unrestricted task condition (p = 0.006). Context-dependent EDR modulation suggests that autonomic reactivity is associated with some higher level of processing independent of the degree of challenge related to stimulus characteristics. This work has potential implications for understanding determinants of central nervous system reactivity among individuals with impaired limb control where the recovery challenge is uniquely linked to the context.
Habituation and sensitization of protective reflexes: Dissociation between cardiac defense and eye-blink startle
2009, Biological Psychology
We examined the habituation and recovery of two protective reflexes, cardiac defense and eye-blink startle, simultaneously elicited by a white noise of 500 ms as a function of the time interval between stimulus presentations. Participants were 90 volunteers (54 women) randomly distributed into 6 inter-trial interval (ITI) conditions. They all received three presentations of the stimulus with a time interval of 30 min between the first and third noise. The timing of the second noise was manipulated in six steps, using a between-group design, in order to increase the ITI between Trials 1 and 2 and symmetrically decrease the ITI between Trials 2 and 3. Cardiac defense showed fast habituation at the shortest ITI (2.5 min), but reduced habituation and increased recovery at the longest ITI (27.5 min). In contrast, eye-blink startle showed sensitization irrespective of the ITI. This pattern of findings highlights dissociations between protective reflexes when simultaneously examined. The results are discussed in the context of the cascade model of defense reactions.
Cardiac defense: From attention to action
2007, International Journal of Psychophysiology
The concept of defense relates to the idea that organisms react physiologically to the presence of danger or threat in order to protect themselves from potential injury or death. This article reviews the literature on cardiac defense, a specific defense reaction that has a long tradition in psychophysiological research. The review begins with a brief analysis of the two traditional approaches to understand this autonomic response: the cognitive – linked to Pavlov, Sokolov, and Graham's work on sensory reflexes – and the motivational — linked to Cannon and Selye's work on the concepts of activation and stress. Then, the classic model of cardiac defense and its basic assumptions concerning differentiation from other cardiac reflexes – namely orienting and startle – are presented. A critical analysis of these assumptions follows centered on evidence from a systematic research of the cardiac response to intense acoustic stimulation. Finally, an integrative model of cardiac defense is presented which emphasizes the dynamic nature of this defense reaction – characterized by a complex pattern of heart rate changes with accelerative and decelerative components, with sympathethic and parasympathetic influences, and with both attentional and motivational significance – providing a new framework in which the two opposite traditional approaches can be reconciled.
Sensory evaluation of alcohol-related and neutral stimuli: Psychophysical assessment of stimulus intensity
2003, Addictive Behaviors
Research on reactivity to alcohol cues yielded conflicting results. While some authors report differences in subjective or physiological responses to drug-related stimuli between addicts and healthy controls, other researchers found no group differences in response patterns. Moreover, a dissociation of self-report and psychophysiological measures of cue reactivity is often observed. To some extent, this might be due to confounding stimulus type (neutral vs. drug-related) and stimulus intensity in cue reactivity research. The purpose of the present study is to match alcoholic and nonalcoholic stimuli according to their empirically assessed intensity. Stimulus intensity is estimated by magnitude estimation. Results clearly indicate that alcohol-related cues differ considerably from water and other neutral stimuli with respect to perceived intensity. Moreover, estimation of stimulus intensity depends on mode of presentation (smell vs. combined smell and taste). Results of previous cue reactivity studies in the alcohol field might have been affected in different degrees by confounding stimulus type and intensity.
Habituation and recovery of a slow negative wave of the event-related brain potential
2002, International Journal of Psychophysiology
This study is concerned with the question of whether the late, slow negative wave 2 (SNW2) component of the event-related brain potential is a component of the orienting response (OR). As habituation of the SNW2 would be an argument for such a link with the OR, it was investigated using a variant of the classical repetition/change paradigm. Results supported major claims to be made for a component of the OR: the amplitude of the vertex SNW2 exhibited roughly the typical exponential decline with repeated stimulations (six numeric verbal stimuli presented seriatim in an ascending order) and responded incrementally to a change, at least in a narrow time slot, i.e. it exhibited partial recovery to an out-of-sequence stimulus. These findings were accompanied by similar effects on an exemplary OR component, the skin conductance response, and on such possible components of the OR as heart rate deceleration and the vertex P3 of the event-related brain potential. In so far as OR components should behave in comparable fashion in response to orienting stimuli, it is thus reasonable to suppose that the SNW2 relates to the OR.
Associative learning in humans - Conditioning of sensory-evoked brain activity
2000, Behavioural Brain Research
A classical conditioning paradigm was employed in two experiments performed on 35 human volunteers. In nine subjects, the presentation of Landolt rings (conditioned stimuli, CS+) was paired with an electric stimulus (unconditioned stimuli, UCS) applied to the left median nerve. Neutral visual control stimuli were full circles (CS−) that were not paired with the UCS. The skin conductance response (SCR) was determined in a time interval of 5 s after onset of the visual stimuli, and it was measured in the acquisition and test phase. Associative learning was reflected by a SCR occurring selectively with CS+. The same experiment was repeated with another group of 26 adults while electroencephalogram (EEG) was recorded from 30 electrodes. For each subject, mean evoked potentials were computed. In 13 of the subjects, a conditioning paradigm was followed while the other subjects served as the control group (non-contingent stimulation). There were somatosensory and visual brain activity evoked by the stimuli. Conditioned components were identified by computing cross-correlation between evoked somatosensory components and the averaged EEG. In the visual evoked brain activity, three components with mean latencies of 105.4, 183.2, and 360.3 ms were analyzed. Somatosensory stimuli were followed by major components that occurred at mean latencies of 48.8, 132.5, 219.7, 294.8, and 374.2 ms latency after the shock. All components were analyzed in terms of latency, field strength, and topographic characteristics, and were compared between groups and experimental conditions. Both visual and somatosensory brain activity was significantly affected by classical conditioning. Our data illustrate how associative learning affects the topography of brain electrical activity elicited by presentation of conditioned visual stimuli.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Stimulus rise time, intensity and the elicitation of unconditioned cardiac and electrodermal responses

Abstract

Biol. Psychol.

Novelty and significance effects in the fractionation of phasic OR measures: A synthesis with traditional OR theory

Psychophysiology

Preliminary processes in orienting response elicitation

Heart rate deceleration is not an orienting reflex; heart rate acceleration is not a defensive reflex

Pavlovian J. Biol. Sci.

Tone intensity and rise-decay time effects on cardiac responses during sleep

Psychophysiology

The startle response to acoustic stimuli near startle threshold: Effects of stimulus rise and fall time, duration, and intensity

Psychophysiology

Stimulus rise time, intensity, and bandwidth effects on acoustic startle amplitude and probability

Psychophysiology

Integration of energy at threshold with gradual rise-fall tone pips

J. Acoust. Soc. Am.

Is the startle reaction an emotion?

Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

Publication recommendations for electrodermal measurements

Psychophysiology

Distinguishing among orienting, defense, and startle reflexes

Effects of acoustic rise time on heart rate response

Psychonom. Sci.