Abstract
Background
To evaluate the clinical presentation, diagnostic and therapeutic management and outcome of 27 cases of post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome (PT TOS).
Methods
Retrospective chart analysis.
Results
Nineteen women and eight men were included in this study. Involvement in a traffic accident was the most common scenario. Fracture of either the first rib or the clavicle was reported in eight patients at the time of injury; in others, the diagnosis was cervical or shoulder soft tissue trauma. Upon presentation at our clinic at a mean 41 months after injury, four patients had bilateral symptoms and 17 reported decreased function of either the arm or hand. Two patients presented with severe lower trunk deficits including one who had received surgical intervention at both the cervical spine and elbow before diagnosis of TOS was made. Sixteen and 15 patients were suffering from some degree of anxiety and/or depression. Upon diagnosis of neurogenic TOS, the two patients with atrophy of the hand musculature were treated surgically. Conservative treatment was applied to all other patients. Six months after presentation to our clinic, nine patients demonstrated a significant improvement. The remainder that reported incapacitating symptoms were offered surgical treatment. Three patients declined the latter. Fifteen patients received surgical treatment via an anterior supraclavicular approach with resection of the anterior scalene muscles. Eleven patients had resection of the middle scalene muscle while five had resection of an osseous structure (partial claviculectomy, C7 transverse process or a cervical rib). The two patients with atrophy of the hand only slightly improved their motor deficit but had a notable relief of symptoms of pain. Postoperative improvement occurred in 80% of surgically treated patients.
Conclusions
The majority of patients suffering from a post-traumatic TOS present a neurogenic, usually subjective syndrome. Prompt therapeutic management is necessary, addressing both physical and psychological complaints. Most patients are cured or well improved by conservative and/or surgical treatment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexandre A, Coro L, Azuelos A, Pellone M (2005) Thoracic outlet syndrome due to hyperextension-hyperflexion cervical injury. Acta Neurochir Suppl 92:21–24
Capistrant TD (1977) Thoracic outlet syndrome in whiplash injury. Ann Surg 185(2):175–178
Casbas L, Chauffour X, Cau J, Bossavy JP, Midy D, Baste JC, Barret A (2005) Post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndromes. Ann Vasc Surg 19:25–28
Cheng SW, Reilly LM, Nelken NA, Ellis WV, Stoney RJ (1995) Neurogenic thoracic outlet decompression: rationale for sparing the first rib. Cardiovasc Surg 3(6):617–623
Cherington M, Wilbourn AJ, Schils J, Whitaker J (1995) Thoracic outlet syndromes and MRI. Brain 118:819–821
Collins JD, Disher AC, Miller TQ (1995) The anatomy of the brachial plexus as displayed by magnetic resonance imaging: technique and application. J Natl Med Assoc 87(7):489–498
Crotti FM, Carai A, Carai M, Sgaramella E, Sias W (2005) Post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). Acta Neurochir Suppl 92:13–15
Dellon AL (1993) The results of supraclavicular brachial plexus neurolysis (without first rib resection) in management of post-traumatic “thoracic outlet syndrome”. J Reconstr Microsurg 9(1):11–17
Demirbag D, Unlu E, Ozdemir F, Genchellac H, Temizoz O, Ozdemir H, Demir MK (2007) The relationship between magnetic resonance imaging findings and postural manoeuver and physical examination tests in patients with thoracic outlet syndrome: results of a double-blind, controlled study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 88(7):844–851
Demondion X, Bacqueville E, Paul C, Duquesnoy B, Hachulla E, Cotten A (2003) Thoracic outlet: assessment with MR imaging in asymptomatic and symptomatic populations. Radiology 227(2):461–468
Devin R, Branchereau A, Aubaniac JM, Boutboul R (1978) Les syndromes de la traversée thoraco-cervico-brachiale post-traumatiques. Rev Fr Dommage Corp 4(4):327–336
Dixon D, Johnston M, McQueen M, Court-Brown C (2008) The disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand questionnaire (DASH) can measure the impairment, activity limitations and participation restriction constructs from the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF). BMC Musculoskelet Disord 9:114
Dubuisson AS, Kline DG, Weinshel SS (1993) Posterior subscapular approach to the brachial plexus. Report of 102 patients. J Neurosurg 79:319–330
Dubuisson A, Nguyen Khac M, Scholtes F, Racaru T, Kaschten B (2011) La main de Gilliatt-Sumner ou le syndrome de défilé cervicothoracique neurogène vrai. A propos de sept cas opérés. Neurochirurgie 57:9–14
Ellison DW, Wood VE (1994) Trauma-related thoracic outlet syndrome. J Hand Surg 19B(4):424–426
Ferrari R, Bohr T, Wilbourn AJ (2001) Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is one of the traumatic complications of whiplash injury. J Spinal Disord 14(6):487–493
Fiévé G (1989) Les syndromes de la traversée thoraco-brachiale. Kieffer, Paris
Franklin GM, Fulton-Kehoe D, Bradley C, Smith-Weller T (2000) Outcome of surgery for thoracic outlet syndrome in Washington state workers’ compensation. Neurology 54(6):1252–1258
Ghoussoub K, Tabet G, Faroy C, Sleilaty G, Rouhoz G, Jebara S (2007) Predictive factors of long-term functional rehabilitation in thoracic outlet syndromes: 85 patients. Ann Readapt Med Phys 50(3):134–139
Gillard J, Perez-Cousin M, Hachulla E, Remy J, Hurtevent JF, Vinckier L, Thevenon A, Duquesnoy B (2001) Diagnosing thoracic outlet syndrome: contribution of provocative tests, ultrasonography, electrophysiology, and helical computed tomography in 48 patients. Joint Bone Spine 68(5):416–424
Gilliat RW, Le Quesne PM, Logue V, Sumner AJ (1970) Wasting of the hand associated with a cervical rib or band. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 33:615–624
Huang JH, Zager EL (2004) Thoracic outlet syndrome. Neurosurgery 55:897–903
Ide J, Kataoka Y, Yamaga M, Kitamura T, Takagi K (2003) Compression and stretching of the brachial plexus in thoracic outlet syndrome: correlation between neuroradiographic findings and symptoms and signs produced by provocation manoeuvres. J Hand Surg (Br) 28(3):218–233
Ide M, Ide J, Yamaga M, Takagi K (2001) Symptoms and signs of irritation of the brachial plexus in whiplash injuries. J Bone Joint Surg Br 83-B:226–229
Jamieson WG, Chinnick B (1996) Thoracic outlet syndrome: fact or fancy? A review of 409 consecutive patients who underwent operation. Can J Surg 39(4):321–326
Kai Y, Oyama M, Kurose S, Inadome T, Oketani Y, Masuda Y (2001) Neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome in whiplash injury. J Spinal Disord 14(6):487–493
Kasch H, Bach FW, Stengaard-Pedersen K, Jensen TS (2003) Development in pain and neurologic complaints after whiplash: a 1-year prospective study. Neurology 60(5):743–749
Komanetsky RM, Novak CB, Mackinnon SE, Russo MH, Padberg AM, Louis S (1996) Somatosensory evoked potentials fail to diagnose thoracic outlet syndrome. J Hand Surg (Am) 21(4):662–666
Lindgren KA (1997) Conservative treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome: a 2-year follow-up. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 78(4):373–378
Machleder HI, Moll F, Verity MA (1986) The anterior scalene muscle in thoracic outlet compression syndrome. Histochemical and morphometric studies. Arch Surg 121(10):1141–1144
Machleder HI, Moll F, Nuwer M, Jordan S (1987) Somatosensory evoked potentials in the assessment of thoracic outlet compression syndrome. J Vasc Surg 6(2):177–184
Magnusson T (1994) Extracervical symptoms after whiplash trauma. Cephalalgia 14(3):223–227
Mailis A, Papagapiou M, Vanderlinden RG, Campbell V, Taylor A (1995) Thoracic outlet syndrome after motor vehicle accidents in a Canadian pain clinic population. Clin J Pain 11(4):316–324
Makhoul RG, Machleder HI (1992) Developmental anomalies at the thoracic outlet: an analysis of 200 consecutive cases. J Vasc Surg 16(4):534–542
Martinez NS (1986) Traumatic TOS. In: Pollack EW (ed) Thoracic outlet syndrome. Diagnosis and treatment. Futura Publishing Co, New York, pp 125–134
McGillicuddy JE (2004) Cervical radiculopathy, entrapment neuropathy, and thoracic outlet syndrome: how to differentiate? J Neurosurg Spine 2:179–187
Mulder DS, Greenwood FAH, Brooks CE (1973) Posttraumatic thoracic outlet syndrome. J Trauma 13(8):706–715
Mulhall KJ, Moloney M, Burke TE, Masterson E (2003) Chronic neck pain following road traffic accidents in an Irish setting and its relationship to seat belt use and low back pain. Ir Med J 96(2):53–54
Narakas A (1991) Syndrome de la traversée thoraco-cervico-brachiale. In Tubiana R (ed) Traité de Chirurgie de la Main. Tome 4: Affections neurologiques – Paralysies du membre supérieur – Syndromes canalaires. Masson, Paris, pp 378–418
Novak CB, Collins ED, Mackinnon SE (1995) Outcome following conservative management of thoracic outlet syndrome. J Hand Surg 20A(4):542–548
Ochsner A, Gage M, Debakey M (1935) Scalenus anticus (Naffziger) syndrome. Am J Surg 28:669–695
Ovadia D, Steinberg EL, Nissan MN, Dekel S (2002) Whiplash injury: a retrospective study on patients seeking compensation. Injury 33(7):569–573
Panegyres PK, Moore N, Gibson R, Rushworth G, Donaghy M (1993) Thoracic outlet syndromes and magnetic resonance imaging. Brain 116:823–841
Papelard A (2002) Le traumatisme cervical dans le temps, de 1980 à 2000, et les cervicalgies « post-traumatiques ». Rev Fr Dommage Corp 28(2):89–100
Pettersson K, Hildingsson C, Toolanen G, Fagerlund M, Bjornebrink J (1997) Disc pathology after whiplash injury. A prospective magnetic resonance imaging and clinical investigation. Spine 22(3):283–287
Poleshuck EL, Bair MJ, Kroenke K, Damush TM, Tu W, Wu J, Krebs EE, Giles DE (2009) Psychosocial stress and anxiety in musculoskeletal pain patients with and without depression. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 3152:116–122
Povlsen B, Belzberg A, Hansson T, Dorsi M (2010) Treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome (Review). Cochrane Database of Systematic Review (1): CD007218
Rayan GM, Jensen C (1995) Thoracic outlet syndrome: provocative examination maneuvers in a typical population. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 4(2):113–117
Razi DM, Wassel HD (1993) Traffic accident induced thoracic outlet syndrome: decompression without rib resection, correction of associated recurrent thoracic aneurysm. Int Surg 78:25–27
Remy-Jardin M, Doyen J, Remy J, Artaud D, Fribourg M, Duhamel A (1997) Functional anatomy of the thoracic outlet: evaluation with spiral CT. Radiology 205(3):843–851
Richter M, Ferrari R, Otte D, Kuensebeck H-W, Blauth M, Krettek C (2004) Correlation of clinical findings, collision parameters, and psychological factors in the outcome of whiplash associated disorders. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 75:758–764
Romain M (2003) Le syndrome de la traversée cervico-thoraco-brachiale. Sauramps Médical, Montpellier
Roos DB (1976) Congenital anomalies associated with thoracic outlet syndrome. Anatomy, symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment. Am J Surg 132(6):771–778
Roos DB (1999) Thoracic outlet syndrome is underdiagnosed. Muscle Nerve 22:126–129
Sanders RJ, Jackson CG, Banchero N, Pearce WH (1990) Scalene muscle abnormalities in traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome. Am J Surg 159(2):231–236
Sanders RJ, Pearce WH (1989) The treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome: a comparison of different operations. J Vasc Surg 10:626–634
Sanders RJ, Haug CE (1991) Thoracic outlet syndrome. A common sequela of neck injuries. J.B. Lippincott Company, Philadelphia
Schenardi C (2005) Whiplash injury, TOS and double crush syndrome. Forensic medical aspects. Acta Neurochir Suppl 92:25–27
Schwartzman RJ (1991) Brachial plexus traction injuries. Hand Clin 7(3):547–556
Selmonosky CA, Byrd R, Blood C, Blanc JS (1981) Useful triad for diagnosing the cause of chest pain. South Med J 74(8):947–949
Seror P (2004) Medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve conduction study, a new tool to demonstrate mild lower brachial plexus lesions. A report of 16 cases. Clin Neurophysiol 115(10):2316–2322
Sheth RN, Belzberg AJ (2001) Diagnosis and treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome. Neurosurg Clin N Am 12(2):295–309
Shukla PC, Carlton FB Jr (1996) Diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome in the emergency department. South Med J 89(2):212–217
Slipman CW, Chow DW (2001) Whiplash. Hanley & Belfus Medical Publishers, Philadelphia
Snaith RP (2003) The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale. Health Qual Life Outcomes 1:29
Spitzer WO, Skovron ML, Salmi LR (1995) Scientific monograph of the Quebec Task Force on Whiplash-Associated Disorders: redefining “whiplash” and its management. Spine 20:1S–73S
Sterling M, Jull G, Vicenzino B, Kenardy J, Darnell R (2005) Physical and psychological factors predict outcome following whiplash injury. Pain 114:141–148
Tender GC, Thomas AJ, Thomas N, Kline DG (2004) Gilliatt-Sumner hand revisited: a 25-year experience. Neurosurgery 55:883–890
Thomas J (1990) Road traffic accidents before and after seatbelt legislation: study in a district general hospital. J R Soc Med 83(2):79–81
Versteegen GJ, Kingma J, Meijler WJ, ten Duis HJ (2000) Neck sprain after motor vehicle accidents in drivers and passengers. Eur Spine J 9(6):547–552
Wilbourn AJ (1999) Thoracic outlet syndromes. Neurol Clin 17(3):477–497
Wilbourn AJ (1999) Thoracic outlet syndrome is overdiagnosed. Muscle Nerve 22:130–138
Wilbourn AJ, Lederman RJ (1984) Evidence of conduction delay in thoracic outlet syndrome is challenged. N Engl J Med 19(16):1052–1053
Wishchuk JR, Dougherty CR (2004) Therapy after thoracic outlet release. Hand Clin 20(1):87–90
Woods WW (1978) Thoracic outlet syndrome. West J Med 128:9–12
Conflict of interest
None.
Presentation at a conference
No.
Clinical trial registration number
Not applicable.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dubuisson, A., Lamotte, C., Foidart-Dessalle, M. et al. Post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome. Acta Neurochir 154, 517–526 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-011-1269-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00701-011-1269-x