This study examined the influence of positive imagery of everyday activities on attention using a visual probe task with concurrent eye tracking. Results showed that positive compared to neutral imagery increases self-reported behavioral motivation and biases the direction, but not the duration, of gaze on objects associated with the imagined activities. A post-hoc analysis revealed that the observed direction bias was more pronounced in individuals with greater depressive symptom severity. However, no evidence was found to suggest that the direction bias was related to subjective reports of behavioral motivation.
Imagining the positive emotional impact of performing an activity relative to a neutral circumstance of the activity shifted early attention, but not sustained attention, toward objects involved in the imagined activity. This is in line with Pool et al. (
2016), who showed that positive stimuli attract attention especially during the early stages of attentional processing. It has been suggested that this is because desired stimuli attract attention automatically without conscious awareness (Frankland et al.,
2016; Theeuwes,
2010; Theeuwes & Belopolsky,
2012). The lack of evidence for sustained attention on positively imagined objects, thus, could indicate that the positive imagery manipulation was not strong enough to influence a conscious evaluation of the stimuli at a later point in time. As predicted, however, positively imagined objects appear to have captured early attention due to an increase in positive value. This is in line with recent work suggesting that mental imagery can affect the evaluation of real-life environments (Benoit et al.,
2019; Paulus et al.,
2022). Paulus et al. (
2022), as mentioned previously, demonstrated that imagining an interaction with liked or disliked individuals at an initially neutral place changes a person’s attitude toward that place in the respective direction. This imagery-based evaluative conditioning (Hofmann et al.,
2010) could, thus, explain the present findings. The positive valence of emotions experienced during positive imagery (unconditioned stimulus) might have transferred to the simultaneously depicted objects (conditioned stimulus), thereby increasing their saliency during the subsequent visual probe task. Activities imagined in a positive compared to a neutral manner, indeed, were evaluated more positively by participants. They gave higher ratings of reward experienced during the positive imagery as well as higher ratings of anticipated reward and motivation to perform the activities. However, no evidence was found to suggest that these subjective reports were associated with the observed bias in initial orientation. It has been previously argued that early attention as opposed to sustained attention occurs independent of conscious awareness (Frankland et al.,
2016; Theeuwes,
2010; Theeuwes & Belopolsky,
2012). In keeping with this, self-report measures assessing the reflection of performance (explicit processing) and behavioral measures assessing performance itself (implicit processing) do not always correspond (Dang et al.,
2020). This could explain why behavioral motivation and early attention were not related in the present study. However, temporary goals have been argued to influence automatic attention processes (Vogt et al.,
2020). A recent meta-analytic review by Hardman et al. (
2021) further suggested that state motivation is a key determinant of attention bias for appetitive (food) stimuli. Contrary to this, in the present study, motivation was assessed specifically for each stimulus rather than as a general motivational state of the individual. Moreover, it is possible that the difference in inherent (food) versus acquired (objects associated with positive imagery) motivational value of stimuli might play an important role. It may also be that participants memorized objects imagined in a positive manner better than objects imagined in a neutral manner. Previous work, indeed, has shown a memory benefit for emotional compared to neutral material (Kensinger & Corkin,
2003). As reward associations can magnify the effect of memory on attention already in the early stages of perceptual processing (Doallo et al.,
2013), the observed shift in early attention could also be explained by a better memory of positively imagined objects. Although more research is needed to fully understand the lack of relation between behavioral motivation and early attention in this context, this study highlights the potential of positive imagery to increase behavioral motivation and shift early attention toward activities through an increase in positive value.
Directing attention using positive imagery may prove useful to motivate the engagement in adaptive behaviors. Indeed, enhancing the saliency of (monetary) rewards has been recently found to increase motivated behavior in an effort-based decision-making task (Renz et al.,
2021). Similarly, in real-life behavioral contexts, shifting early attention toward healthy food and lifestyle choices has been found to positively influence motivational approach (Suri & Gross,
2015). This is particularly interesting in light of clinical interventions aiming to promote behavioral activation. Here, positive imagery has been proposed as a
motivational amplifier addressing reward anticipation deficits in depression (Renner et al.,
2019,
2021). Previous research has suggested that these deficits in reward anticipation are the primary factor for reduced reward-motivated behavior (Bakker et al.,
2017; Gorka et al.,
2014; Sherdell et al.,
2012). Moreover, depression has been associated with difficulties in the prioritization of environmental stimuli (Whitton et al.,
2015). By shifting early attention toward environmental stimuli predictive of reward, positive imagery, thus, may be well suited to target these deficits in depression. Indeed, in the present study, individuals with greater depressive symptom severity were more susceptible to the positive imagery manipulation and showed a more pronounced shift in early attention. This further signifies the applicability of positive imagery in the context of depression.