Abstract.
Management scholars and practitioners often believe that individuals and organizations benefit by trusting their work contacts. (Husted, 1998; Sonnenberg, 1994) Trust is generally viewed as “good” and imperative to a modern functioning economy (Blau, 1964; Hosmer, 1995; Zucker, 1986) Consequently, scholars and practitioners have given scant attention to the “downside” of trust, despite the fact that trust involves taking risk under conditions of uncertainty (Rousseau et al., 1998) Recent corporate scandals show that people suffer when they misplace trust in untrustworthy organizations and individuals. This paper develops a model of the causes and consequences of “over-trust,” which we define as a state where a trustor’s trust exceeds that which is warranted given the conditions. The antecedents of overtrust related to characteristics of the trustee, the trustor, and situational characteristics. We examine the role played by self-monitoring and perceived power base of the trustee as two key trustee characteristics. Among trustor characteristics, we examine the role (played by trustor’s core evaluation, core values). based on cultural affiliation), prior experiences with trustees, and use of habitual thinking behavior. Under characteristics of the situation, we examine the role played by uncertainty inherent in the situation, perceived threat from the context, degree of task interdependence, and organizational systems and routines. Next, we examine three consequences of over-trust – leniency in judging the trustee, delay in perceiving exploitation, and increased risk-taking. We conclude our paper by developing a set of guidelines that organizational members may employ to avoid over-trust.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baier, A. C.: 1994, ‘Trust and its Vulnerabilities’, Moral Prejudices: Essays on Ethics (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA), 130–151.
Becker, L. C.: 1996, ‘Trust as Noncognitive Security about Motives’, Ethics 107(October), 43–61.
G. G. Bell R. J. Oppenheimer A. Bastien (2002) ArticleTitle‘Trust Deterioration in an International Buyer-Supplier Relationship’ Journal of Business Ethics 36 IssueID1/2 65–78 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1014239812469
R. J. Bies (1987) ‘The Predicament of Justice: The Management of Moral Outrage’ B. M. Staw L. L. Cummings (Eds) Research in Orgnaizational Behavior JAI Press Greenwich, CT 289–319
P. M. Blau (1964) Exchange and Power in Social Life Wiley New York
G. G. Brenkert (1998) ArticleTitle‘Trust, Morality and International Business’ Business Ethics Quarterly 8 IssueID2 293–317 Occurrence Handle10.2307/3857330
T. Burns G. M. Stalker (1961) The Management of Innovation Tavistock London, UK
R. Coase (1937) ArticleTitle‘The Nature of the Firm’ Economica 4 386–405 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1468-0335.1937.tb00002.x
K. T. Dirks (2000) ArticleTitle‘Trust in Leadership and Team Performance: Evidence from NCAA Basketball’ Journal of Applied Psychology 85 IssueID6 1004–1013 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0021-9010.85.6.1004
G. H. Dobbins E. J. Dedrick T. C. Clemona (1990) ArticleTitle‘The Role of Self-Monitoring and Gender on Leader Emergence: A Labratory and Field Study’ Journal of Management 16 IssueID3 609–618 Occurrence Handle10.1177/014920639001600306
P. M. Doney J. P. Cannon M. R. Mullen (1998) ArticleTitle‘Understanding the Influence of National Culture on the Development of Trust’ Academy of Management Review 23 IssueID3 601–620 Occurrence Handle10.2307/259297
P. M. Doney J. P. Cannon M. R. Mullen (1997) ArticleTitle‘An Examination of the Nature of Trust in Buyer-Seller Relationships’ Journal of Marketing 61 IssueIDApril 35–51 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1251829
E. Erickson (1950) Childhood and Society Norton New York
A. Etzioni (1961) A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organizations, on Power, Involvement, and their Correlates Free Press of Glenco New York
E. F. Fama M. C. Jensen (1983) ArticleTitle‘Separation of Ownership and Control’ Journal of Law and Economics 26 301–325 Occurrence Handle10.1086/467037
J. R. P. French B. Raven (1959) ‘The Bases of Social Power’ D. Cartwright (Eds) Studies in Social Power University of Michigan Ann Arbor, MI 150–167
F. Fukuyama (1995) Trust: The social virtues and the creation of prosperity Penguin Books London
D. Gioia (1992) ArticleTitle‘Pinto Fires and Personal Ethics: A Script Analysis of Missed Opportunities’ Journal of Business Ethics 11 IssueID5/6 379–389 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00870550
J. M. Hagen S. Choe (1998) ArticleTitle‘Trust in Japanese Interfirm Relations: Institutional Sanctions Matter’ AMR 23 IssueID3 589–600
R. Hardin (1996) ArticleTitle‘Trustworthiness’ Ethics 107 IssueIDOctober 26–42 Occurrence Handle10.1086/233695
G. Hofstede (1980) Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values SAGE Publications Beverly Hills, CA
G. Hofstede (1983) ArticleTitle‘National Cultures in Four Dimensions: A Research-Based Theory of Cultural Differences Among Nations’ International Studies of Management and Organization 13 IssueID1–2 46–74
G. Hofstede (1993) ArticleTitle‘Cultural Constraints in Management Theories’ Academy of Management Executive 7 IssueID1 81–94
G. C. Homans (1961) Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms Harcourt, Brace, & World New York
L. T. Hosmer (1995) ArticleTitle‘Trust: The Connecting Link Between Organizational Theory and Philosophical Ethics’ Academy of Management Review 20 IssueID2 379–403 Occurrence Handle10.2307/258851
B. W. Husted (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Ethical Limits of Trust in Business Relations’ Business Ethics Quarterly 8 IssueID2 233–248 Occurrence Handle10.2307/3857327
M. C. Jensen W. H. Meckling (1976) ArticleTitleTheory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure Journal of Financial Economics 3 305–360 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0304-405X(76)90026-X
L. N. Jewell H. J. Reitz (1981) Group Effectiveness in Organizations Scott Foresman Glenview, IL
K. Jones (1996) ArticleTitle‘Trust as an Affective Attitude’ Ethics 107 IssueID1 4–25 Occurrence Handle10.1086/233694
T. A. Judge A. Erez J. E. Bono C. J. Thoresen (2003) ArticleTitle‘The Core-Evaluation Scale: Development of a Measure’ Personnel Psychology 56 IssueID2 303–332 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1744-6570.2003.tb00152.x
Judge, T. A., E. A., Locke and C. C. Durham: 1997, ‘The Dispositional Causes of Job Satisfaction: A Core Evaluations Approach’, in B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (Eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior Vol. 19, 151–188.
Kelman, H. C.: 1958, ‘Compliance, Identification, and Internalization: Three Processes of Attitude Change’, Journal of Conflict Resolution 51–61.
P. R. Lawrence J. W. Lorsch (1969) Organization and Environment RD Irwin Homewood, Ill
R. J. Lewicki D. J. McAllister R. J. Bies (1998) ArticleTitle‘Trust and Distrust: New Relationships and Realities’ Academy of Management Review 22 IssueID3 438–458 Occurrence Handle10.2307/259288
R. H. Lowe S. J. Vodanovich (1995) ArticleTitle‘A Field Study of Distributive and Procedural Justice as Predictors of Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment’ Journal of Business and Psychology 10 IssueID1 99–113 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF02249273
R. C. Mayer J. H. Davis F. D. Schoorman (1995) ArticleTitle‘An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust’ Academy of Management Review 20 IssueID3 709–734 Occurrence Handle10.2307/258792
D. C. McClelland (1970) ArticleTitle‘The Two Faces of Power’ Journal of International Affairs 24 29–47
D. H. McKnight L. L. Cummings N. L. Chervany (1998) ArticleTitle‘Initial Trust Formation in New Organizational Relationships’ Academy of Management Review 23 IssueID3 473–490 Occurrence Handle10.2307/259290
W. Mischell (1973) ArticleTitleToward a Cognitive Social Learning Reconceptualization of Personality’ Psychological Review 80 252–283 Occurrence Handle10.1037/h0035002
E. Packer (1985) ArticleTitle‘Understanding the Subconscious’ The Objectivist Forum 6 IssueID1 1–10
J. L. Pierce T. Kostova K. T. Dirks (2003) ArticleTitle‘The State of Psychological Ownership: Integrating and Extending a Century of Research’ Review of General Psychology 7 IssueID1 84–107 Occurrence Handle10.1037/1089-2680.7.1.84
P. S. Ring A. H. Vande Ven (1992) ArticleTitle‘Structuring Cooperative Relationships Between Organizations’ Strategic Management Journal 13 483–498 Occurrence Handle10.1002/smj.4250130702
P. S. Ring A. H. Vande Ven (1994) ArticleTitle‘Developmental Processes of Cooperative Interorganizational Relationships’ Academy of Management Review 19 IssueID1 90–118 Occurrence Handle10.2307/258836
D. M. Rousseau S. Sitkin R. Burt C. F. Camerer (1998) ArticleTitle‘Not So Different After All: A Cross-Discipline View of Trust’ Academy of Management Review 23 IssueID3 393–404
M. Sako S. Helper (1998) ArticleTitle‘Determinants of Trust in Supplier Relations: Evidence From the Automotive Industry in Japan and the United States’ Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 34 IssueID3 387–417 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0167-2681(97)00082-6
G. R. Salancik J. Pfeffer (1978) ArticleTitle‘A Social Information Processing Approach to Job Attitudes and Task Design’ Administrative Science Quarterly 23 224–253 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2392563
M. J. Scher (1999) ‘Japanese Interfirm Networks’ A. Grandori (Eds) Interfirm Networks Routledge London and New York 303–318
L. Smircich G. Morgan (1982) ArticleTitle‘Leadership: The Management of Meaning’ Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 18 IssueID3 257–273 Occurrence Handle10.1177/002188638201800303
F. K. Sonnenberg (1994) ArticleTitle‘Trust Me ... Trust me not’ Journal of Business Strategy 15 IssueID1 14–16 Occurrence Handle10.1108/eb039609
A. Tversky D. Kahneman (1982) ‘Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases’ D. Kahneman P. Slovic A. Tversky (Eds) Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK 3–20
A. H. Van de Ven A. L. Delbecq R. J. Koenig (1976) ArticleTitle‘Determinants of Coordination Modes within Organizations’ American Sociological Review 41 322–338 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2094477
D. Watson L. A. Clark A. Tellegen (1988) ArticleTitle‘Development and Validation of Brief Measures of Positive and Negative Affect’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54 1063–1070 Occurrence Handle10.1037/0022-3514.54.6.1063
W. F. Whyte (1949) ArticleTitle‘The Social Structure of the Restaurant’ American Journal of Sociology 54 302–308 Occurrence Handle10.1086/220366
A. C. Wicks S. L. Berman T. M. Jones (1999) ArticleTitle‘The Structure of Optimal Trust: Moral and Strategic Implications’ Academy of Management Review 24 IssueID1 99–116 Occurrence Handle10.2307/259039
O. E. Williamson (1975) Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications The Free Press New York
O. E. Williamson (1979) ArticleTitle‘Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations’ University of Chicatgo Law School Journal of Law and Economics 22 IssueIDOctober 233–261
O. E. Williamson (1985) The Economic Institutions of Capitalism The Free Press New York
A. Zaheer B. Mc Evily V. Perrone (1998) ArticleTitle‘Does Trust Matter? Exploring the Effects of Interorganizational and Interpersonal Trust on Performance’ Organization Science 9 IssueID2 141–159 Occurrence Handle10.1287/orsc.9.2.141
L. G. Zucker (1986) ‘Production of Trust: Institutional Sources of Economic Structure.’ 1840–1920’ L. L. Cummings B. Staw (Eds) Research in Organizational Behavior JAI Press Inc New York, NY 53–111
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Goel, S., Bell, G.G. & Pierce, J.L. The Perils of Pollyanna: Development of the Over-Trust Construct. J Bus Ethics 58, 203–218 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-1415-6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-005-1415-6