Abstract
More than 100 years ago, Osler inspired educators to consider health professions education (HPE) as intricately reliant on patients. Since that time, patient involvement in HPE has taken on many different meanings. The result is a disparate body of literature that is challenging to search, making it difficult to determine how to continue to build knowledge in the field. To address this problem, we conducted a review of the literature on patient involvement in HPE using a meta-narrative approach. The aim of the review was to synthesize how questions of patient involvement in HPE have been considered across various research traditions and over time. In this paper, we focus on three scholarly communities concerned with various interpretations of patient involvement in HPE—patient as teachers, real patients as standardized patients, and bedside learning. Focus on these three research communities served as a way to draw out various meta-narratives in which patients are thought of in particular ways, specific rationales for involvement are offered, and different research traditions are put to use in the field. Attending to the intersections between these meta-narratives, we focus on the potentially incommensurate ways in which “active” patient engagement is considered within the broader field and the possible implications. We end by reflecting on these tensions and what they might mean for the future of patient involvement, specifically patient involvement as part of future iterations of competency based education.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agrawal, S., & Edwards, M. (2013). Upside down: The consumer as advisor to a psychiatrist. Psychiatric Services, 64(4), 301–302. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ps.640413.
Allen, S. S., Miller, J., Ratner, E., & Santilli, J. (2011). The educational and financial impact of using patient educators to teach introductory physical exam skills. Medical Teacher, 33(11), 911–918. https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2011.558139.
Arenson, C., Giordano, C., Lyons, K., Collins, L., Umland, E., Hewston, L., et al. (2012). Effect of the health mentors program on student attitudes toward team care. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 60, S157–S158. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1532-5415.2012.04000.x.
Arnstein, S. R. (1969). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35(4), 216–224.
Asprey, D. P., Hegmann, T. E., & Bergus, G. R. (2007). Comparison of medical student and physician assistant student performance on standardized-patient assessments. Journal of Physician Assistant Education (Physician Assistant Education Association), 18(4), 16–19.
Barr, J., Ogden, K., Radford, J., & Rooney, K. (2009). Sustainable involvement of real patients in medical education: Thanks to volunteerism and relationship management. Medical Education, 43(6), 599–600. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03377.x.
Barrows, H. S. (1993). An overview of the uses of standardized patients for teaching and evaluating clinical skills. AAMC. Academic Medicine, 68(6), 443–451. (discussion 451–443).
Bashour, H., Sayed-Hassan, R., & Koudsi, A. (2012). Involving patients in medical education: Ethical issues experienced by Syrian patients. Education for Health, 25(2), 87–91. https://doi.org/10.4103/1357-6283.103453.
Bates, J., & Towle, A. (2012). Longitudinal integrated clinical placements: Where are we going? Medical Education, 46(11), 1024–1026. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12045.
Beadle, M., Needham, Y., & Dearing, M. (2012). Collaboration with service users to develop reusable learning objects: The ROOT to success. Nurse Education in Practice, 12(6), 352–355. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2012.04.005.
Beecham, R. (2005). ‘Clients’ as teachers: Power-sharing in the speech-language therapy curriculum. Advances in Speech Language Pathology, 7(3), 130–137.
Bleakley, A. (2012). The proof is in the pudding: Putting actor-network-theory to work in medical education. Medical Teacher, 34(6), 462–467.
Bleakley, A. (2014). Patient-centred medicine in transition: The heart of the matter. New York: Springer.
Bleakley, A., & Bligh, J. (2008). Students learning from patients: Let’s get real in medical education. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 13(1), 89–107.
Bokken, L., Rethans, J. J., Scherpbier, A. J., & van der Vleuten, C. P. (2008). Strengths and weaknesses of simulated and real patients in the teaching of skills to medical students: a review. Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of The Society for Medical Simulation, 3(3), 161–169. https://doi.org/10.1097/SIH.0b013e318182fc56.
Bollard, M., Lahiff, J., & Parkes, N. (2012). Involving people with learning disabilities in nurse education: Towards an inclusive approach. Nurse Education Today, 32(2), 173–177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2011.10.002.
Broer, T., Nieboer, A. P., & Bal, R. (2014). Mutual powerlessness in client participation practices in mental health care. Health Expectations, 17(2), 208–219. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1369-7625.2011.00748.x.
Celenza, A., Li, J., & Teng, J. (2011). Medical student/student doctor access to patients in an emergency department. Emergency Medicine Australasia, 23(3), 364–371. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1742-6723.2011.01414.x.
Charlton, J. I. (1998). Nothing about us without us: Disability oppression and empowerment. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Chiong, W. (2007). Justifying patient risks associated with medical education. JAMA, 298(9), 1046–1048.
Coleman, K., & Murray, E. (2002). Patients’ views and feelings on the community-based teaching of undergraduate medical students: A qualitative study. Family Practice, 19(2), 183–188.
Davidson, R., Duerson, M., Rathe, R., Pauly, R., & Watson, R. T. (2001). Using standardized patients as teachers: A concurrent controlled trial. Academic Medicine, 76(8), 840–843.
Debyser, B., Grypdonck, M. H., Defloor, T., & Verhaeghe, S. T. (2011). Involvement of inpatient mental health clients in the practical training and assessment of mental health nursing students: Can it benefit clients and students? Nurse Education Today, 31(2), 198–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2010.06.001.
Draper, H., Ives, J., Parle, J., & Ross, N. (2008). Medical education and patients’ responsibilities: Back to the future? Journal of Medical Ethics, 34(2), 116–119. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.2006.019257.
Duggan, A., Bradshaw, Y. S., & Altman, W. (2010). How do I ask about your disability? An examination of interpersonal communication processes between medical students and patients with disabilities. Journal of Health Communication, 15(3), 334–350. https://doi.org/10.1080/10810731003686630.
Eakin, J. M. (1984). Survival of the fittest? The democratization of hospital administration in Quebec. International Journal of Health Services, 14(3), 397–412.
Engeström, Y. (1999). Expansive visibilization of work: An activity-theoretical perspective. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 8(1–2), 63–93.
Fenwick, T., & Edwards, R. (2010). Actor-network theory in education. New York: Routledge.
Gall, E. P., Meredith, K. E., Stillman, P. L., Rutala, P. J., Gooden, M. A., Boyer, J. T., et al. (1984). The use of trained patient instructors for teaching and assessing rheumatologic care. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 27(5), 557–563.
Gough, D. (2013). Meta-narrative and realist reviews: Guidance, rules, publication standards and quality appraisal. BMC Medicine, 11(1), 22.
Graham, K. L., Green, S., Kurlan, R., & Pelosi, J. S. (2014). A patient-led educational program on Tourette syndrome: Impact and implications for patient-centered medical education. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 26(1), 34–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/10401334.2013.857339.
Greenhalgh, T., & Peacock, R. (2005). Effectiveness and efficiency of search methods in systematic reviews of complex evidence: Audit of primary sources. BMJ, 331(7524), 1064–1065.
Greenhalgh, T., Potts, H. W., Wong, G., Bark, P., & Swinglehurst, D. (2009). Tensions and paradoxes in electronic patient record research: A systematic literature review using the meta-narrative method. Milbank Quarterly, 87(4), 729–788.
Greenhalgh, T., Robert, G., Macfarlane, F., Bate, P., & Kyriakidou, O. (2004). Diffusion of innovations in service organizations: Systematic review and recommendations. Milbank Quarterly, 82(4), 581–629. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0887-378x.2004.00325.x.
Greenhalgh, T., Robert, G., Macfarlane, F., Bate, P., Kyriakidou, O., & Peacock, R. (2005). Storylines of research in diffusion of innovation: A meta-narrative approach to systematic review. Social Science and Medicine, 61(2), 417–430.
Gutman, C., Kraiem, Y., Criden, W., & Yalon-Chamovitz, S. (2012). Deconstructing hierarchies: A pedagogical model with service user co-teachers. Social Work Education, 31(2), 202–214. https://doi.org/10.1080/02615479.2012.644963.
Hamilton, M. (2011). Unruly practices: What a sociology of translations can offer to educational policy analysis. Educational Philosophy & Theory, 43, 55–75. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-5812.2009.00622.x.
Holmboe, E. S., Sherbino, J., Long, D. M., Swing, S. R., Frank, J. R., & Collaborators, I. C. (2010). The role of assessment in competency-based medical education. Medical Teacher, 32(8), 676–682.
Hope, K., Pulsford, D., Thompson, R., Capstick, A., & Heyward, T. (2007). Hearing the voice of people with dementia in professional education. Nurse Education Today, 27(8), 821–824.
Hubbeling, D. (2008). Can patients refuse to be treated by medical students? Medical Education, 42(7), 747. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03115.x.
Iezzoni, L. I., & Long-Bellil, L. M. (2012). Training physicians about caring for persons with disabilities: “Nothing about us without us!”. Disability & Health Journal, 5(3), 136–139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dhjo.2012.03.003.
Jamal, F., Bertotti, M., Lorenc, T., & Harden, A. (2013). Reviewing conceptualisations of community: reflections on a meta-narrative approach. Qualitative Research, 15, 1–20.
Jha, V., Quinton, N. D., Bekker, H. L., & Roberts, T. E. (2009a). Strategies and interventions for the involvement of real patients in medical education: A systematic review. Medical Education, 43(1), 10–20.
Jha, V., Quinton, N. D., Bekker, H. L., & Roberts, T. E. (2009b). What educators and students really think about using patients as teachers in medical education: A qualitative study. Medical Education, 43(5), 449–456. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03355.x.
Jha, V., Setna, Z., Al-Hity, A., Quinton, N. D., & Roberts, T. E. (2010). Patient involvement in teaching and assessing intimate examination skills: A systematic review. Medical Education, 44(4), 347–357. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03608.x.
Krahn, L. E., Bostwick, J. M., Sutor, B., & Olsen, M. W. (2002). The challenge of empathy: A pilot study of the use of standardized patients to teach introductory psychopathology to medical students. Academic Psychiatry, 26(1), 26–30. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ap.26.1.26.
Kroll, T., Groah, S., Gilmore, B., & Neri, M. (2008). Consumer-directed teaching of health care professionals involved in the care of people with spinal cord injury: The Consumer-Professional Partnership Program. Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 39(5), 228–234.
Kuhn, T. S. (1996). The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Kumagai, A. K. (2008). A conceptual framework for the use of illness narratives in medical education. Academic Medicine, 83(7), 653–658.
Kumagai, A. K., & Naidu, T. (2015). Reflection, dialogue, and the possibilities of space. Academic Medicine, 90(3), 283–288.
Latour, B. (1999). On recalling ANT. The Sociological Review, 47(S1), 15–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-954x.1999.tb03480.x.
Latour, B. (2004). Why has critique run out of steam? From matters of fact to matters of concern. Critical Inquiry, 30, 225–248.
Latour, B. (2007). Reassembling the social: An introduction to actor-network-theory. New York: Oxford University Press.
Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Law, J. (1999). After ANT: Complexity, naming and topology. The Sociological Review, 47(S1), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-954x.1999.tb03479.x.
Leinster, S. (2004). Of course you don’t mind being seen by the students. Medical Education, 38(10), 1024–1025. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.01966.x.
Livingston, G., & Cooper, C. (2004). User and carer involvement in mental health training. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 10(2), 85–92.
Long-Bellil, L. M., Robey, K. L., Graham, C. L., Minihan, P. M., Smeltzer, S. C., Kahn, P., et al. (2011). Teaching medical students about disability: The use of standardized patients. Academic Medicine, 86(9), 1163–1170. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0b013e318226b5dc.
Ludmerer, K. M. (1983). The rise of the teaching hospital in America. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 38(4), 389–414.
McCreaddie, M. (2002). Involving patients in teaching about blood-borne viruses. Nursing Standard, 16(44), 33–36.
McKeown, M., Malihi-Shoja, L., Hogarth, R., Jones, F., Holt, K., Sullivan, P., et al. (2012). The value of involvement from the perspective of service users and carers engaged in practitioner education: Not just a cash nexus. Nurse Education Today, 32(2), 178–184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2011.07.012.
Mol, A. (1999). Ontological politics. A word and some questions. The Sociological Review, 47(S1), 74–89. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-954x.1999.tb03483.x.
Mol, A. (2010). Actor-network theory: Sensitive terms and enduring tensions. K√∂lner Zeitschrift f√ºr Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie. Sonderheft, 50, 253–269.
Monrouxe, L. V., Rees, C. E., & Bradley, P. (2009). The construction of patients’ involvement in hospital bedside teaching encounters. Qualitative Health Research, 19(7), 918–930. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732309338583.
Muir, D., & Laxton, J. C. (2012). Experts by experience; the views of service user educators providing feedback on medical students’ work based assessments. Nurse Education Today, 32(2), 146–150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2011.08.015.
Nestel, D., Cecchini, M., Calandrini, M., Chang, L., Dutta, R., Tierney, T., et al. (2008). Real patient involvement in role development: Evaluating patient focused resources for clinical procedural skills. Medical Teacher, 30(5), 534–536. https://doi.org/10.1080/01421590802047232.
Ocloo, J. E., & Fulop, N. J. (2012). Developing a ‘critical’ approach to patient and public involvement in patient safety in the NHS: Learning lessons from other parts of the public sector? Health Expectations, 15(4), 424–432.
O’Neill, F., Morris, P., & Symons, J. (2006). Bridging the gap: Learning with patient teachers in health professional education. Practice Development in Health Care, 5(1), 26–29.
Paull, J. D. (2006). More students and less patients: The squeeze on medical teaching resources. Medical Journal of Australia, 184(2), 94. (author reply 94).
Plaksin, J., Nicholson, J., Kundrod, S., Zabar, S., Kalet, A., & Altshuler, L. (2016). The benefits and risks of being a standardized patient: A narrative review of the literature. The Patient: Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 9(1), 15–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40271-015-0127-y.
Regan de Bere, S., & Nunn, S. (2016). Towards a pedagogy for patient and public involvement in medical education. Medical Education, 50(1), 79–92. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12880.
Repper, J., & Breeze, J. (2007). User and carer involvement in the training and education of health professionals: A review of the literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 44(3), 511–519.
Robertson, K., Hegarty, K., O’Connor, V., & Gunn, J. (2003). Women teaching women’s health: Issues in the establishment of a clinical teaching associate program for the well woman check. Women and Health, 37(4), 49–65.
Rowland, P., & Kumagai, A. K. (2018). Dilemmas of representation: Patient engagement in health professions education. Academic Medicine, 93(6), 869–873.
Silverman, R. E., Araujo, M., & Nicholson, A. (2012). Including gynecological teaching associates’ perspectives in women’s health exams: Lessons for improved communication practices. Health Communication, 27(7), 723–725. https://doi.org/10.1080/10410236.2012.666714.
Skog, M., Grafstrom, M., Negussie, B., & Winblad, B. (2000). The patient as “teacher”: Learning in the care of elderly persons with dementia. Nurse Education Today, 20(4), 288–297.
Spencer, J., Blackmore, D., Heard, S., McCrorie, P., McHaffie, D., Scherpbier, A., et al. (2000). Patient-oriented learning: A review of the role of the patient in the education of medical students. Medical Education, 34(10), 851–857.
Stillman, P. L., Ruggill, J. S., Rutala, P. J., & Sabers, D. L. (1980). Patient instructors as teachers and evaluators. Journal of Medical Education, 55(3), 186–193.
Stockhausen, L. J. (2009). The patient as experience broker in clinical learning. Nurse Education in Practice, 9(3), 184–189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2008.06.006.
Taylor, J. S. (2011). The moral aesthetics of simulated suffering in standardized patient performances. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, 35(2), 134–162. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11013-011-9211-5.
Towle, A., Bainbridge, L., Godolphin, W., Katz, A., Kline, C., Lown, B., et al. (2010). Active patient involvement in the education of health professionals. Medical Education, 44(1), 64–74. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03530.x.
Towle, A., & Godolphin, W. (2011). A meeting of experts: The emerging roles of non-professionals in the education of health professionals. Teaching in Higher Education, 16(5), 495–504.
Towle, A., & Godolphin, W. (2015). Patients as teachers: Promoting their authentic and autonomous voices. The Clinical Teacher, 12(3), 149–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/tct.12400.
Tritter, J. Q. (2009). Revolution or evolution: The challenges of conceptualizing patient and public involvement in a consumerist world. Health Expectations, 12(3), 275–287.
Tritter, J. Q., & McCallum, A. (2006). The snakes and ladders of user involvement: Moving beyond Arnstein. Health Policy, 76(2), 156–168.
Vail, R., Mahon-Salazar, C., Morrison, A., & Kalet, A. (1996). Patients as teachers: An integrated approach to teaching medical students about the ambulatory care of HIV infected patients. Patient Education and Counseling, 27(1), 95–101. https://doi.org/10.1016/0738-3991%2895%2900793-8.
Walters, K., Buszewicz, M., Russell, J., & Humphrey, C. (2003). Teaching as therapy: Cross sectional and qualitative evaluation of patients’ experiences of undergraduate psychiatry teaching in the community. BMJ, 326(7392), 740.
Waterbury, J. T. (2001). Refuting patients’ obligations to clinical training: A critical analysis of the arguments for an obligation of patients to participate in the clinical education of medical students. Medical Education, 35(3), 286–294.
Webster, B. J., Goodhand, K., Haith, M., & Unwin, R. (2012). The development of service users in the provision of verbal feedback to student nurses in a clinical simulation environment. Nurse Education Today, 32(2), 133–138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2011.10.003.
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Wong, G., Greenhalgh, T., Westhorp, G., Buckingham, J., & Pawson, R. (2013). RAMESES publication standards: Meta-narrative reviews. BMC Medicine, 11(1), 987–1004.
Wykurz, G., & Kelly, D. (2002). Developing the role of patients as teachers: Literature review. BMJ: British Medical Journal, 325(7368), 818–821. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.325.7368.818.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Arnold P. Gold Foundation for supporting this project through Mapping the Landscape funding. The authors would also like to acknowledge the assistance of Dr. Nancy McNaugton and Dr. Sophie Soklaridis for their contribution as members of the Advisory Panel, and for SS’s thoughtful commentary on earlier drafts of this paper. The authors would also like to thank Debbie Rolfe for her contributions to earlier aspects of the literature review and her commentary on earlier drafts. Finally, the authors would like to thank Professor Trisha Greenhalgh for advice on methodology, analysis, and reviews of earlier versions of this manuscript.
Funding
This work is supported by the Arnold P. Gold Foundation through a Mapping the Landscape grant.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rowland, P., Anderson, M., Kumagai, A.K. et al. Patient involvement in health professionals’ education: a meta-narrative review. Adv in Health Sci Educ 24, 595–617 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-018-9857-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-018-9857-7