Abstract
Background
The effect of footwear on running economy has been investigated in numerous studies. However, no systematic review and meta-analysis has synthesised the available literature and the effect of footwear on running performance is not known.
Objective
The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to investigate the effect of footwear on running performance and running economy in distance runners, by reviewing controlled trials that compare different footwear conditions or compare footwear with barefoot.
Methods
The Web of Science, Scopus, MEDLINE, CENTRAL (Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials), EMBASE, AMED (Allied and Complementary Medicine), CINAHL and SPORTDiscus databases were searched from inception up until April 2014. Included articles reported on controlled trials that examined the effects of footwear or footwear characteristics (including shoe mass, cushioning, motion control, longitudinal bending stiffness, midsole viscoelasticity, drop height and comfort) on running performance or running economy and were published in a peer-reviewed journal.
Results
Of the 1,044 records retrieved, 19 studies were included in the systematic review and 14 studies were included in the meta-analysis. No studies were identified that reported effects on running performance. Individual studies reported significant, but trivial, beneficial effects on running economy for comfortable and stiff-soled shoes [standardised mean difference (SMD) <0.12; P < 0.05), a significant small beneficial effect on running economy for cushioned shoes (SMD = 0.37; P < 0.05) and a significant moderate beneficial effect on running economy for training in minimalist shoes (SMD = 0.79; P < 0.05). Meta-analysis found significant small beneficial effects on running economy for light shoes and barefoot compared with heavy shoes (SMD < 0.34; P < 0.01) and for minimalist shoes compared with conventional shoes (SMD = 0.29; P < 0.01). A significant positive association between shoe mass and metabolic cost of running was identified (P < 0.01). Footwear with a combined shoe mass less than 440 g per pair had no detrimental effect on running economy.
Conclusions
Certain models of footwear and footwear characteristics can improve running economy. Future research in footwear performance should include measures of running performance.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Hennig EM. Eighteen years of running shoe testing in Germany—a series of biomechanical studies. Footwear Sci. 2011;3(2):71–81.
Moore IS, Jones A, Dixon S. The pursuit of improved running performance: can changes in cushioning and somatosensory feedback influence running economy and injury risk? Footwear Sci. 2014;6(1):1–11.
Rothschild CE. Primitive running: a survey analysis of runners’ interest, participation, and implementation. J Strength Cond Res. 2012;26(8):2021–6.
Richards CE, Magin PJ, Callister R. Is your prescription of distance running shoes evidence-based? Br J Sports Med. 2009;43(3):159–62.
Perl DP, Daoud AI, Lieberman DE. Effects of footwear and strike type on running economy. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012;44(7):1335–43.
Warne JP, Warrington GD. Four-week habituation to simulated barefoot running improves running economy when compared with shod running. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2012;24(3):563–8. doi:10.1111/sms.12032.
Hanson NJ, Berg K, Deka P, et al. Oxygen cost of running barefoot vs. running shod. Int J Sports Med. 2011;32(6):401–6.
Saunders PU, Pyne DB, Telford RD, et al. Factors affecting running economy in trained distance runners. Sports Med. 2004;34(7):465–85.
Divert C, Mornieux G, Freychat P, et al. Barefoot-shod running differences: shoe or mass effect? Int J Sports Med. 2008;29(6):512–8.
Luo G, Stergiou P, Worobets J, et al. Improved footwear comfort reduces oxygen consumption during running. Footwear Sci. 2009;1(1):25–9.
Nigg BM, Stefanyshyn DJ, Cole G, et al. The effect of material characteristics of shoe soles on muscle activation and energy aspects during running. J Biomech. 2003;36:569–75.
Roy JPR, Stefanyshyn DJ. Shoe midsole longitudinal bending stiffness and running economy, joint energy, and EMG. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006;38(3):562–9.
Thomson RD, Birkbeck AE, Tan WL, et al. The modelling and performance of training shoe cushioning systems. Sports Eng. 1999;2(2):109–20.
Rubin DA, Butler RJ, Beckman B, et al. Footwear and running cardio-respiratory responses. Int J Sports Med. 2009;30:379–82.
Frederick EC, Howley ET, Powers SK. Lower oxygen demands of running in soft-soled shoes. Res Q Exerc Sport. 1986;57(2):174–7.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151(4):264–9.
Higgins JPT, Altman DG, Gøtzsche PC, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2011;343:d5928. doi:10.1136/bmj.d5928.
Hopkins WG, Marshall SW, Batterham AM, et al. Progressive statistics for studies in sports medicine and exercise science. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2009;41(1):3–12.
Elbourne DR, Altman DG, Higgins JPT, et al. Meta-analysis involving cross-over trials: methodological issues. Int J Epidemiol. 2002;31(1):140–9.
Higgins JPT, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, et al. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ. 2003;327:557–60.
Burkett LN, Kohrt WM, Buchbinder R. Effects of shoes and foot orthotics on VO2 and selected frontal plane knee kinematics. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1985;17(1):158–63.
Franz JR, Wierzbinski CM, Kram R. Metabolic cost of running barefoot versus shod: is lighter better? Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012;44(8):1519–25.
Hamill J, Freedson PS, Boda W, et al. Effects of shoe type on cardiorespiratory responses and rearfoot motion during treadmill running. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1988;20(5):515–21.
Hardin EC, Van Den Bogert AJ, Hamill J. Kinematic adaptations during running: effects of footwear, surface, and duration. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2004;36(5):838–44.
Lussiana T, Fabre N, Hebert-Losier K, et al. Effect of slope and footwear on running economy and kinematics. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2013;23:246–53.
Sinclair J, Taylor PJ, Edmundson CJ, et al. The influence of footwear kinetic, kinematic and electromyographical parameters on the energy requirements of steady state running. Mov Sport Sci. 2013;80:39–49.
Squadrone R, Gallozzi C. Biomechanical and physiological comparison of barefoot and two shod conditions in experienced barefoot runners. J Sports Med Phys Fit. 2009;49(6):6–13.
Tung KD, Franz JR, Kram R. A test of the metabolic cost of cushioning hypothesis during unshod and shod running. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2014;46(2):324–9.
Bosco C, Rusko H. The effect of prolonged skeletal muscle stretch-shortening cycle on recoil of elastic energy and on expenditure. Acta Physiol Scand. 1983;119:314–8.
Buchheit M, Laursen PB, Leblond F, et al. Effect of dorsiflexion shoes on the energy cost of running. Sci Sports. 2010;25:81–7.
Faiss R, Terrier P, Praz M, et al. Influence of initial foot dorsal flexion on vertical jump and running performance. J Strength Cond Res. 2010;24(9):2352–7.
Jones BH, Knapik JJ, Daniels WL, et al. The energy cost of women walking and running in shoes and boots. Ergonomics. 1986;29(3):439–43.
Mercer JA, Branks DA, Wasserman SK, et al. Physiological cost of running while wearing spring-boots. J Strength Cond Res. 2003;17(2):314–8.
Berg K, Sady S. Oxygen cost of running at submaximal speeds while wearing shoe inserts. Res Q Exerc Sport. 1985;56(1):86–9.
Jones BH, Toner MM, Daniels WL, et al. The energy cost and heart-rate response of trained and untrained subjects walking and running in shoes and boots. Ergonomics. 1984;27(8):895–902.
Morgan DW, Miller TA, Mitchell VA, et al. Aerobic demand of running shoes designed to exploit energy storage and return. Res Q Exerc Sport. 1996;67(1):102–5.
Brizuela G, Llana S, Ferrandis R, et al. The influence of basketball shoes with increased ankle support on shock attenuation and performance in running and jumping. J Sports Sci. 1997;15(5):505–15.
Ratamess NA, Kraemer WJ, Volek JS, et al. The effects of ten weeks of resistance and combined plyometric/sprint training with the Meridian Elyte athletic shoe on muscular performance in women. J Strength Cond Res. 2007;21(3):882–7.
Stefanyshyn D, Fusco C. Increased shoe bending stiffness increases sprint performance. Sports Biomech. 2004;3(1):55–66.
Killgore GL, Coste SC, O’Meara SE, et al. A comparison of the physiological exercise intensity differences between shod and barefoot submaximal deep-water running at the same cadence. J Strength Cond Res. 2010;24(12):3302–12.
Rife RK, Myrer JW, Vehrs P, et al. Water treadmill parameters needed to obtain land treadmill intensities in runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2010;42(4):733–8.
Williams KR, Cavanagh PR, Ziff JL. Biomechanical studies of elite female distance runners. Int J Sports Med. 1987;8:107–18.
Hanson NJ, Berg K. Response to the letter to the editor: is barefoot running more economical? [letter]. Int J Sports Med. 2012;33:250.
Kram R, Franz JR. Is barefoot running more economical? [letter]. Int J Sports Med. 2012;33:249.
Conley DL, Krahenbuhl GS. Running economy and distance running performance of highly trained athletes. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1980;12:357–60.
Svedenhag J, Sjodin B. Physiological characteristics of elite male runners in and off-season. Can J Appl Sport Sci. 1985;10(3):127–33.
Foster C, Daniels JT, Yarbrough RA. Physiological and training correlates of marathon running performance. Aust J Sports Med. 1977;9:58–62.
Williams KR, Cavanagh PR. Relationship between distance running mechanics, running economy and running performance. J Appl Physiol. 1987;63(3):1236–45.
Hopkins WG, Hawley JA, Burke LM. Design and analysis of research on sport performance enhancement. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;31(3):472–85.
Paquette MR, Zhang S, Baumgartner LD. Acute effects of barefoot, minimal shoes and running shoes on lower limb mechanics in rear and forefoot strike runners. Footwear Sci. 2013;5(1):9–18.
Ridge ST, Johnson AW, Mitchell UH, et al. Foot bone marrow edema after a 10-wk transition to minimalist running shoes. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2013;45(7):1363–8.
Milner CE, Ferber R, Pollard CD, et al. Biomechanical factors associated with tibial stress fracture in female runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006;38(2):323–8.
Rooney BD, Derrick TR. Joint contact loading in forefoot and rearfoot strike patterns during running. J Biomech. 2013;46:2201–6.
Acknowledgments
No sources of funding were used to assist in the preparation of this review. Dr. Dominic Thewlis has been a recipient of funding from ASICS Oceania (ASICS Oceania Pty Ltd, Eastern Creek, NSW, Australia) to undertake separate research. All other authors declare no potential conflicts of interest and have no financial relationships with any organisations that might have an interest in the submitted work.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fuller, J.T., Bellenger, C.R., Thewlis, D. et al. The Effect of Footwear on Running Performance and Running Economy in Distance Runners. Sports Med 45, 411–422 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-014-0283-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-014-0283-6