Abstract
This paper reports two studies that investigate differences in comprehension monitoring skills between good and poor comprehenders. Two groups of 9– to 10-year-olds, who were matched for reading vocabulary and word recognition skills but who differed in comprehension skill, were selected. In the first study, in which the children were required to find anomalous words and phrases, the skilled comprehenders engaged in more accurate monitoring of sentence level anomalies (but not word level anomalies) than did the poorer comprehenders. In the second study, the comprehension monitoring task required the children to detect pairs of sentences, in short texts, that were contradictory. In addition, the working memory demands of the task were varied by placing the two items of inconsistent information either in adjacent sentences, or in sentences that were separated in the text by several others. As in the first study, less-skilled comprehenders performed more poorly on the detection task, but the difference between the groups was considerably more pronounced when the sentences were separated than when they were adjacent. In addition, the children were given a numerical working memory test, and the poorer comprehenders performed more poorly on this test. However, although working memory performance was related to performance on some of the error detection tasks, comprehension ability was also a good, and sometimes better, predictor. The results are discussed in terms of the different cognitive abilities that might contribute to efficient comprehension monitoring.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
B. P. Ackerman (1984a) ArticleTitleThe effects of storage and processing complexity on comprehension repair in children and adults Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 37 303–334
B. P. Ackerman (1984b) ArticleTitleStorage and processing constraints on integrating story information in children and adults Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 38 64–92
A. D. Baddeley (1986) Working memory Oxford University Press Oxford
L. Baker (1984) ArticleTitleSpontaneous versus instructed use of multiple standards for evaluating comprehension: Effects of age, reading proficiency and type of standard Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 38 289–311 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0022-0965(84)90127-9
K. Cain J. V. Oakhill (1996) ArticleTitleThe nature of the relationship between comprehension skill and the ability to tell a story British Journal of Developmental Psychology 14 187–201
K. Cain J. V. Oakhill (1999) ArticleTitleInference making and its relation to comprehension failure Reading and Writing 11 489–503 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008084120205
K. Cain J. V. Oakhill (2004) Reading comprehension difficulties T. Nunes P.E. Bryant (Eds) Handbook of children’s literacy Kluwer Dordrecht 313–338
K. Cain J. Oakhill P. E. Bryant (2004) ArticleTitleChildren’s reading comprehension ability: Concurrent prediction by working memory, verbal ability, and component skills Journal of Educational Psychology 96 31–42
I. deSousa J. V. Oakhill (1996) ArticleTitleDo levels of interest have an effect on children's comprehension monitoring importance British Journal of Educational Psychology 66 471–482
M.-F. Ehrlich (1996) Metacognitive monitoring in the processing of anaphoric devices in skilled and less-skilled comprehenders C. Cornoldi J. V. Oakhill (Eds) Reading comprehension difficulties: Processes and remediation (pp Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 221–249
M. F. Ehrlich M. Remond H. Tardieu (1999) ArticleTitleProcessing of anaphoric devices in young skilled and less skilled comprehenders: Differences in metacognitive monitoring Reading and Writing 11 29–63 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1007996502372
K. A. Ericsson W. Kintsch (1995) ArticleTitleLong-term working memory Psychological Review 102 211–245 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0033-295X.102.2.211
R. Garner (1980) ArticleTitleMonitoring of understanding: An investigation of good and poor readers' awareness of induced miscomprehension of text Journal of Reading Behavior 12 55–63
R. Garner C. Kraus (1981–82) ArticleTitleGood and poor comprehender differences in knowing and regulating reading behaviors Education Research Quarterly 6 5–12
R. Garner N. Taylor (1982) ArticleTitleMonitoring of understanding: An investigation of attentional assistance needs at different grade and reading proficiency levels Reading Psychology 3 1–6
A. I. Gates W. H. MacGinitie (1965) Gates-MacGinitie Reading Tests Teachers’ College Press, Columbia University New York
D. J. Hacker (1998) Self-regulated comprehension during normal reading D. J. Hacker J. Dunlosky A. C. Graesser (Eds) Metacognition in Educational Theory and Practice LEA Mahwah, NJ 165–191
P. L. Harris A. Kruithof T. M. Meerum T. Visser (1981) ArticleTitleChildren’s detection and awareness of textual anomaly Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 31 212–230 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0022-0965(81)90013-8
W. Kintsch (1998) Comprehension: A paradigm for cognition Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
E. M. Markman (1979) ArticleTitleRealizing that you don’t understand: Elementary school children’s awareness of inconsistencies Child Development 50 643–655
M. D. Neale (1989) The neale analysis of reading ability–revised British edition NFER-Nelson Windsor
J. V. Oakhill (1982) ArticleTitleConstructive processes in skilled and less- skilled comprehenders’ memory for sentences British Journal of Psychology 73 13–20
J. V. Oakhill (1983) ArticleTitleInstantiation in skilled and less-skilled comprehenders Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 35A 441–450
J. V. Oakhill (1984) ArticleTitleInferential and memory skills in children’s comprehension of stories British Journal of Educational Psychology 54 31–39
J. V. Oakhill (1996) Mental models in children’s text comprehension J. V. Oakhill A. Garnham (Eds) Mental models in cognitive science Hove UK: Psychology Press 77–94
J. V. Oakhill K. Cain P. E. Bryant (2003a) ArticleTitleThe dissociation of word reading and text comprehension: Evidence from component skills Language and Cognitive Processes 18 443–468 Occurrence Handle10.1080/01690960344000008
Oakhill, J. V., Cain, K., & Bryant, P. E. (2003b). Prediction of comprehension skill in the primary school years. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Tampa, Florida.
J. V. Oakhill S. Patel (1991) ArticleTitleCan imagery training help children who have comprehension problems Journal of Research in Reading 14 106–115 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-9817.1991.tb00012.x
J. V. Oakhill N. M. Yuill A. Parkin (1986) ArticleTitleOn the nature of the difference between skilled and less-skilled comprehenders Journal of Research in Reading 9 80–91 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-9817.1986.tb00115.x
S. G. Paris M. Myers (1981) ArticleTitleComprehension monitoring, memory and study strategies of good and poor readers Journal of Reading Behavior 13 5–22
C. A. Perfetti M. A. Marron P. W. Foltz (1996) Sources of comprehension failure: Theoretical perspectives and case studies C. Cornoldi J. V. Oakhill (Eds) Reading comprehension difficulties: Processes and intervention Mahwah NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 137–165
C. N. Rubman H. S. Waters (2000) ArticleTitleA, B seeing: The role of constructive processes in children's comprehension monitoring Journal of Educational Psychology 92 503–514 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-0663.92.3.503
K. E. Ruffman (1996) Reassessing children’s comprehension-monitoring skills C. Cornoldi J. V. Oakhill (Eds) Reading comprehension difficulties: Processes and intervention Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ 33–67
M. Sadoski A. Paivio (2001) Imagery and text: a dual coding theory of reading and writing Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah, NJ
A. Seigneuric M.-F. Ehrlich J. V. Oakhill N. M. Yuill (2000) ArticleTitleWorking memory resourses and children’s reading comprehension Reading and Writing 13 81–103 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008088230941
S. Vosniadou P. D. Pearson T. Rogers (1988) ArticleTitleWhat causes children’s failures to detect inconsistencies in text? Representation versus comparison difficulties Journal of Educational Psychology 80 27–39
S. A. Wagoner (1983) ArticleTitleComprehension monitoring: What it is and what we know about it Reading Research Quarterly 18 328–346
C. Westby (2004) A language perspective on executive functioning, metacognition, and self-regulation in reading C. A. Stone E. R. Silliman B. J. Ehren K. Apel (Eds) Handbook of language and literacy: Development and disorders The Guilford Press New York 398–427
N. M. Yuill J. V. Oakhill (1988) ArticleTitleUnderstanding of anaphoric relations in skilled and less skilled comprehenders British Journal of Psychology 79 173–186
N. M. Yuill J. V. Oakhill A. J. Parkin (1989) ArticleTitleWorking memory, comprehension ability and the resolution of text anomaly British Journal of Psychology 80 351–361
K. Zabrucky H. H. Ratner (1986) ArticleTitleChildren’s comprehension monitoring and recall of inconsistent stories Child Development 57 1401–1418
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Oakhill, J., Hartt, J. & Samols, D. Levels of Comprehension Monitoring and Working Memory in Good and Poor Comprehenders. Read Writ 18, 657–686 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11145-005-3355-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11145-005-3355-z