Introduction
… it comprises time-dependent biographical, historical, and developmental processes [and] because these processes are multidimensional and multidetermined, manifesting themselves in very different ways at different levels, and resulting from multiple factors reciprocally interacting with each other (p. 379, Gelo and Salvatore 2016).
Coordination and Psychotherapy
Present Review
Method
Search and Retrieval
Eligibility Criteria
Exclusion Criteria
Results
Descriptive Summaries of Studies
Therapy Types Summary
Gender Composition Summary
Disorders/Issues Summary
Methods Summary
Time Scales
Results by Coordination Function
Links to Psychotherapy Outcomes
Reference | Modality | Sample | Outcome measure | Method | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bos et al. (2002) | Nonverbal involvement behavior—symmetric | 51 dyads (six clinical interviewers) | Symptomology | Regression Model | Lower levels of involvement behavior during the remission interview were associated with more unfavorable depression recoveries |
Borelli et al. (2019) | Language style matching | 7 dyads (three therapists) | Symptomology | Categorical proportion matching | Higher language style matching during the early treatment phase was associated with lower symptomatology at the end of treatment |
Geerts et al. (1996) | Nonverbal involvement behaviors—asymmetric | 32 dyads | Symptomology | Difference Score | Patients who improved showed an increase in attunement over the duration of the session; whereas, patients that did not improve showed a decrease in attunement |
Geerts and Bouhuys (1998) | Nonverbal involvement behaviors—asymmetric | 26 dyads | Symptomology | Difference score | Change in attunement (toward higher levels of attunement) over the interview was associated with a reduction in depression symptoms |
Geerts et al. (2000) | Nonverbal involvement behaviors—asymmetric | 60 dyads | Symptomology | Difference Score | More attunement during the interviews was associated with better responsiveness to treatment in terms of reduction in depression symptoms. The more attunement increased during the interview the higher its associations with a reduction in depression symptoms |
Geerts et al. (2006) | Nonverbal involvement behavior—asymmetric | 101 dyads (three clinical interviewers) | Treatment relapse | Difference Score | Nonverbal convergence between the involvement behaviors of patient and interviewer were related to a reduction in the risk for recurrence of depression |
Rasting and Beutel (2005) | Affective facial displays | 20 dyads (two therapists) | Treatment success | Categorical proportion matching | Patients hedonic affective displays (e.g., relating to smiles and happiness) were positively associated with therapist submissive affective displays (e.g., sadness and fear) in the successful treatment group. By contrast, the unsuccessful group was characterized by positive associations for the same types of all affective displays (e.g., when both a patient and therapist exhibit an aggressive display, etc.) and a negative association between patient hedonic affective displays and therapist submissive displays |
Ramseyer and Tschacher (2011) | Nonverbal upper body movements | 70 dyads (42 therapists) | Symptomology | Cross-correlationa | Synchrony was negatively associated with pre-post outcome measures reflecting a reduction in symptomology with higher synchrony, but not retrospective outcome measures. Patients with higher nonverbal synchrony exhibited less distress from interpersonal problems (IIP), showed fewer symptoms (BSI), reported higher self-efficacy (GSE), and indicated less insecure attachment patterns (MAQ) |
Ramseyer and Tschacher (2014) | Nonverbal head and neck movements | 70 dyads | Perceived treatment outcome | Cross-correlationa | Head synchrony (when controlling for body synchrony) was positively associated with goal attainment scaling (GAS) |
Reich et al. (2014) | Vocal pitch | 52 dyads (16 therapists) | Symptomology | Correlationa | Higher therapist following was positively associated with increases in depression symptoms |
Reuzel et al. (2013) | Eye-Gaze direction | 19 dyads | Session outcome | Cross-recurrence quantification analysisa | Higher synchronization of eye-gaze directions was positively correlated with client’s satisfaction with the session |
Reuzel et al. (2013) | Speech pattern | 19 dyads | Session outcome | Cross-recurrence quantification analysisa | The recurrence rate peak for speech was positively associated with the clients’ reports that they were listened to by the staff member, that they adequately discussed important goal relevant topics, and their overall satisfaction with the interaction |
Rocco et al. (2016) | Verbal attunement of speech rate | 2 dyads | Session outcome | Attunement ratio | There was significantly higher attunement for a good-outcome session compared to a poor-outcome session. In the good outcome case, the data were better fit by a model where attunement drives the relationship quality, which then promoted formal thinking processes. The opposite pathway was a better fit for the poor outcome session |
Tracey et al. (1999) | Interpersonal complementarity | 20 dyads (four therapists) | Symptomology & treatment outcome | Transition matrices | Interpersonal complementarity was curvilinearly related to a composite treatment outcome over time. Dyads without the U pattern had lower treatment outcomes |
Tschacher and Meier (2019) | Respiration | 4 dyads (one therapist) | Session outcome | Cross-correlationa and Windowed regressiona | In-phase synchrony, but not concordance, was associated with therapist’s progress ratings of the patient |
Links to Therapeutic Alliance and Relationship
Reference | Modality | Sample | Measure | Method | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Altenstein et al. (2013) | Interpersonal processes | 20 dyads (12 therapists) | Therapeutic Alliance | Correlation | Patients' mean affiliative behaviors predicted the patients' perception of alliance as measured using the Bern Post Session Report (BPSR-P) |
Bar-Kalifa et al. (2019) | EDA | 31 dyads (ten therapists) | Therapeutic alliance | Cross-correlationa | Synchrony of EDA was related to session level alliance ratings |
Ramseyer and Tschacher (2014) | Nonverbal upper body movements | 70 dyads (42 therapists) | Therapeutic alliance | Cross-correlationa | Nonverbal upper body synchrony (when controlling for head movements) were positively associated with alliance and self-efficacy (BPSR-P). Upper body synchrony was negatively associated with patients' resistance (BPSR-T) |
Bryan et al. (2018) | Vocal pitch (f0) | 54 dyads (five clinicians) | Therapeutic alliance | Actor-partner interdependence model | Higher synchrony in emotional arousal (measured with fundamental frequency) was positively associated with higher alliance (WAI) during a crisis intervention, but not a risk assessment interview |
Ramseyer and Tschacher (2011) | Nonverbal upper body movements | 70 dyads (42 therapists) | Relationship quality | Cross-correlationa | Nonverbal upper body synchrony was positively associated with patient reports of relationship quality |
Ramseyer and Tschacher (2016) | Nonverbal hand movements | 1 dyad | Therapeutic alliance | Cross-correlationa | Hand movement synchrony was positively associated with patient reports of alliance (BPSR-P) |
Reich et al (2014) | Vocal pitch | 52 dyads (16 therapists) | Therapeutic alliance | Correlationa | Higher therapist leading in vocal pitch was negatively associated with therapeutic alliance as measured using a short form of the WAI and 11 interpersonal relationship items of the outcome questionnaire |
Rocco et al. (2016) | Speech rate | 2 dyads | Relationship/alliance | Attunement ratio | Higher attunement in speech rate was evident in a good-outcome session when compared to a poor-outcome session. In the good outcome case, the data were better fit by a model where attunement drives the relationship quality, which then promoted formal thinking processes. The opposite pathway was a better fit for the poor outcome session. The quality of the relationship was measured using the Collaborative Interactions Scale |
Tschacher and Meier (2019) | Heart rate variability (HRV) | 4 dyads (one therapist) | Therapeutic alliance | Cross-correlationa and windowed regressiona | In-phase HRV synchrony was associated with therapist’s alliance rating |
Tschacher and Meier (2019) | Heart rate variability (HRV) | 4 dyads (one therapist) | Cooperation | Cross-correlationa and windowed regressiona | Anti-phase HRV concordance was associated with therapist cooperation ratings |
Tschacher and Meier (2019) | Respiration | 4 dyads (one therapist) | Therapeutic alliance | Cross-correlationa and regressiona | In-phase synchrony, but not concordance index, was associated with client’s alliance rating |
Links to Empathy
Reference | Modality | Sample | Measure | Method | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gaume et al. (2019) | Vocal pitch (f0) | 412 dyads | Empathy rating | Actor-partner interdependence model | No relationship between synchrony in vocal pitch and empathy ratings was observed |
Imel et al. (2014) | Vocal pitch (f0) | 89 dyads (89 therapists) | Empathy rating | Multilevel modelinga | There was higher synchrony in vocal pitch (measured as fundamental frequency) for sessions with high-empathy ratings (using MITI) compared to low-empathy rated sessions |
Lord et al. (2015) | Language style (LS) | 122 dyads (122 therapists) | Empathy rating | Categorical proportion matchinga | Average LS synchrony was higher in high-empathy sessions when compared to low-empathy session as assessed using the MITI specifically in the following categories: Second-person pronouns, impersonal pronouns, articles, prepositions, and quantifiers |
Marci and Orr (2006) | Skin conductance level | 20 dyads (one therapist) | Empathy questionnaire | Windowed regression and correlation | During a deliberate emotionally distant condition, there was lower physiological concordance in skin conductance levels between patient and therapist, and lower responses on the EUS |
Marci et al. (2007) | Skin conductance level | 20 dyads (eight therapists) | Empathy questionnaire | Windowed regression and correlationa | Physiological concordance in SCLs was positively correlated with patient ratings of therapist empathy on EUS. When controlling for variability in the number of prior sessions, SCL concordance was the only significant predictor of empathy when including number of therapy sessions and therapist age. Both patients and therapists showed higher positive social-emotional responses during moments of high physiological concordance |
Messina et al. (2013) | EDA | 39 dyads (13 therapists, 13 psychologists, 13 non—therapists) | Empathy questionnaire | Windowed regression and correlation | EDA concordance at 3 and 4 s lags were positively correlated with EUS empathy questionnaire |
Robinson et al. (1982) | Skin conductance | 21 dyads (ten counselors) | Empathy questionnaire | Correlation | Both small and large, rapid skin conductance responses between client and patients (less than 7 s apart) were positively correlated with empathy responses on the BLRI |
Links Between Modalities
Reference | Primary modality | Secondary modality | Sample | Method | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Coleman et al. (1956) | Heart rate | Interactive and affective behaviors using Bales interaction coding system, and an affective coding system | 1 dyad | Visualization | Patient heart rate was quicker during instances of anxiety, when compared to instances of extra/punitive hostility and depression. Intrapunitive hostility instances had a higher rate than depression instances. When comparing the therapist’s heart rate, during these patient instances, the pattern was the same, although the differences were not as large |
DiMascio et al. (1957) | Heart rate | Patient tension behaviors | 1 dyad | Correlation | Increases in the number of patient’s tension behaviors were associated with a significant decrease in patient’s average heart rate. Increases in the number of patient’s tension release behaviors were associated with a significant decrease in patient’s heart rate lability, an increase in patient’s average heart rate, and an increase in the therapist’s heart rate |
DiMascio et al. (1957) | Skin temperature | Patient antagonism behavior | 1 dyad | Correlation | An increase in the number of patient’s antagonism behaviors was associated with a decrease in patient’s skin temperature lability |
Geerts et al. (2006) | Nonverbal involvement behavior | Patient reported satisfaction | 101 dyads (three clinical interviewers) | Difference Score | Patients reported satisfaction about the interview interaction was positively associated with convergence of involvement behaviors |
Stratford et al. (2012) | EDA | EEG | 30 dyads (six therapists) | Windowed Regression and Correlation | During periods of high EDA concordance, there was lower beta activity in frontal lobe in the last session as compared to mid-treatment session. Parietal theta activity reduced from first session to later sessions. Occipital beta activity was greater in session 4 than session 3 |
Stratford et al. (2014) | Heart rate variability (HRV) | EDA | 30 dyads (six therapists) | Windowed regression and correlation | During the second therapy session, high EDA coordination between patient and therapist was linked to higher patient low frequency HRV. In session 4, high EDA coordination was linked to higher patient low frequency HRV, higher high frequency HRV, and higher total HRV power. In session 6, high EDA coordination was linked to a lower low frequency/high frequency HRV ratio |