Abstract
Human movement analysis using stereophotogrammetry is based on the reconstruction of the instantaneous laboratory position of selected bony anatomical landmarks (AL). For this purpose, knowledge of an AL's position in relevant bone-embedded frames is required. Because ALs are not points but relatively large and curved areas, their identification by palpation or other means is subject to both intra- and inter-examiner variability. In addition, the local position of ALs, as reconstructed using anad hoc experimental procedure (AL calibration), is affected by photogrammetric errors. The intra- and inter-examiner precision with which local positions of pelvis and lower limb palpable bony ALs can be identified and reconstructed were experimentally assessed. Six examiners and two subjects participated in the study. Intra- and inter-examiner precision (RMS distance from the mean position) resulted in the range 6–21 mm and 13–25 mm, respectively. Propagation of the imprecision of ALs to the orientation of bone-embedded anatomical frames and to hip, knee and ankle joint angles was assessed. Results showed that this imprecision may cause distortion in joint angle against time functions to the extent that information relative to angular movements in the range of 10 degrees or lower may be concealed. Bone geometry parameters estimated using the same data showed that the relevant precision does not allow for reliable bone geometry description. These findings, together with those relative to skin movement artefacts reported elswhere, assist the human movement analyst's consciousness of the possible limitations involved in 3D movement analysis using stereophotogrammetry and call for improvements of the relevant experimental protocols.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Backman, S. (1957): ‘The proximal end of the femur’,Acta Radiol., suppl. vol. 146
Bell, A. L., Petersen, D. R., andBrand, R. A. (1990): ‘A comparison of the accuracy of several hip center location prediction methods’,J. Biomech.,23, pp. 617–621
Benedetti, M. G., Cappozzo, A., Catani, F., andLeardini, A. (1991): ‘Anatomical Landmark Definition and Identification’,CAMARC II Internal Report, March 15, 1994
Borghese, N. A., andFerrigno, G. (1990): ‘An algorithm for 3-D automatic movement detection by means of standard TV cameras’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,37, pp. 1221–1225
Cappello, A., Cappozzo, A., La Palombara, P. F., Lucchetti, L., andLeardini, A. (1997): ‘Multiple anatomical landmark calibration for optimal bone pose estimation’,Hum. Mov. Sci.,16, pp. 259–274
Cappozzo, A. (1984): ‘Gait analysis methodology’,Hum. Mov. Sci.,3, pp. 27–54
Cappozzo, A., Catani, F., Della Croce, U., andLeardini, A. (1995): ‘Position and orientation of bones during movement: anatomical frame definition and determination’,Clin. Biomech.,10, pp. 171–178
Cappozzo, A., Catani, F., Leardini, A., Benedetti, M. G., andDella Croce, U. (1996): ‘Position and orientation of bones during movement: experimental artefacts’,Clin. Biomech.,11, pp. 90–100
Cappozzo, A., Cappello, A., Della Croce, U., andPensalfini, F. (1997): ‘Surface-marker cluster design criteria for 3-D bone movement reconstruction’,IEEE Trans. Biom. Eng.,44, pp. 1165–1174
Challis, J. H. (1995): ‘A procedure for determining rigid body transformation parameters’,J. Biomech.,28, pp. 733–737
Cheze, L., Fregly, B.J., andDimnet, J. (1995): ‘A solidification procedure to facilitate kinematic analysis based on video system data’,J. Biomech.,28, pp. 879–884
De Luzio, K. J., Wyss, U. P., Li, J., andCostigan, P. A. (1993): ‘A procedure to validate three-dimensional motion assessment systems’,J. Biomech.,26, pp. 753–759
Ehara, Y., Fujimoto, H., Miyazaki, S., Tanaka, S., andYamamoto, S. (1995): ‘Comparison of the performance of 3D camera systems’,Gait & Posture,3, pp. 166–169
Fioretti, S., Cappozzo, A., andLucchetti, L. (1997): ‘Joint kinematics’,in Allard, P., Cappozzo, A., Lundberg, A., andVaughan, C. (Eds.), Three dimensional analysis of human locomotion (John Wiley, Chichester) pp. 173–189
Fuller, J., Liu, L.-J., Murphy, M. C., andMann, R. W. (1997): ‘A comparison af lower-extremity skeletal kinematics measured using skin-and pin-mounted markers’,Hum. Mov. Sci.,16, pp. 219–242
Grood, E. S., andSuntay, W. J. (1983): ‘A joint coordinate system for the clinical description of three-dimensional motions: application to the knee’,Trans. ASME, J. Biomech. Eng.,105, pp. 136–144
Kadaba, M. P., Ramakrishnan, H. K., andWootten, M. E. (1990): ‘Measurement of lower extremity kinematics during level walking’,J. Orthop. Res.,8, pp. 383–392
Morris, J. R. W., andMacleod, A. (1990): ‘An investigation of the sources and characteristics of noise in a video-based kinematic measurement system’,in CAMARC II Internal Report: ‘Models, connections with experimental apparatus and relevant DSP techniques for functional movement analysis’
Pennock, G. R., andClark, K. J. (1990): ‘On anatomy-based coordinate system for the description of the kinematic displacements in the human knee’,J. Biomech.,23, pp. 1209–1218
Ramakrishnan, H. K., andKadaba, M. P. (1991): ‘On the estimation of joint kinematics during gait’,J. Biomech.,24, pp. 969–977
Reinschmidt, C., Van Den Bogert, A. J., Lundberg, A., Nigg, B. M., Murphy, N., Stacoff, A., andStano, A. (1997): ‘Tibiofemoral and tibiocalcaneal motion during walking: external vs. skeletal markers’,Gait & Posture,6, pp. 98–109
Small, C. F., Pichora, D. R., Bryant, J. T., andGriffiths, P. M. (1993): ‘Precision and accuracy of bone landmarks in characterising hand and wrist position,’J. Biomed. Eng.,15, pp. 371–378
Söderkvist, I., Wedin, P. A. (1993): ‘Determining the movements of the skeleton using well-configured markers’,J. Biomech.,13, pp. 1473–1477
Spoor, C. W., andVeldpaus, F. E. (1980): ‘Rigid body motion calculated from spatial coordinates of markers’,J. Biomech.,13, pp. 391–393
Steindler, A. (1955): ‘Kinesiology of the Human Body under Normal and Pathological Conditions’ (Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, IL)
Veldpaus, F. E., Woltring, H. J., andDortmans, L. J. M. G. (1988): ‘A least-squares algorithm for the equiform transformation from spatial marker coordinates’,J. Biomech.,21, pp. 45–54
White, S. C., Yack, H. J., andWinter, D. A. (1989): ‘A three-dimensional musculo-skeletal model for gait analysis, anatomical variability estimates’,J. Biomech.,22, pp. 885–893
Woltring, H. J. (1994): ‘3-D attitude representation of human joints: a standardisation proposal’,J. Biomech.,27, pp. 1399–1414
Woltring, H. J., andFioretti, S. (1989): ‘Representation and photogrammetric calculation of 3-D joint movement’in Proceedings of First I.O.C. World Congress on Sport Science, pp. 350–351, US Olympic Committee, Colorado Springs, USA
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Della Croce, U., Cappozzo, A. & Kerrigan, D.C. Pelvis and lower limb anatomical landmark calibration precision and its propagation to bone geometry and joint angles. Med. Biol. Eng. Comput. 37, 155–161 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02513282
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02513282